Facebook finally appoints members to its Oversight Board, but will it really matter?
A Yemeni Nobel Peace Prize laureate who organized protests during the Arab Spring. The Vice President of the conservative Cato Institute who wrote a book titled "The Struggle to Limit Government." The former editor-in-chief of The Guardian when it was breaking news on the Edward Snowden’s leaked NSA documents.
What do the three people described here -- Tawakkol Karman, John Samples, and Alan Rusbridger -- have in common? They’re all members of Facebook’s new Oversight Board, often referred to as the platform’s “Supreme Court.”
On Wednesday, Facebookfinally unveiledthe first 20 people who will serve on the long-awaited Oversight Board. The independent board will rule over cases regarding content issues on the social network.
Since Facebook first made its plans for the independent Oversight Board public in 2018, the company had promised diversity among its members. Judging by that metric, CEO Mark Zuckerberg has lived up to the promise in a multitude of ways from gender and race to ideological diversity.
The 20 announcedmembers make up half of what will be a 40-person board. Half of those announced today are male, half are female. Collectively, the members of the board have lived in more than 27 countries and speak at least 29 different languages.
So far, the United States has the most representation on the board, with at least five members. The rest of the board spans the globe, with no other country currently having more than one representative on the board.
Daily content decisions will still be made by Facebook. The Oversight Board’s role, at least for now, is to make rulings on cases where specific content is removed from Facebook or Instagram. While it won’t be writing policy, these individual decisions from the board can certainly help shape it and provide guidance.
But, the biggest issue with the Oversight Board, however well-intentioned or diverse its membership is, is how limited in scope its powers over the social media giant are.
Yes, the Oversight Board has the ability to overrule even CEO Zuckerberg. Indeed, the board is its own independent corporate identity. The Oversight Board’s funding, however, comes from Facebook. In fact, the company itself chose the four co-chairs who in turn appoint the members of the board.
In addition, just because Zuckerberg can’t outright smack down a ruling, it doesn’t mean Facebook won’t have the final say.
Written out in the board’s own charter is a line that certainly gives Facebook carte blanche to opt out of practically any decision. Facebook says it will take action based on the Oversight Board’s decisions based on whether it’s “technically and operationally feasible.”
That’s fairly open and vague. It's also a pretty slick way of saying that none of what the Oversight Board rules is binding. If a decision from the board fundamentally changes the way an integral feature on Facebook works for the greater good, but it affects the company’s bottom line, does this wording give Facebook an out? Seems like it.
As NBC Newsalso points out, for a platform that has been criticizedfor its weak policieson misinformationand fake news, not a single person of the 20 announced on the board so far has a prominent background in disinformation.
With both the potential good and bad aspects of the Oversight Board laid out, it's far too early to deem it a failure or success. The board is expected to begin overseeing cases this summer. Then, we’ll see how this plays out.
(责任编辑:产品中心)
- Value Judgment
- NK creates new holiday to mark ICBM test launch
- Trump campaign gets in Twitter trouble again with Photoshopped poll image
- Samsung will replace more than 2.5 million Galaxy Note7 devices
- Military prosecutors indict intel official over leaking 'black agent' info
- 11 Telescopes Exploring The Magic of Space
- Upsets in Olympic pool as Japan, Tunisia strike gold
- North Korean art sells in China despite UN sanctions over nuclear program
- #DeleteUber campaign inspired 500,000 to delete accounts in one week: NYTimes
- New image shows the North Star is changing. And it has spots.
- Parent gives brutally honest excuse for tardy kids
- S. Korea to develop indigenous missile for light
- 累计筹款2.96亿!广东恤孤助学会成立二十年资助孤贫学生38808人
-
NYT mini crossword answers for August 29
The Mini is a bite-sized version of The New York Times' revered daily crossword. While the crossword ...[详细] -
S. Korea to develop indigenous missile for light
South Korea's arms procurement agency said Tuesday it has decided to develop a guided missile for li ...[详细] -
NK restores DMZ guard posts after ending military pact
North Korean soldiers are spotted near a guard post in the Demilitarized Zone separating the two Kor ...[详细] -
美味不止荔枝!化橘红、拖罗饼等化州味道亮相第八届中国荔枝龙眼产业大会
美味不止荔枝!化橘红、拖罗饼等化州味道亮相第八届中国荔枝龙眼产业大会_南方+_南方plus5月20日,由农业农村部南亚热带作物中心、国家荔枝龙眼产业技术体系共同主办的第八届中国荔枝龙眼产业大会在茂名高 ...[详细] -
Carbon neutrality law violates basic rights: Constitutional Court
South Korea's carbon neutrality law does not conform with the Constitution because the absence ...[详细] -
NPAD reform panel struggles to set sail
The main opposition party on Friday officially proposed a former top Gyeonggi Province educator to h ...[详细] -
Newborn calf looks suspiciously like KISS frontman Gene Simmons
Moooove on over, Gene Simmons. A newborn calf is ready to take your place in the spotlight.Genie, a ...[详细] -
Djokovic loses Tokyo 2020 bronze
TOKYO:Novak Djokovic hurled his racquet into the empty stands and smashed another on a net post as h ...[详细] -
近日,我市气温持续居高不下。气象学上,气温在35℃及以上时可称为“高温天气”。如果连续三天最高气温都超过35℃时,即可称作“高温热浪”天气。高温天气下,运动员、户外工作者、老年人、婴幼儿等都是容易中暑 ...[详细]
-
Everton captain Coleman signs new deal until 2023
LONDON:Everton captain Seamus Coleman has signed a new deal that ties him to the club until 2023, th ...[详细]