A prominent climate scientist just won a major court battle
In a legal first, a federal appeals court ruled on Thursday that a climate science researcher can proceed with defamation claims against writers who made false allegations about his scientific work.
The ruling by the Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia, found that a "reasonable jury" could find that two writers defamed Michael Mann -- known for the famous "hockey stick" graph showing that modern climate change is unprecedented in human history -- by making false claims about his work, and comparing him to a notorious child molester.
SEE ALSO:Climate scientist who got death threats says he fears more attacks under TrumpThe court found that two writers for the National Reviewand the Competitive Enterprise Institute, a conservative think tank, may have defamed Mann by comparing him to Penn State football coach Jerry Sandusky, who was convicted of molesting dozens of children in 2012.
Mann has been the subject of extraordinary criticism since his research was used as part of the foundation of a 2001 climate science report that found that human-caused emissions of greenhouse gases are the most likely cause of global warming.
Scientists at a rally in San Francisco on Dec. 13, 2016, protesting the incoming Trump administration.Credit: Marcio Jose Sanchez/APOther climate scientists have been subjected to similar criticism and even death threats over their work. The court's decision, which now allows Mann to proceed with a defamation case against CEI and the National Review, comes less than a month before the climate-denying Trump administration comes to power.
Employees from CEI, including Chris Horner, are on Trump's transition team for the EPA, raising concerns that harassment of climate scientists could become official government policy. Horner, for example, has spent years filing lawsuits against climate scientists, seeking email records and other information to prove allegations of research misconduct.
The case, which specifically concerns articles that appeared on the CEI website and in the conservative publication National Review, will now be remanded to a lower court for trial.
And the ruling may have wide-reaching implications.
The case may lay the groundwork for future lawsuits brought by climate scientists and scientists in other hotly contested fields who believe their reputations were damaged by press reports and even organized misinformation campaigns.
The opinion, written for the three judge panel by Senior Judge Vanessa Ruiz, states:
To the extent statements in appellants’ articles take issue with the soundness of Dr. Mann’s methodology and conclusions — i.e., with ideas in a scientific or political debate — they are protected by the First Amendment. But defamatory statements that are personal attacks on an individual’s honesty and integrity and assert or imply as fact that Dr. Mann engaged in professional misconduct and deceit to manufacture the results he desired, if false, do not enjoy constitutional protection and may be actionable.
The court's majority opinion also found that making statements to gain advantage in a "no-holds-barred debate over global warming" are typically protected under the First Amendment. However:
... If the statements assert or imply false facts that defame the individual, they do not find shelter under the First Amendment simply because they are embedded in a larger policy debate.
Mann said he is "pleased" with the decision, and looking forward to moving on to a jury trial.
"We are particularly pleased that the court, after performing an independent review of the evidence, found that the allegations against me have been 'definitively discredited,'" he said in a statement.
While the climate wars that flared up during the George W. Bush administration subsided under President Barack Obama, scientists are girding for battle again, now that President-elect Trump appointed climate deniers to lead each of the environment-related cabinet agencies.
Mann himself has warned of what is to come, writing an op-ed in the Washington Postlast week that he and his colleagues are now "bracing for a renewed onslaught of intimidation, from inside and outside government," given the coming changes in Washington.
"I fear the chill that could descend," he wrote.
