Law school professors need more practical experience.
Regarding your posting, Akhil:
I don’t think the Supreme Court is likely to accept advice from law professors on administrative issues, such as whether to have opinions in tie cases and whether to identify the justices voting for or against cert. The court is understandably likely to think that law professors are not in a position to advise on such issues. I also think there’s a growing gap between judges (including the Supreme Court justices) and the academy, which judges tend to think is increasingly distant from the actual practice of law, staffed as it increasingly is with refugees from other disciplines—the graduate students in classics, and history, and anthropology, and so on who upon discovering there were very few well-paying positions in such fields nowadays decided to go to law school and afterward had no time to practice law before getting a law-teaching job.
I think law schools should be hiring a higher percentage of lawyers with significant practical experience. I think, for example, of Benjamin Kaplan at Harvard Law School, who went into law-teaching after 14 years in practice. There used to be many like that; there are many fewer now, especially at the leading law schools.
On a different subject, I worry that law professors are too respectful of the Supreme Court, in part perhaps because they don’t want to spoil the chances of their students to obtain Supreme Court clerkships. I think the Supreme Court is at a nadir. The justices are far too uniform in background, and I don’t think there are any real stars among them; the last real star, Robert Jackson, died more than 60 years ago. I regard the posthumous encomia for Scalia as absurd. Especially those of Harvard Law School Dean Martha Minow and Justice Elena Kagan.
Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementAnd on another note about academia and practical law, I see absolutely no value to a judge of spending decades, years, months, weeks, day, hours, minutes, or seconds studying the Constitution, the history of its enactment, its amendments, and its implementation (across the centuries—well, just a little more than two centuries, and of course less for many of the amendments). Eighteenth-century guys, however smart, could not foresee the culture, technology, etc., of the 21stcentury. Which means that the original Constitution, the Bill of Rights, and the post–Civil War amendments (including the 14th), do not speak to today. David Strauss is right: The Supreme Court treats the Constitution like it is authorizing the court to create a common law of constitutional law, based on current concerns, not what those 18th-century guys were worrying about.
In short, let’s not let the dead bury the living.
Dick Posner
Read the previous entry. |Read the next entry.
Tweet Share Share Comment(责任编辑:资讯)
- 中山古镇:到苏炳添家乡看“村BA”,来一场说走就走的美食之旅
- How the UK government can hack your personal data
- Apple announces $129 Smart Battery Case for iPhone XR, XS, XS Max
- More Snap execs are out amid reports of 'inappropriate relationship'
- Get Thee to Totality: Chicago
- Apple's iPhone 17 will come with a huge RAM upgrade, report claims
- 深入推进中心城区环境综合治理
- Bernie Sanders' Nevada caucus win caused a ruckus on political Twitter
- NK joins Park bashing
- US to oppose North Korean worker dispatch to occupied Ukrainian territory: State Dept.
- Amazon's Jeff Bezos announces he and wife MacKenzie are getting a divorce
- Josh Gad brings some serious star power for his latest grilling of Daisy Ridley
- Ministry eyes ‘intelligent’ electronic tags to deter crimes
-
29 Dive Bars, Saloons, and Taverns Where the Vibe Is Unbeatable
From hand-sculpted ice spheres to baroque cocktails made with everything from olive oil–washed gin t ...[详细] -
本报讯 近日来,我市进入主汛期,雷暴雨天气和高温天气交替出现,给雅安电网安全和稳定运行带来较大影响,部分线路因此多次跳闸停电。针对这些情况,雅电集团多措并举保障市民用电。针对近段时间自然灾害频发,雅电 ...[详细]
-
国道318线飞仙关段被巨石阻路国道318线天全境内抢通工作正在开展交通、公路部门时组织排畅18日夜间至19日,我市再次出现降雨天气,全市37个乡镇降下暴雨、12个乡镇降下大暴雨。连续的降雨中,全市国道 ...[详细]
-
NK science commission's 2023 research to focus on agriculture, key industries
North Korean people hold a mass rally at May Day Stadium in Pyongyang to vow to carry through the ta ...[详细] -
21 College and University Museums
University campuses have no shortage of knowledge—from eclectic libraries filled to the brim with ra ...[详细] -
Ministry eyes ‘intelligent’ electronic tags to deter crimes
The Justice Ministry plans to outfit criminals with “intelligent” electronic anklets to monitor them ...[详细] -
Neymar's World Cup dream slips away again
DOHA:Yet another World Cup has ended in tears for Neymar, with football's most expensive player ...[详细] -
US again downplays informal talks with NK
The United States again downplayed last week's talks between North Korean diplomats and former US nu ...[详细] -
On April 8, 2024, the moon’s shadow will completely cover the sun for around three and a half minute ...[详细]
-
NK science commission's 2023 research to focus on agriculture, key industries
North Korean people hold a mass rally at May Day Stadium in Pyongyang to vow to carry through the ta ...[详细]