Is the U.S. on the verge of a cold war with China?
Tensions between the U.S. and China have been frosty for a long time. But things have strained even further this year, as a result of the pandemic and China’s announcement of a new security law that threatens Hong Kong’s autonomous status. The frustrations between the countries are now reaching new heights. Could the world’s two foremost superpowers be on the cusp of a new cold war? If so, how will that play out with so much at stake?
On Thursday’s episode of What Next, I spoke with Joshua Keating, a senior editor at Slate who covers international affairs, about how the coronavirus has thrown already-strained relations with China into a deep freeze, and whether any sort of conflict could be next. Our conversation has been edited and condensed for clarity.
Mary Harris: I’m hoping you can explain this tweetfrom Pompeo: “Today, I reported to Congress that Hong Kong is no longer autonomous from China, given facts on the ground. The United States stands with the people of Hong Kong.”
Joshua Keating:The U.S. considers Hong Kong a separate political entity from the rest of China. This means things like the tariffs that the U.S. placed on Chinese exports during the recent trade war don’t apply to Hong Kong. It means there are different visa rules for travelers from Hong Kong. And when Chinese companies want to expand internationally, they often start by listing themselves on the Hong Kong stock market.
So what does it mean that Pompeo pulled this special status?
AdvertisementA bill that was passed by Congress last year during the Hong Kong protests basically requires the secretary of state to certify every year that Hong Kong is still sufficiently autonomous to be granted this special status. Both China and the U.S. didn’t really think the other would act on Hong Kong because it’s such a major escalation. The U.S. Chamber of Commerce was strongly opposed to this. Generally, the U.S. business community and the businesses that have their offices in Hong Kong were very opposed to pulling its autonomy. So it’s a controversial step.
Why now?
Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementTrump is really spoiling for a fight with China, both because he’s been blaming China for the coronavirus and because he’s heading into an election year where he’s going to try to portray the Democrats as being soft on China and himself as being the guy who stood up to Beijing. I think right now we’re witnessing maybe the worst crisis in U.S.-China relations since Tiananmen Square in 1989.
AdvertisementFiguring out how the U.S. and China reached this new low point means understanding all the different ways the two countries challenge each other—and the way this coronavirus has magnified those friction points. Hong Kong is just one of many points of conflict, but what’s happened there shows how the coronavirus has given a sudden shock to U.S.-China diplomacy.Last year, when protesters flooded Hong Kong’s streets, demanding a say in the way the city runs, it seemed like the United States might be able to use the situation to its advantage. But the coronavirus changed all that.
Those protests have kind of dissipated, largely because of social distancing requirements. So it’s been a good moment for China to press its advantage when it’s harder to protest and when the attention of the international community is focused elsewhere. That’s involved arresting a number of activists who were involved in the protests last year. And the biggest escalation last week was when Beijing announced that it was going to pass a new security law that would ban what it calls “seditious activities” or “foreign interference” but can basically be used to criminalize any kind of dissent or what it sees as anti-China behavior.
Advertisement AdvertisementAnd this law that affects Hong Kong skips the usual process of going through Hong Kong’s government.
AdvertisementExactly. This is being inserted by the Chinese government into what’s effectively Hong Kong’s constitution. Pro-democracy activists in Hong Kong fear it’s going to be used to criminalize basically any kind of dissent or any kind of anti-China organizing in Hong Kong. A number of prominent pro-democracy politicians in Hong Kong said this is basically the end of “one country, two systems”—the end of Hong Kong’s political independence.
Thisis why Pompeo has suddenly declared that Hong Kong is “no longer autonomous from China.” This new security law was set to go to a vote this week. Pompeo’s tweet was a clear message.
AdvertisementThis announcement Pompeo made does not actually involve policy changes. This is a recommendation the State Department is making. It’s up to Trump how he wants to interpret it. If he wants to actually change the U.S. relationship with Hong Kong, he’d do it through an executive order. It seems unlikely he wouldn’t do anything, especially given all the buildup to this.
I think we’re going to see a lot of ferocious lobbying. The business community will want a softer response. The more business- and trade-oriented voices within the administration, like Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer, are going to want to water this down a bit.
How would you characterize the U.S.-China relationship now?
Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementThere have always been two sides to the U.S. engagement with China. There’s the “pragmatic” side that looks at the economic, business, trade, and security benefits. On the other side, you’ve had conservative hawks, who don’t trust China’s international intentions, and activists, who don’t think we should be engaged with a country with such atrocious human rights practices.
