Magic Leap vs. Microsoft HoloLens: Which is the better AR experience?
I first tried out Microsoft HoloLens a few years ago, a few months before its launch as a developer tool, and came away with similar impressions that many tech journalists had at the time: the tech was intriguing and impressive in some ways, but its limited field of view diminished the experience considerably.
I’ve used HoloLens a few times since then at demos and events, and although there have been improvements, they haven’t changed fundamental experience — or its limitations.
SEE ALSO:Apple takes a step towards its own version of Google GlassMagic Leap, which launched its developer hardware in August, provoked similar reactions. Although the product is different from HoloLens in many ways — it’s more steampunk goggles than futuristic visor, and you need to carry around a small hockey-puck computer to make it work — most people who had hands-on time with the device had similar observations: Here was a very promising augmented-reality experience that also suffers from field-of-view limitations and a lack of compelling software (although the latter criticism may have changed on Wednesday, with the release of a Magic Leap version of Angry Birds).
But if you were to conclude from those general impressions that the two devices provide near-identical experiences, you’d be mistaken. There are clear differences between the two, rooted in each company's approach to augmented reality, the specific problems they’re trying to solve, and even the respective company cultures. Magic Leap also had the benefit of being able to act after HoloLens, learning from early criticisms of that device.
I recently got a chance not just to try out Magic Leap and HoloLens, but to do so back to back— a rare treat for expensive developer hardware made by competing companies. Thanks to a gathering of virtual- and augmented-reality storytellers arranged by StoryUp, a startup that helps produce immersive content, and the Reynolds Journalism Institute at the University of Missouri, I was able to use both products extensively. The exposure to both headsets in the same time and place gave me strong impressions of what each product is — and isn’t — good at.
Leaps and Lenses
This was my first exposure to the Magic Leap One. Most AR/VR headsets require a certain amount of precision when putting them on, but that goes double for Magic Leap since it requires that you carry around the tiny computer, called a Lightpack, that powers the experience. That means you have to remember to sling it around your shoulder beforedonning the goggles. You also need to make sure the supports in back are more on the top of your head than lower on your skull, which is a bit counterintuitive.
Magic Leap is more of a chore to put on than HoloLens, but it's slightly more comfortable to actually wear.Credit: Pete Pachal/MashableHoloLens isn’t much better in this department, but it’s better. Microsoft’s headset is a single, standalone unit, so there’s no purse computer. However, it’s also a bit weird in how it fits on your head: The visor connects to a headband via a hinge, and you’re often left wondering if you’ve put it on right once you’ve slipped it on and raised the visor back up. Still, I prefer Microsoft’s crank for tightening the headset on your head to Magic Leap’s traditional straps, but will admit the crank might feel weird for novice users.
Where Magic Leap surprised me the most was its field of view. Yes, it’s limited — the virtual images are confined to a rectangular zone right in front of you – but it’s not nearly as limited as HoloLens. There's no official spec for field of view, but some have pegged the vertical FoV at almost double that of HoloLens.
Smart hardware and software choices help, too. My first experience with Magic Leap was a demo “world,” where various patterns that resemble marine life appeared all around me, changing seemingly at random. When I reached out to touch the images, they’d react in different ways: seaweed-like tendrils would bend to my hand movements, and a jellyfish-like ball would rapidly spin and implode when I tried to grab it.
Magic Leap’s goggles do appear to cut off more peripheral vision than HoloLens. While that sounds bad, it also means the ratio of non-augmented space to augmented space in your gaze goes up, so naturally it feels more immersive. Whatever the reason, I was not immediately struck, and subsequently frustrated, by how limited the “magic” window was on Magic Leap.
By contrast, HoloLens keeps reminding you of what you're missing. After putting on the $3,000 headset, I took a look around the kitchen I was standing in and saw it was populated with several holograms, including very precise renderings of ballerinas, weightlifters, and breakdancers. But as I moved my head to check them out, parts of the holograms would get cut off as they moved out of the holographic part of the display.
This is the most annoying thing about HoloLens. When something interests you visually, you have a natural inclination to move closer so you can see it better. But instead of rewarding you, HoloLens’ limited field of view will cut off parts of the object you’re looking at, preventing you from taking it in fully. The closer you get, the more it takes you out of the experience.
A winner materializes
I didn’t experience the same level of frustration with Magic Leap. The software is a big part of this; most of the virtual objects I interacted with weren’t particularly large, so there was less chance of them being cut off.
The objects also tended to have a more ethereal quality to them, which does a lot to manage expectations: it’s less weird to see something ghostly start to disappear. By contrast, Microsoft’s very solid-looking holograms always looked strange when heads, feet, or arms were cut off.
That said, I have to concede realistic holograms are more of a point for Microsoft than against. The goal of HoloLens is to mix virtual objects with the real world, but in a way where the viewer sees and treats those objects as if they were real. And it succeeds: The holograms are almost always crisp and clear to the eye. I tried a couple of different apps on Magic Leap, but the virtual objects never felt quite as present.
