The big flaw with the law that prevents Trump from getting a Georgia pardon.
Now that Donald Trump has been indicted for a fourth time—this time in Georgia—the public is asking if Trump can escape the charges with a pardon. The answer is no. And the law that prevents a Trump pardon is a mixed bag for ordinary criminal defendants.
First, the charges against Trump have been brought by a county prosecutor in state court. Even if Trump were to win the presidency in 2024, a president can only issue a pardon in federal cases, not for state charges.
But what about the Republican governor of Georgia, Brian Kemp? Can’t he pardon Trump and the other defendants? Not a chance. Georgia is one of a handful of states that puts all of the pardon power in the hands of an independent board and keeps the governor out of it.
The Georgia rules cut off any escape hatch for Trump and his co-defendants. While this is very bad news for defendant Trump, it is good news for other Georgia defendants. And it’s a policy other states should try to emulate.
Related From Slate
Ben Mathis-Lilley
Americans Are Not Really That “Divided” About Donald Trump’s Conduct
Read MoreTaking the pardon power out of the governor’s hands limits the politicization of crime and justice. The United States is a prison juggernaut. We have nearly 2 million people in prison—including many who committed serious crimes but were hammered with excessively long sentences, and many who are no longer dangerous.
AdvertisementYet, pardons and sentencing reductions are a rarity. Crime is so politicized that governors are too afraid to show mercy to those who are no longer dangerous and those who have already been adequately punished for their crimes. Many governors go their entire term in office almost never granting pardons. Thanksgiving often brings media coverage of turkeys being pardoned at the White House, but no actual people being sent home to spend the holidays with their families. Instead, our nation has grown accustomed to governors giving out a handful of pardons in their last days in office, or perhaps, if they are “very generous,” during the Christmas season. And even then, governors often concentrate the use of their pardon power on very low-level misdemeanor offenses.
Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementIf our nation is going to make a dent in mass incarceration, we need to do better. Sadly, decades of evidence show that our elected leaders are not up to the task. Pardon boards that are insulated from politics—those that cannot be pushed around by elected governors who are worried about reelection or seeking higher office—have the best chance to reduce the size of the prison population. An independent pardon board of reasonable size (the Georgia board has five people) is unlikely to make rash decisions that throw out meritorious prosecutions. Georgia’s independent pardon board is the right way forward.
Popular in News & Politics
- We’ve Been Entertaining an Illusion About the Supreme Court. It’s Finally Been Shattered.
- A Supreme Court Justice Gave Us Alarming New Evidence That He’s Living in MAGA World
- Them Supreme Court Boys Are at It Again
- In a Week Full of Hypocrites, Greg Abbott Came Close to Winning the Crown
But the pardon news from Georgia isn’t all good. Georgia also has an antiquated rule that forbids pardons from being issued until five years after a defendant has completed their sentence. (The state constitution provides a rare exception if a person can prove their innocence.) Not allowing pardons until five years after a defendant finishes their sentence is a terrible rule. If a rogue or overly punitive prosecutor seeks unjust charges against a criminal defendant, the pardon door should be open from the beginning of the case as an avenue to challenge prosecutorial overreach. And while there’s zero evidence that the Fulton County district attorney has engaged in improper conduct against Donald Trump, there are surely “regular” defendants in Georgia and around the country who can point to unjust prosecutions that should never have been filed in the first place. The pardon power should operate from the very beginning of a criminal case so that it can shut down a wrongful prosecution at any point in the life of a case, not just years down the road. This is particularly important because while Georgia still provides the option of parole, it may take many years for inmates to become eligible for parole. Moreover, few people are granted parole at their initial eligibility, and some recidivist offenders (not just those sentenced to life without parole) are not eligible for parole at all.
If we are to move toward a fairer and less punitive criminal justice system, we need a revitalized pardon power. The Trump case brings this issue to the surface. And the Georgia pardon rules show us both the right and wrong ways forward.
Tweet Share Share Comment(责任编辑:关于我们)
- Sinkhole swallows up car, injuring 2 in Seoul
- Pogba keen on playing for Real Madrid one day
- North Carolina Gov. Pat McCrory admits defeat.
- US Secretary of State welcomed to New Zealand with 'a display of middle fingers'
- 海丰芥蓝入选全国名特优新农产品名录
- 雨城区疾控中心提示:科学补碘 防治碘缺乏病
- S. Korea on alert over yet another cluster infection amid eased social distancing
- Facebook has a giant, Europe
- Elon Musk is safe for now: AI still sucks at writing Christmas Carols
- 21 College and University Museums
- Facebook has a giant, Europe
- S. Korea on alert over yet another cluster infection amid eased social distancing
- Zodiac meme Instagram will align the stars to make you feel seen
-
9 Festive Holiday Treats and Where to Find Them
Whether it’s lechón(roast suckling pig) for Noche Buena in the Philippines or an aspic made ofbathtu ...[详细] -
Comet pizzeria gunman says “the intel on this wasn’t 100 percent” in first interview.
The New York Timesmanaged the first interview Wednesday with the Comet Ping Pong gunman, Edgar Maddi ...[详细] -
How to speed up Google Chrome and Mozilla Firefox using OneTab
Tab addicts, rejoice!If you're a tab-loving Chrome power user, a simple extension can give you the p ...[详细] -
宝兴东拉山大峡谷资料图片) 雅安日报讯 从今6)日开始,游客可以去宝兴东拉山等地休闲避暑了。我市天全喇叭河、宝兴东拉山、硗碛藏寨旅游市场恢复启动,这标志着我市主要景区景点已全面恢复启动。在8月4日召开 ...[详细]
-
Noelle Mateer ,July 17, 2024 The Techies W ...[详细]
-
N. Korea holds cabinet plenary meeting to discuss economic plans
North Korean leader Kim Jong-un shakes hands with North Korean offical in Pyongyang, Jan. 15. Yonhap ...[详细] -
Out Magazine's latest issue celebrates women and non
This isOne Good Thing, a weekly column where we tell you about one of the few nice things that happe ...[详细] -
This 2021 file photo shows Cho Hyun-jung, who recently joined the Korea Institute for National Unifi ...[详细]
-
Weather update for second Pak vs Ban second Test match day one
ListentoarticleThe second Test between Pakistan and Bangladesh, part of the ICC World Test Champions ...[详细] -
The best and worst Oscar moments of the night
Even without a host, the 2019 Oscars managed to be simultaneously entertaining, infuriating, insipid ...[详细]
- Gastro Obscura's Guide to Where to Eat in Nashville
- Twitter: Donald Trump's nuclear button tweets don't violate the rules
- Uber is selling its auto
- 我市将尽快对遇难者家属发放抚慰金
- Best smartphone deal: Google Pixel 8a on sale for $449 at Amazon
- Telegram and Instagram blocked in Iran in the midst of protests
- Trump's climate expert is wrong: The world's plants don't need more CO2