The arrest of two men at a Philadelphia Starbucks shows how deeply raced our public spaces can be.
Philadelphia is a city in which 43 percent of residents are black. The Philadelphia Starbucks where two black men were arrested last Thursday, however, is located in a zip code that is 79 percent white and just 6 percent black. In all likelihood, most of the clientele there is white, which, to borrow from sociologist Elijah Anderson, makes this particular location a “white space,” or an area whose “most visible and distinctive feature is [the] overwhelming presence of white people and [the] absence of black people.”
This may explain why a Starbucks staff member called the police while the two men were waiting on a business associate. The employee says the men were trespassing and refused to leave the restaurant. Video of the incident—taken by a bystander—shows them standing like any potential customers. That same footage shows their business associate arrive as they are arrested. He is white.
Race is about power and hierarchy. When one is “raced,” one is placed in relationship to that hierarchy—your position assigned to your body and made visible to the world. Places, too, can be raced. Spaces of affluence and exclusivity are typically associated with white faces, reflecting racial distributions of wealth and power. Films like Get Outtake that association as a given, a conceit the filmmaker doesn’t even have to explain to the audience. There are “black spaces,” too. In a paper titled “The Iconic Ghetto,” Anderson details the tight association between public housing projects and the black poor, a connection so strong that it’s become part of the overall racial stigma against blacks—a singular black pathology that supposedly explains the material conditions of those projects. Blacks, in this view, come from the ghetto and they carry the ghetto with them, representing its putative danger, crime, and poverty.
Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementTo many white Americans, this marks blacks as an inherent threat to the order and safety of their spaces. As Anderson writes, “When the anonymous black person enters the white space, others there immediately try to make sense of him or her—to figure out ‘who that is,’ or to gain a sense of the nature of the person’s business and whether they need to be concerned.”
In these situations, black Americans face heightened scrutiny. This might mean racial profiling, as when shoppers are followed and questioned in retail stores. In 2013, according to the Pew Research Center, 44 percent of black Americans reported such treatment. It might mean unjustified contact with law enforcement. In Pulled Over: How Police Stops Define Race and Citizenship,authors Charles Epp, Steven Maynard-Moody, and Donald Haider-Markel find that suburban and exurban police are much more likely to stop black drivers for intrusive stops; white drivers are rarely stopped for such purposes.
AdvertisementOr it may mean violence. In mid-century Detroit, white mobs attacked and occasionally torched the homes of black people who moved in—or even near—all-white enclaves. In 1986, 23-year-old Michael Griffith died while fleeing a group of white men wielding baseball bats. His offense? Walking through Howard Beach, a largely white neighborhood of Queens, New York. And just last week, 14-year-old Brennan Walker was shot at after knocking on a door in the predominantly white Rochester Hills, Michigan. He was walking to school and had stopped to ask for directions.
AdvertisementNothing so dire happened for the men of the Philadelphia Starbucks. Philadelphia Police Commissioner Richard Ross, who is also black, says the officers who arrested the two men behaved appropriately. “The police did not just happen upon this event—they did not just walk into Starbucks to get a coffee,” he said in a video posted to Facebook. “They were called there, for a service, and that service had to do with quelling a disturbance, a disturbance that had to do with trespassing. These officers did absolutely nothing wrong.”
Advertisement AdvertisementThe commissioner isn’t wrong about the scope of police authority in this situation. Once called to Starbucks, officers had every right to make an arrest and remove the men from the property. They were released from custody, and company CEO Kevin Johnson issued an apology. The police are conducting an internal investigation of the arrests. What’s critical is that this isn’t an isolated occurrence. Black Americans across class, gender, and other social lines have similar stories of hostile examination, or worse, when they find themselves in a “white space.”
Everyone, eventually, finds themselves out of place. But it’s only some people—raced people—who have to move with particular care through unfamiliar spaces, lest they bring ruinous scrutiny on themselves. And too often, even that caution is not enough.
Tweet Share Share Comment(责任编辑:资讯)
- Pragmocracy Now
- Amazon's proposed federal anti
- Dolly Parton just absolutely smashed a 'Jolene' version of the distracted boyfriend meme
- What 5G? Samsung is already working on 6G
- 让法治建设成效更加可感可及
- Tesla reveals Cybertruck has sold more than DeLorean
- ZenGo crypto wallet changes the game by being dead simple to use
- 'Truth isn't truth': Giuliani perfectly sums up 2018
- 市征搬办人口认定组累计完成初步人口登记达619户2759人
- Scientists detect water sloshing on Mars. There could be a lot.
- 'PUBG' players arrested in India for playing game on their phones
- A crocodile was spotted using a pool noodle in Florida
- Trump keeps calling Mueller probe a “witch hunt.” How did actual witch hunts work?
-
改造提升后的景观节点本报讯8月23日,记者再次来到芦山县飞仙关4A级景区旅游基础设施建设项目施工现场,与两个月前相比,这里的变化十分明显。芦山县飞仙关4A级景区旅游基础设施建设项目共有两个标段,建设内 ...[详细]
-
Reed details 'dark space' fighting double pneumonia
WASHINGTON:Patrick Reed described his frightening fight with bilateral pneumonia on Thursday, saying ...[详细] -
Apple fans lose their sh*t for an Apple Watch tip calculator
It's the feature that everyone's dad has been waiting for. At today's WWDC in San Jose, California, ...[详细] -
Theresa May is going to dance, whether the internet likes it or not
Look, it could just be the stress of having to figure out the Irish border post-Brexit, or the risk ...[详细] -
Elon Musk's AI facility is reportedly operating gas turbines without a permit
Elon Musk's AI company has caught the attention of environmentalists in Memphis, Tennessee for repor ...[详细] -
Democrats should be talking even more about Trump.
On Monday, Democrats unveiled an anti-corruption message meant to highlight the kinds of graft and s ...[详细] -
North Korea's newspaper urges people to prioritize socialist ideology
In this photo July 28 file photo released by North Korea's official Korean Central News Agency, peop ...[详细] -
This photo, provided by his side, shows Gyeonggi Gov. Lee Jae-myung announcing his bid to run in the ...[详细]
-
Update your BIOS: Utilities from Top Motherboard Makers
PSA:Enthusiasts building their own PCs are accustomed to keeping up with latest drivers, especially ...[详细] -
How one woman learned that her grandpa had become a meme
At any moment in time, whether you want it to happen or not, someone could take a photo of you, post ...[详细]
Google is bringing AI summaries to ‘Files’ so you can find your docs quicker
Apple's watchOS 6 getting its own App Store and new health apps
- How much will PCB's Champions Cup mentors be paid?
- Xi, Putin vow efforts to advance relations with North Korea
- Moon's proposal to end Korean War faces feasibility questions
- Democrats should be talking even more about Trump.
- Flying spaghetti monster and unworldly life filmed in deep sea footage
- The wildest VMA outfits on the pink carpet
- Moon's proposal to end Korean War faces feasibility questions