Featured Video For You
This is the most alarming scientific information for 2016
(责任编辑:新闻中心)
- Apple Watch bands: 5 favorites to consider as Apple Watch 10 looms
- 毛不易亮相凤凰音乐节 叮嘱粉丝“头发压塌了 别拍照”
- 阵容强大!舞歌《梦在中国》暨尹建平作品视听会走进青岛港
- 100多位音乐人唱响“音乐之岛”
- Webb telescope just snapped image of huge black hole gobbling material
- Washington Mystics vs. Chicago Sky 2024 livestream: Watch live WNBA
- 抓项目 强基础 释放文旅产业新活力
- 青岛:水木年华携电影《一生有你》古城见证爱情
- 骞冲畨浜哄闈掑矝鍒嗗叕鍙革細涓惧姙2022骞村崐骞村害娉曞緥鍚堣鍛樺伐鎶€鑳芥彁鍗囧煿璁彮
- Sinner vs. Michelsen 2024 livestream: Watch US Open for free
- 中建交通建设集团山东公司召开2022年年中工作会
- 五城复赛即将同步启动│江苏卫视《中国有星宝》少儿才艺城市选拔大赛走进山东
- 农业农村部农村社会事业促进司司长唐珂:在潮州感受乡土文化独特魅力
-
World's first green ammonia plant is now open for business
Three Danish energy tech firms have flung open the doors to the first ever green ammonia plant in th ...[详细] -
中国山东网1月1日讯2020年1月1日上午,一场洋溢着新春气息和新年欢乐的快闪,演绎着一场从过去一年传递而来的时尚幸福,清新悦耳的演奏,深情悠扬的歌唱,给来往的人们带来了过年惊喜和感动。2020年1月 ...[详细]
-
暑假期间,青岛栈桥书店举行夜宿书店活动,邀请小读者们晚间走进书店亲近书籍,并通过睡前读书会、好书分享、枕书共眠等形式,培养孩子们良好的睡前阅读习惯,爱读书、读好书。7月24日,在栈桥书店二楼的男生夜宿 ...[详细]
-
中国山东网-感知山东7月11日讯你一定听说了,一场颇具市南气质的啤酒节正在筹备中,它还取了个特别青岛味儿的名字,叫“上街里 哈啤酒”,也有人感慨万千地说,这是青岛啤酒节的回归, ...[详细]
-
在深夜的汉源湖畔,一艘皮划艇搭载着两人,一人驾驶皮划艇,一人放网,两人搭档非法捕捞野生湖鱼……日前,记者从雅安市公安局获悉,夏季治安打击整治行动开展以来,汉源县公安局和汉源县农业农村局联合对大渡河流域 ...[详细]
-
中国山东网—感知山东8月9日讯每当夜幕降临,青岛西海岸新区金沙滩啤酒城就化作欢乐的海洋。第29届青岛国际啤酒节上,来自美国、英国、墨西哥、加拿大、俄罗斯、德国、乌克兰、西班牙等14个国家的 ...[详细]
-
9家猪企2024年目标总量将超1.3亿头,增长2000万头!
9家猪企2024年目标总量将超1.3亿头,增长2000万头!_南方+_南方plus2023年,上市猪企纷纷刷新各自的出栏记录。但由于猪价不给力,销售收入却大打折扣。2024年,猪价行情迷雾重重,上市猪 ...[详细] -
7月23日,中国平安集团宣布正式焕新、升级公司品牌标识,主要将现有品牌标识中的标语"金融•科技"升级为"专业•价值",品牌标识主体的中文和拼 ...[详细]
-
Carbon neutrality law violates basic rights: Constitutional Court
South Korea's carbon neutrality law does not conform with the Constitution because the absence ...[详细] -
骞冲畨浜哄闈掑矝鍒嗗叕鍙革細涓惧姙2022骞村崐骞村害娉曞緥鍚堣鍛樺伐鎶€鑳芥彁鍗囧煿璁彮
銆€銆€涓鸿繘涓€姝ユ彁鍗囬潚宀涘垎鍏徃涓撳吋鑱屾硶寰嬪悎瑙勪汉鍛樼殑宸ヤ綔绠$悊鎶€鑳斤紝鏈夋晥淇冭繘鍒嗗叕鍙稿悎瑙勭ǔ鍋ョ粡钀ワ紝7鏈?2鏃ワ紝骞冲畨浜哄闈掑矝鍒嗗叕鍙告硶寰嬪悎瑙勯儴鍦ㄥ煿璁 ...[详细]