So yes, HoloLens has a certain rigidity that the Magic Leap didn't match, but it wasn't always an advantage. The hand gestures that you use to manipulate the holograms need to be very precise, and those interactions often call up icons and menus in 3D space. In general, it feels like the experience was designed by engineers — it seems Microsoft can’t help but be Microsoft, even when it’s innovating.
I found using Magic Leap to be a much more natural experience. The only menu I really used was the main one that you call up with the remote. Otherwise I mostly just used my hands to goof around with things, walking through virtual environments, like a volcano-ravaged Guatemalan village in an AR experience created by The New York Times. At one point the headset got confused when it couldn’t figure out exactly where I went in the room when I moved from an open area to a tight space, but mostly it did a better job of creating an AR-enhanced environment than HoloLens.
Back in HoloLensCredit: Pete Pachal/MashableIf you’re getting the sense there’s a winner here, you’re right. Again, Magic Leap had the advantage of taking its time — thanks in part to an absurd amount of venture funding — and addressing early concerns of AR, so it's not an even playing field. But there are also some some fundamental differences in approach that help, too.
With its traditional dialog boxes, desktop-like iconography, and need for precise gestures, HoloLens feels much more like a developer tool. Microsoft has told a confusing story around HoloLens — at various points in its lifetime it’s been touted as a consumer, gaming, and enterprise device – which has led to some paralysis in the experience. Without a software experience to walk you through things, it’s not intuitive to use.
Magic Leap, on the other hand, feels like a level up. The graphics don't look better, but, using it immediately after HoloLens, I felt like an artist who’d just been given a slightly bigger canvas and a much better paintbrush. Both platforms still need a killer app to make them worthwhile, but at least with Magic Leap you’re thinking more about what you can see and do than what you can’t.
Featured Video For You
The Lenovo Smart Display looks like a tablet and acts like one, too
TopicsAugmented RealityMicrosoftVirtual RealityInnovations
(责任编辑:新闻中心)
- Military prosecutors indict intel official over leaking 'black agent' info
- Sheryl Sandberg discussed 'Facebook lite' for kids in 2013, leaked messages show
- 好心司机拾金不昧 失主借助媒体表谢意
- 广东唯一!云浮罗平镇获评第三批全国农民体育健身活动基地
- US Open 2024 livestream: How to watch US Open tennis for free
- 特写|在农事定向大赛遇见和美乡村
- Twitter's about to introduce Topics. Here's how the new feature works
- Uber's new self
- Milan clubs face pursuers in race for top four
- U.S. Senators call on FTC to investigate the security of drivers' data
- Chronology of North Korea's missile, rocket launches
- Man Utd's UCL return clouded by ownership uncertainty
- 重达30斤,湛江金鲳海捕节头鱼拍出188888元!
-
Apple Intelligence is now a little easier to get outside the U.S.
Apple Intelligence is a little easier to try out if you're not in the U.S. Unfortunately, users in t ...[详细] -
雨天行车请放慢车速进入7月以来,我市迎来了几轮强降雨天气,导致我市一些低洼地带积水相对较深,不少车主雨中行车时由于速度过快,飞溅了行人一身水;有的车主因为大雨影响视线,驾车冲出了公路;还有的车主出现了 ...[详细]
-
China shuts out Korean cable TV channels over THAAD row: report
China has shut out all South Korean cable TV channels in the country in apparent retaliation against ...[详细] -
Surprising study shows how wind turbines can work better behind hills
Engineers go to great lengths to maximize the exposure of wind turbines, placing blades atop tall to ...[详细] -
[Online Predators] Deepfake pornography haunts S. Korea
(Getty Images Bank)Song, a 17-year-old high schooler based in Gyeonggi Province, used to be just lik ...[详细] -
More than a year and a half ago, Elaine Herzberg was struck and killed while walking her bicycle acr ...[详细]
-
喻佳丽在比赛中雅安日报讯15日晚,2011快乐女声全国总决赛第一场12进11拉开帷幕,一上场就被专业评委判令到PK台的雅女喻佳丽,通过两度PK,成功晋级全国11强。根据赛制,14日评委对每位选手进行小 ...[详细]
-
North Korea says it has achieved goal of becoming nuclear state
By Bahk Eun-jiNorth Korea says it has achieved its longtime goal of becoming a nuclear state with th ...[详细] -
Europe now has a huge AI gap, for better or for worse
When it comes to tech, Europe has been on a slightly separate track from the U.S. for a while, but t ...[详细] -
YouTube says it can delete accounts that aren't 'commercially viable'
YouTube’s new terms of service has some users and content creators very worried that the compa ...[详细]
- NYT mini crossword answers for August 29
- 'North Korea wants a peace'
- AirPods Pro and Android: Is it worth it?
- China deploys its dancing aunties on street corners to teach people about road safety
- Apple Watch 10 rumors: Everything we know so far
- Let's face it: Flying cars are never going to be a thing
- Crouser shatters own world record