The ad industry is still hilariously corrupt, report says
Ad agencies are using smoke-and-mirror tricks to drive up production costs on their clients' dime, according to a new report from an advertiser trade group.
The Association of National Advertisers, which reps big brands like Procter & Gamble, General Motors, and Walmart, found that advertising giants have been known to route lucrative contracts for production and post-production work on commercials to their own in-house shops. This is done through deceptive--and illegal--means like enlisting other agencies to rig the bidding process or disguising their ownership of the firms, the report claims.
SEE ALSO:Why American ad agencies are being accused of having secret agendasThe accusation adds to a growing sense among advertisers--i.e. the parties that foot the bill for all this clandestine maneuvering--that Madison Avenue is using shady business practices to run up their tabs.
It's also caught the attention of federal regulators. The Wall Street Journalreported in December that the Justice Department has opened a probe into these production schemes, which violate competition laws meant to keep markets on a level playing field.
Heading up the investigation is antitrust lawyer Rebecca Meiklejohn, who famously sent a handful of ad execs to jail for similar charges in 2004.
Suffice to say, these are some weighty allegations. But they're also not all that novel. Such dealings have long been something of an open secret in the industry, according to the report's author, ANA vice president Bill Duggan.
"We've been hearing rumblings of this activity for several years now," Duggan said. "It was a long road to get here, and by the time we got here, there was just a lot of evidence."
The study comes on the heels of another bombshell transparency report from the ANA last summer that outlined nebulous rebate schemes through which agencies collude with firms that buy ad placements and media companies in ways that aren't necessarily in the best interest of clients.
Duggan says the group first began collecting evidence on the production rigging while interviewing various industry professionals for that previous research. In addition to those primary sources, the most recent 30-page report is based on the testimonies of a dozen experts on various parts of industry sausage-making, all but one of whom agreed that yeah, transparency seems to be a pretty big problem (the last expert said he had only secondhand knowledge).
"Source after source--or rather...subject matter expert after subject matter expert--has suggested that these things have been going on," Duggan said.
The ANA declined to name any specific bad actors.
Over the past few decades, the global ad industry has been largely folded into six giant holding companies--a process that was expedited by the looming threat of Silicon Valley disruption.
Those behemoths now control firms operating at every level of the advertising assembly line--from creative shops to media buyers to production companies and, in some cases, even media outlets.
In the traditional way of doing things, these smaller companies are supposed to compete for each other's business in order to ensure the best deal for clients. But it's not hard to see how conglomerate entanglements might make for a conflict of interest.
That situation along with chaos caused by the industry's bumpy transition to a digital-first world have led to a situation where advertisers and agencies trust one another less than ever. Record numbers of marketers have put their agencies under review in the past couple years--a process in which an advertiser decides whether or not it wants to fire them. Agency-of-record deals, in which one firm handles all of a client's business are becoming increasingly rare.
Agency trade group 4A's came out in fierce opposition to the rebates report, but their reaction to the latest finding seemed a bit more muted. In a statement to Adweek, it simply said it “condemns any activity or business practice that is unethical or, of course, illegal.”
The group didn't immediately respond to a request for clarification.
Featured Video For You
Water droplets were animated in midair to create a life-sized human figure for an ad
(责任编辑:行业动态)
-
Flying spaghetti monster and unworldly life filmed in deep sea footage
Scientists discovered a giant underwater mountain. And it's teeming with deep sea life.An endeavor a ...[详细] -
9月17日晚,柯震东晒自拍照,并自侃道:“男孩与公狗!”照片中,柯震东身穿黑色背心,露出性感的手臂肌肉,他身后的大黑狗成功抢镜。照片曝光后,有网友留言道:“这次是秀 ...[详细]
-
解读|地域特征+产品特色+文化特质,三个“特”助力三水渔业高质量发展
解读|地域特征+产品特色+文化特质,三个“特”助力三水渔业高质量发展_南方+_南方plus前不久,佛山市三水区水产品区域公用品牌“鱼出三水”正式发布。三水名特优新水产品以肉质细、嫩、甘、鲜享誉市场,素 ...[详细] -
2辆违法占用消防通道的车辆被贴上“电子告知单”“电子告知单”消防通道是消防救援人员实施营救和被困人员疏散的通道,消防通道被占用,将会延误最佳救援时机,直接威胁到群众的生命财产安全。如何让“生命通道”随 ...[详细]
-
Alcaraz vs. Van de Zandschulp 2024 livestream: Watch US Open for free
TL;DR:Live stream Alcaraz vs. Van de Zandschulp in the 2024 US Open for free on 9Now or TVNZ+. Acces ...[详细] -
今天8时30分,备受瞩目的“科龙大战”将上演,张继科和马龙将争夺里约奥运会乒乓球男单金牌,这也是青岛籍运动员在本届奥运会上的首个夺金时刻。“科爸”点赞: ...[详细]
-
中国山东网青岛频道8月11日讯(记者 刘淑红) 8月10日晚,“炫动团岛湾 幸福八大峡”文化艺术节纳凉晚会在青岛市南区八大峡广场盛大开演。在清凉的海风吹拂下,来自八个社区的文艺 ...[详细]
-
今天8时30分,备受瞩目的“科龙大战”将上演,张继科和马龙将争夺里约奥运会乒乓球男单金牌,这也是青岛籍运动员在本届奥运会上的首个夺金时刻。“科爸”点赞: ...[详细]
-
Séamus Malekafzali ,July 23, 2024 Netanyah ...[详细]
-
鍏虫敞浜虹被鑱屽満鍋ュ悍锛氬垱鑱斿伐鍦哄彂甯冣€滆仈鍚堝姙鍏?.0鈥濅骇鍝乢涓浗灞变笢缃慱闈掑矝
銆€銆€涓浗灞变笢缃?2鏈?0鏃ヨ鏂板啝鑲虹値鐤儏鐨勫彂鐢燂紝鍌敓浜嗕竴绯诲垪绀句細娲诲姩鏂瑰紡鐨勮浆鍙橈紝璁稿浼佷笟瀵瑰姙鍏璧佺殑瑙傚康涔熷彂鐢熶簡鍙樺寲銆傛嵁鎴村痉姊佽鍙戝竷鐨勩€ ...[详细]