There was this idea that the U.S. could have it both ways: that by engaging China, we would encourage it to act the way that we want it to. President Bill Clinton would say things like, By bringing China to the world, we bring the world’s values and democracy to China. The idea that by opening up its economy, we would also open up its political system. That was always a dubious proposition. But I think it allowed several U.S. administrations to defend the idea of engagement with China against criticism.
Advertisement AdvertisementI wonder when you think the relationship between China and United States began to shift.
I think it was Xi Jinping. After he took power in 2012, there was some hope that he would be a more pragmatic leader. It hasn’t happened that way at all. He’s effectively made himself a president for life. China’s clamped down even harder on Hong Kong, which resulted in the protests we saw last year. It’s overall become more repressive internally and more assertive internationally. So I think that, under Xi, the engagement narrative that a more open China would become a more democratic or cooperative China has kind of collapsed.
AdvertisementWith the United States leading the world in COVID-19 deaths, China is looking to present itself as the superpower that’s been able to rein in the pandemic. But there’s ample evidence China’s leaders struggled to quash the coronavirus early enough.
AdvertisementThis looks really bad for China. This whole idea that it’s the new responsible superpower takes a hit if its actions made the virus worse. So China engaged in what was called “mask diplomacy,” shipping medical equipment to countries that were hurt really hard, especially in Europe. And it spread its expertise as well as this message that it got the virus under control.
“It seems like we’re drifting into a period of hostility, and there don’t seem to be strong voices on either side who want to keep the relationship on track.” — Joshua KeatingA lot of the equipment turned out to be faulty. But early on, people appreciated the effort that China was making, and it got a lot of praise in Europe. I think that started to backfire because China pressed its advantage a little too hard.
What do you mean by that?
There are these stories that came out that China was demanding that officials in places like Germany, Canada, and the U.S. praise them publicly for the help. You saw Chinese sock puppets online disseminating the message that the virus had originated in Europe. There were doctored clips of Italians playing the Chinese national anthem in gratitude. China could have looked like the responsible country, especially as the U.S. totally bungled its response. But by being so aggressive and unwilling to countenance any sort of criticism, and instead actually actively spreading disinformation, China’s come off looking just as irresponsible and bellicose as the U.S.
Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementThere was reporting in the Times that said Chinese national television was spouting a lot of anti-American coverageand negative reports about Pompeo. It reminded me of the Cold War: a ton of propaganda about how bad this other place is.
There are a lot of parallels. Harvard professor Graham Allison has this theory called the Thucydides Trap: Whenever there’s a rising power that challenges a declining power, they’re usually destined for military conflict. You can poke holes in that theory. But last time I was in China, a lot of officials were talking about that idea of inevitable conflict, whether it’s in an active shooting war or even a kind of long cold war. That’s really taken hold, I think, in both Washington and Beijing. I would point out one key difference, which is that, I think, unlike in the Cold War, neither the U.S. nor China is coming into this with a whole lot of credibility.
AdvertisementBut it’s going to be tough for the rest of the world because of the economic and military importance of both the U.S. and China. Countries can’t just ignore them. You can’t have an effective climate deal that excludes the two largest CO2emitters in the world. You can’t have a meaningful security alliance that excludes the two largest militaries. But I think an unexpected consequence of this may be more multilateralism and economic and political cooperation among countries in Europe and Asia.
AdvertisementWhat happens when you fight a cold war and nobody shows up? How does an escalation like this end?
It seems like both sides right now see it as in their interest to escalate the crisis. Even after Tiananmen Square, there were back channels maintained between the first Bush administration and Beijing. Right now, it doesn’t seem like there’s the same level of communication, partly because of the Trump administration’s distrust of diplomacy.I think that right now you’re hearing more support in Washington and in the business community for this idea of decoupling: separating the U.S. and Chinese economies because of how intertwined supply lines are between them. That’s probably not possible to do entirely.
Advertisement AdvertisementRecently in The World
- I Study Famine. The Conversation About Gaza Has Been Very Confused.
- The Iran Strikes and World Central Kitchen Deaths Have Felt Like Turning Points—in America. In Israel …
- Putin Is Not Going to Let a Crisis Like This Go to Waste
- The Biggest Misconception About the Crisis in Haiti
I do think it seems like we’re drifting into a period of hostility, and there don’t seem to be strong voices on either side who want to keep the relationship on track. On the other hand, I don’t think this means we are necessarily destined for military conflict. If you look at the history of the Cold War, even during the worst periods, it was possible to make progress on arms control. There are definitely multilateral issues that the U.S. and China have common interests in, like climate change. There are still ways the U.S. and China can keep lines of communication open and act responsibly in areas where they have common interests while being clear-eyed that there are a lot of areas where, for the foreseeable future at least, they’re not going to see eye to eye.
