In highly vaccinated Korea, mandates are fueling a backlash
Korea’s new policy requiring people to be completely vaccinated or cleared in tests to enter public places is stirring up a wave of protests and court challenges.
On Saturday civic groups and local community organizations marched from Seoul Station to Gwanghwamun Square demanding that the compulsory vaccine-or-testing policy be scrapped. The Saturday rally, among the firsts of many that is being planned, follows a series of legal battles facing the government over the mandate, with one reaching the Constitutional Court last month.
Last week, a Seoul court temporarily blocked the use of vaccine passes at educational facilities, citing potential infringements of constitutional rights to education and other freedoms. This marks the first time in the past two years that the judiciary has put a brake on the government’s COVID-19 rules.
In other places, including cafes, restaurants and libraries, the mandate remains in full force while they await a verdict from the court, expected to be given in two to three weeks.
Starting Monday, large malls and grocery stores will require people to provide proof of being fully vaccinated within the last six months or a negative PCR test result that is less than 48 hours old. For the first “trial” week no penalties will be imposed on those that fail to comply. After that, first-time offenders can face a fine of up to 1.5 million won ($1,263) and other administrative penalties.
During the first court showdown on Friday in a Seoul administrative court, the judges questioned the validity of extending the pass system to low-risk, essential places while health officials maintained it was necessary to control the pandemic.
Asked what public good the passes achieved, Son Young-rae, the Ministry of Health and Welfare spokesperson, appearing as a defendant, told the judges that vaccine passes would provide relief to struggling intensive care rooms at hospitals.
“The spirit of the COVID-19 pass is to shield the unvaccinated and keep hospitals from breaking,” he said. He said unvaccinated adults -- just 6 percent of the entire adult population -- were making up about a third of all cases, and more than half of all hospital admissions and deaths.
Saying that large proportions of critical care resources were going into treating unvaccinated patients, he argued that “the fewer unvaccinated patients there are, the less burdened our hospitals are going to be.”
Son said vaccine passes were “more efficient at controlling COVID-19 than social distancing.” Since the passes were introduced in early December, cases have started to fall, he said.
“If the controversy stops the passes from being used in more places, it will take us longer to contain the surge, which means that we will have to keep restrictive measures in place for that much longer,” he said.
Health experts both within or working with the government say they have qualms about courts having the ultimate say in COVID-19 response measures.
Dr. Lee Jacob, infectious disease specialist who is on the advisory panel providing advice to the government on its return to normal strategy, said, “The court now has the final authority on COVID-19 policies. Any policy met by similar public protests will be subject to review by the court.”
Dr. Jung Jae-hun, a COVID-19 adviser to the prime minister, said although the court’s decision should be respected, some of its reasoning “lacked scientific, medical understanding.”
For one thing, the court was “evidently wrong to say that the unvaccinated are ‘not at a significantly higher risk of spreading COVID-19’ than the vaccinated,” he said.
Other health experts say the expansive mandates are doing more harm than good.
Infectious disease professor Dr. Kim Woo-joo of Korea University worried that the enforcement of sweeping mandates is producing a “rise of more vocal vaccine naysayers.” He said the controversy surrounding the mandates was “emboldening vaccine skeptics into discrediting the vaccination campaign.”
To counter hesitancy, the government should engage in a transparent and responsible risk communication, he said.
On Son’s claims that the surge has stabilized since the implementation of the pass policy, Kim said, “It’s not accurate to attribute the slowdown in infections in the last few weeks to vaccine passes. Over the period, booster vaccination rates in older adults have gone up and more intensive social distancing was reinstituted.”
Dr. Paik Soon-young, an emeritus professor of microbiology at Catholic University of Korea’s College of Medicine, agreed that, “Koreans have responded with an incredible enthusiasm to the vaccine campaign. Blaming the unvaccinated for crowding hospitals will only end up dividing the country.”
He said, “Mandates of similar nature have been adopted elsewhere in the world with an aim of encouraging people to get the shot. On the other hand, as far as adult vaccinations go, Korea is as vaccinated as it can be. So why fix something that isn’t broken?”
Barring unvaccinated people from visiting grocery stores, shopping centers and other common places where face masks can be worn is “minimally helpful” in stemming the spread, he said. “Most dangerous places are where people take masks off and dine together.”
He went on, “In the early days, Korea used to pride itself on getting the pandemic under control without sacrificing personal freedoms. But with the latest mandate, I worry that we’re straying farther from that direction.”
By Kim Arin (arin@heraldcorp.com)
(责任编辑:资讯)
相关内容
- Campbell highlights Washington Declaration amid security concerns over Putin
- How to preorder the PlayStation Portal Remote Player
- 7 Graves Devoted to Food Pioneers
- Alito’s Hobby Lobby leak: The real problem with SCOTUS ethics rules right now.
- Spate of defections show Kim Jong
- Black Friday GPU Buying Guide: November GPU Pricing Update
- Tesla Cybertruck is here: 7 key new things we learned
- Schools brace for impact of record
- “一把手”晒承诺 必须掷地有声踏石留印
- 让法治建设成效更加可感可及
- Best Garmin deal: Garmin Instinct 2S watch on sale for $199.99 at Amazon
- iPhone 16: Rumored AI
- How to turn off touch screen on Chromebook
推荐文章
-
市民填写献血相关表格8月22日晚,雨城区正黄时代天街广场天桥旁停靠着一辆献血车,身穿红马甲的志愿者们正向路过的市民发放无偿献血宣传手册,不少市民停下脚步,参与无偿献血。这是雅安市中心血站开启夜间献血模 ...[详细]
-
Rural development expert nominated as agriculture minister
Agriculture Minister nominee Song Mi-ryung (Yonhap)Song Mi-ryung, former deputy director of the Kore ...[详细] -
How to watch UCLA vs. Villanova basketball without cable: game time, streaming deals, and more
Wondering how to watch college basketball this season? Here are your best options:Best for affordabi ...[详细] -
Schools brace for impact of record
A picture taken on Feb. 30 shows an empty sixth-grade classroom at Namsung Elementary School in Poha ...[详细] -
Hannah Gais ,July 16, 2024 To Russia, with ...[详细]
-
Warmer winter temperatures expected this week
Passersby walk in winter jackets at Gwanghwamun Square in Seoul on Nov. 20. (Yonhap)Temperatures are ...[详细] -
Alito’s Hobby Lobby leak: The real problem with SCOTUS ethics rules right now.
Supreme Court justices? They’re just like you and me.That’s about the sum of the public defense moun ...[详细] -
Herschel Walker and Raphael Warnock: How Georgia's runoff election defines the 2022 midterms.
One could write a thorough history of American politics from 2020 to 2022 through the prism of Georg ...[详细] -
Best Home Depot Labor Day sale deals
Labor Day weekend is almost here, and retailers like Home Depot have already rolled out their Labor ...[详细] -
Trilateral cooperation with S. Korea, Japan most important to US: State Dept.
Department of State press secretary Ned Price is seen answering questions during a press briefing at ...[详细]
热点阅读
随机内容
- Best Labor Day mattress deals in 2024
- Tesla Cybertruck is here: 7 key new things we learned
- Rune ‘super
- Best mesh Wifi router deals: Get eero mesh WiFi routers up to 40% off
- Klarna CEO reveals plan to reduce workforce by 50% and replace it with AI
- Our Favorite Newly Added Places Across Africa
- N. Korea closes 7 embassies, now down to 46, says Seoul