How doctors really feel about the Apple Watch's health features
With mountains of product leaks and an underwhelming amount of innovation, the moments of sincere, unmanufactured awe that Apple events used to be known for are few and far between these days. But at Apple's 2018 event, when COO Jeff Williams unveiled the Apple Watch Series 4's ability to take an honest-to-God Electrocardiogram (ECG) — a feat unconquered by any other consumer tech company — it felt like a true breakthrough.
Using emotionally compelling advertising campaigns, Apple has been touting the ability of these features to save lives. At Apple's Worldwide Developer Conference (WWDC) on Monday, the company will likely unveil a new Watch OS that offers even more health capabilities.
SEE ALSO:Apple Watch Series 4 review: Sidekick no moreHealth features are a crown jewel priority for Apple; Tim Cook has even gone on the record several times with the somewhat astonishing statement that — forget the iPhone — Apple's greatest contribution may be to healthcare.
Tweet may have been deleted
But there's often a gap between what healthcare professionals actually want and need, and what tech companies thinkwill help doctors and their patients. It turns out the Apple Watch is no exception.
"I think the Apple Watch is an incredibly good tool to engage patients, but it's not a medical device," said Dr. Kevin Campbell, a cardiologist and expert in heart rhythm disorders who has written about the intersection of tech and medicine.
Campbell laid out a few issues he has with the Apple Watch. First, in terms of the heart rate information it gathers, he's concerned the Apple Watch produces too much data, with too little A.I. interpretation, that's not necessarily useful for doctors.
"As physicians, we are going to want to use it," Campbell said. "However, you're going to need software, you're going to need artificial intelligence, you're going to need other ways to sort through that data, so that data is delivered to the physician in a way that's easily digestible and manageable."
Moreover, despite the abundance of data patients may hand over to their busy doctors, the Apple Watch does not provide information on other key data points that physicians doneed to diagnose problems. It's the sort of information needed to distinguish something like atrial fibrillation from a spiked heart rate caused by something else.
If a patient's heart rate spikes, geriatrician and "geriatric tech" expert Dr. Leslie Kernison said, every physician would also need to know that person's blood pressure to make any diagnostic sense of heart rate data.
"Just from a problem-solving perspective, once you have people who are middle-aged or older, you need the blood pressure, too," Kernison said.
Dr. Kernison was also concerned with usability on the patient side. Some have speculated that Apple's health product moves are designed to help capture an older customer base. But Dr. Kernison pointed out that seniors not only have to afford the watch, they also have to have it paired with an iPhone, remember to charge it, and actually wear it. Any one of those factors could be a challenge for someone who could truly benefit from fall detection, or GPS location in cases of wandering.
Still, because the watch is more stylish than other fall detectors, she believes it has the potential to be useful. But overcoming the technological hurdles will vary greatly from patient to patient.
A larger concern beyond the specific features is Apple's suggestion, through its advertising campaign, that the Apple Watch can save lives.
Apple never explicitly says that, but it uses anecdotal videos to show how the watch's health and emergency functions havesaved lives. Williams, Tim Cook, and Apple's promotional material all describe the watch as "the ultimate guardian for your health," and something that is becoming "indispensable" to people's lives.
Campbell takes issue with the implication, mainly because the Apple Watch is not an FDA-approved medical device, and therefore does not have the data to back up the live-saving "claim."
"Has the Apple Watch impacted care?" Campbell asked. "I would say yes. We have multiple anecdotes, multiple scenarios, where we discover an abnormal heart rhythm, and we were able to treat that patient and prevent a stroke. But that's not data, and you can't make that type of sweeping claim with any accuracy or legitimacy."
Unlike many other tech-health devices, the Apple Watch is not devoid of scientific research. Apple and Stanford Medicine conducted a 400,000-person study that found that the a-fib detection was accurate. However, that study answers a different question than whether using watches to detect a-fib was actually lifesaving.
Additionally, the watch's ECG and heart rate monitoring features actually have received FDA "clearance." But "clearance" for a feature requires far less scientific evidence than "approval" for a device. (The Verge has a great explainer on the difference.)
Without that FDA approval, Campbell feels that Apple has no business suggesting the watch can save lives.