Tweet Share Share Comment(责任编辑:产品中心)
- Yes, big spiders are spreading in the U.S. No, they're not flying.
- Pyongyang opposes UNSC meeting on North Korea's human rights
- Where to buy Beyoncé's pink kitty headphones
- 加大普法防范宣传力度 增强防范意识能力
- Nvidia GeForce Now Ultimate vs. New Graphics Card
- Elon Musk's AI facility is reportedly operating gas turbines without a permit
- Better sleep deal: Get a Philips SmartSleep Wake
- CTBTO chief urges N. Korea to take 'small step' in nuclear test moratorium
- N. Korea, Russia defend Moscow's war with Ukraine during showing of film over Nazi trials
- 18 Places for Epic Outdoor Adventure Across Colorado
- No detection of suspected bombing attack near Pyongyang: Spy agency
- YouTube bests Netflix, Disney+ as the top streamer of 2023
- N. Korea joins China trade fair in another sign of border reopening
-
Amazon Android Days sale 2024: Save on unlocked phones, tablets, and more
Table of ContentsTable of ContentsUPDATE: Aug. 28, 2024, 1:50 p.m. EDT This story has been updated w ...[详细] -
YouTube demonetizes public domain 'Steamboat Willie' video after copyright claim
UPDATE: Jan. 5, 2024, 5:18 p.m. EST On Friday, Disney retracted the copyright claim on YouTuber Broc ...[详细] -
牛肉糁、德州扒鸡、酱卤驴肉......山东特色优品组团亮相预制菜“第一会”
牛肉糁、德州扒鸡、酱卤驴肉......山东特色优品组团亮相预制菜“第一会”_南方+_南方plus3月15-17日,第二届中国国际佛山)预制菜产业大会在佛山潭洲国际会展中心举办。山东组团携牛肉糁、羊肉汤 ...[详细] -
AI George Carlin releases comedy special that Carlin would've despised
George Carlin has dropped a new comedy special. And if that seems weird — because, you know, h ...[详细] -
New Grok response directs users to Vote.gov for election questions
X's native AI chatbot Grok is now providing users with election-related queries a Vote.gov banner an ...[详细] -
当“五大百亿”遇到马拉松,2024清远马拉松赛逛吃攻略来了!
当“五大百亿”遇到马拉松,2024清远马拉松赛逛吃攻略来了!_南方+_南方plus在清远体育馆的绿色草坪上,一抹红色显得格外亮眼。凑近一看,清远鸡、英德红茶、连州菜心、清远丝苗米、西牛麻竹笋..... ...[详细] -
NK leader calls for efforts to minimize typhoon damage to crops
North Korean leader Kim Jong-un, center, inspects farms in the typhoon-hit county of Anbyon in Kangw ...[详细] -
本报讯近日,记者从石棉县七一中学学生毕业典礼上获悉,该校九年级六班全体19名)男生荣获“阿里巴巴天天正能量特别奖”及一万元奖金。面对荣誉,他们决定将全部奖金捐给母校,希望以此鼓励更多学弟学妹心怀善意、 ...[详细]
-
Korea's economy to stop growing without drastic labor change: FKI
A port in South Korea's southeastern city of Busan. (Yonhap)South Korea’s economy is expected to sto ...[详细] -
当“五大百亿”遇到马拉松,2024清远马拉松赛逛吃攻略来了!
当“五大百亿”遇到马拉松,2024清远马拉松赛逛吃攻略来了!_南方+_南方plus在清远体育馆的绿色草坪上,一抹红色显得格外亮眼。凑近一看,清远鸡、英德红茶、连州菜心、清远丝苗米、西牛麻竹笋..... ...[详细]
Best smart home deal: The Amazon Smart Thermostat is just $63.99
Galaxy AI is coming soon to other Samsung devices
- NCT member Taeil leaves band over sexual offense allegations
- iPhone 16 Pro: These 2 camera rumors will make you regret the iPhone 15 Pro
- 培养选拔优秀检察人才 提升刑事检察队伍水平
- 培养选拔优秀检察人才 提升刑事检察队伍水平
- Listeners encouraged to go wild with Le Sserafim's 4th EP
- 7 of Oregon's Most Magical Places
- 'True Detective: Night Country': What's with the polar bears?