Kernison is not as concerned about whether the watch itself has an FDA approval. But she agrees that Apple needs to demonstrate more scientific evidence about how it may improve the care and health of patients before doctors and patients should consider it part of their medical care.
"If regular people wear this, is it likely to benefit an individual’s health, or a population’s health?" Kernison said. "That I don’t think we can know until we’ve done more research. Until then, it’s kind of anecdotal. But that’s kind of where things start."
Doctors like Campbell and Kernison are enthusiastic about how devices like the Apple Watch may improve preventative care and preemptive medicine. However, the Apple Watch has a ways to go — in terms of both scientific research and integrating features doctors truly need — before Apple can rest on the watch's allegedly live-saving laurels.
Or, as Dr. Campbell said, "anecdotes are not data."
CORRECTION June 3, 7:30 a.m. PT:
A previous version of the story said Dr. Campbell thought the “Apple Watch would be much more useful to doctors if there were also a way users could put in symptoms, such as shortness of breath or dizziness, when the watch alerted them that their heart rate was spiking.” Apple Watch currently allows users to enter symptoms after taking an ECG.
Featured Video For You
Apple's health-centric Watch Series 4 can call for help if it senses you fall
(责任编辑:产品中心)
-
Pakistan to host South Africa before ICC Women’s T20 World Cup
In preparation for the ICC Women’s T20 World Cup, South Africa’s women’s cricket t ...[详细] -
雅安展馆吸引不少人驻足本报讯第十八届中国国际农产品交易会于11月27日在重庆市国际博览中心举行。为加快建设绿色发展示范市,提升农业品牌市场影响力,推动农业贸易合作,我市以“天润雅安”市级区域公用品牌为 ...[详细]
-
中国山东网青岛7月11日讯2018年7月,正值招商银行潍坊分行成立十周年。招行特推出7.29元观影活动,即日起至7月31日,每位客户可使用招行借记卡购7.29元电影票,每人最多两张。据悉,招商银行始终 ...[详细]
-
第三批全国乡村治理示范村镇名单公示!广东这些村镇上榜→_南方+_南方plus9月4日,农业农村部官网发布第三批全国乡村治理示范村镇名单公示公告:“经地方推荐和专家评审,拟认定北京市大兴区庞各庄镇等10 ...[详细]
-
NASA's new plan keeps Starliner astronauts in space until 2025
Have you ever had an eight-day road trip turn into an eight-month excursion? Nope? Well, consider yo ...[详细] -
中国山东网青岛7月11日讯2018年7月,正值招商银行潍坊分行成立十周年。招行特推出7.29元观影活动,即日起至7月31日,每位客户可使用招行借记卡购7.29元电影票,每人最多两张。据悉,招商银行始终 ...[详细]
-
南农晨读丨广东柚,柚飘香_南方+_南方plus【今日关注】喊全球吃“菠萝的海”月饼——来自“菠萝的海”的邀请信菠萝自春来,香飘满绿野。徐闻是中国大陆最南端的一个县,独特的火山半岛,三面环海,四季阳光, ...[详细]
-
浜ら€氶摱琛岄潚宀涘磦灞辨敮琛孃灏嗗井绗戣疮绌夸簬鏈嶅姟鐨勬瘡涓€澶涓浗灞变笢缃慱闈掑矝
銆€銆€“鎮ㄥソ锛岃闂偍鍔炵悊浠€涔堜笟鍔?”鍒颁氦閫氶摱琛屽姙鐞嗕笟鍔$殑瀹㈡埛锛屽浜庤繖鍙ヨ瘽澶ф閮戒笉闄岀敓銆傚洜涓烘瘡娆″綋浣犱竴韪忚繘閾惰澶у巺锛岃繋闈㈣€ ...[详细] -
NASA says Earth just had the hottest day ever recorded
In the 1800s, pioneering scientists foresaw how carbon in the air could warm Earth. By 1938, English ...[详细] -
近几年来,伴随着互联网金融的迅速崛起,传统的银行金融机构也开始加快了金融服务的电子化,智能化,互联网化!交通银行为客户提供的电子银行服务包括:网上银行,手机银行,电话银行以及其他利用电子服务设备和网络 ...[详细]