Encryption backdoors violate human rights, EU court rules
The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) has ruled that enabling governments to access everyone's encrypted messages is a human rights violation. It probably won't stop them from continuing to try, though.
In a 27-page judgement on Tuesday, the ECHR found that Russian legislation concerning online messaging services breach Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights, which protects the right to privacy. The case was brought by a Russian Telegram userwho objected to laws requiring messaging services to store users' communications for six months, keep their metadata for one year, and provide law enforcement with keys to decrypt their conversations upon request.
Russia stopped being a party to the Convention in Sept. 2022, six months after it was expelled from the Council of Europe, however the ECHR decided it was still able to hear the case as the events in question occurred prior to this.
SEE ALSO:Warning: Telegram is not end-to-end encrypted by defaultThe applicant successfully argued that it is impossible for Telegram to selectively provide authorities with decryption keys for some users and not others, as the technology simply does not work that way. Creating the ability to access any encrypted messages would enable access to all encrypted messages, weakening security and undermining privacy for everyone across the entire platform.
When encryption is an all or nothing deal, it seems better to err on the side of all.
"In the digital age, technical solutions for securing and protecting the privacy of electronic communications, including measures for encryption, contribute to ensuring the enjoyment of other fundamental rights, such as freedom of expression," wrote the ECHR.
"[I]n the present case the [internet communication organisers'] statutory obligation to decrypt end-to-end encrypted communications risks amounting to a requirement that providers of such services weaken the encryption mechanism for all users; it is accordingly not proportionate to the legitimate aims pursued."
The ECHR also considered Russia's data retention requirements "extremely broad," with "exceptionally wide-ranging and serious" implications which would require significant safeguards against abuse. Unfortunately, such safeguards were nowhere to be found.
The court accepted the applicant's claim that Russia's laws violate the right to privacy by enabling the government to arbitrarily access anyone's communication logs, even without cause. Russian law enforcement is not required to show messaging services judicial authorisation before accessing decryption keys, theoretically enabling them to conduct secret extrajudicial surveillance of users.
"Although the possibility of improper action by a dishonest, negligent or overzealous official can never be completely ruled out whatever the system, the Court considers that a system, such as the Russian one, which enables the secret services to access directly the Internet communications of each and every citizen without requiring them to show an interception authorisation to the communications service provider, or to anyone else, is particularly prone to abuse," wrote the ECHR.
Telegram refused Russia's request to weaken encryption
The ECHR case concerned a 2017 order from Russia's Federal Security Service, which demanded Telegram provide information allowing it to decrypt communications from six users suspected of "terrorism-related activities." Telegram refused to comply with the order, stating that it was impossible to do so without creating a backdoor that would weaken encryption for all its users. It also noted that the users in question had activated Telegram's optional end-to-end encryption, meaning even the company couldn't access their messages.
Related Stories
- Messenger is finally adding default end-to-end encryption
- Update: Telegram says it will ‘protect user data at any cost’
- What Russians should keep in mind when using Telegram
- What is end-to-end encryption?
- Twitter's encrypted DMs are here, but they have many, many limitations
Russia subsequently fined and blocked Telegram in the country. Though the ban was eventually lifted in 2020, it was upheld in domestic courts despite challenges by the current applicant and others. The applicant therefore took the matter to the ECHR, alleging that he was unable to get justice for the violation of their human rights through the Russian courts.
Tuesday's ECHR ruling awarded the applicant €10,000 ($10,725) in damages, though whether he'll actually receive that money is another question. In 2015 Russia passed a domestic law enabling its Constitutional Court to overturn ECHR rulings, a move which Human Rights Watch criticised as undermining victims' ability to seek justice.
Governments vs Encryption
Governments around the world have tried forcing tech companies to weaken their encryption for years. In 2016, Apple CEO Tim Cook publicly opposedthe U.S. government's request for an iPhone encryption backdoor, stating that creating one would have "chilling" privacy and surveillance implications. Nevertheless, the U.S. has continued to pressure Apple to build a way for law enforcement to unlock people's devices. WhatsApp also rejected a request from the UK government to build a backdoorto its encryption in 2017 — a conflict that could still end with it pulling out of the country altogether.
Encryption is further being threatened in the U.S. by the Eliminating Abusive and Rampant Neglect of Interactive Technologies (EARN IT) Act, proposed legislation which was introduced to Congress in 2020. At the time, messaging app Signal warned that it may not be able to continue operating in the U.S. if the bill passed, alleging that the act would undermine end-to-end encryption. The bill was later amended in an attempt to address such concerns, though it wasn't enough to assuage privacy experts.
The ECHR's ruling this week is unlikely to put this long running encryption issue to rest. Still, it's a notable victory for privacy and security advocates across the globe.
(责任编辑:新闻中心)
- DOJ accuses TikTok of collecting and sharing users' personal views, as the app fights a ban
- Exclusive dating app for Tesla owners is not a joke (maybe)
- N. Korea vows to take countermeasures against organizations that impose sanctions
- N. Korea bristles at US over comments about possible disabling of spy satellite
- Microwave technique recovers 87% of batteries' lithium in 15 minutes
- Listeners encouraged to go wild with Le Sserafim's 4th EP
- Exclusive dating app for Tesla owners is not a joke (maybe)
- Alcaraz makes winning return
- Tsitsipas, Auger
- Students get free entry at second Rawalpindi Test but what’s the catch?
- Teen ransomware 'K!NG' blew his loot on drugs, gambling, and sex
- Your 'smart AI' often involves a low
- Tsitsipas, Auger
-
First officially approved Gen IV nuclear reactor in the US breaks ground
Kairos Power has broken ground at Oak Ridge on the first officially approved Generation IV reactor e ...[详细] -
累计善款超460万元!恩平慈善公益篮球赛火热进行_南方+_南方plus6月23日晚,由恩平市总工会、恩平市文化广电旅游体育局联合举办2024年恩平市“工会杯”慈善公益篮球赛决赛三四名争夺赛)在恩平市 ...[详细]
-
Pedri fires Barcelona 11 points clear in La Liga
BARCELONA:Pedri's strike earned Barcelona a battling 1-0 win over Villarreal on Sunday to move 1 ...[详细] -
Tinder launches apocalyptic Swipe Night experience in the UK and around the world
Trying to find love as the world ends? What a concept! That premise is central to Tinder's interacti ...[详细] -
Understanding Relational vs. Non
Relational databases and non-relational databases primarily differ in the types of data they store a ...[详细] -
Which is Faster for Gaming, Windows 10 or Windows 11?
Which is faster for gaming, Windows 10 or Windows 11? That's a question we've noticed people has kep ...[详细] -
Jack Dorsey's getting dunked on for his unkempt look at TED 2019
Congrats to Jack Dorsey for, once again, becoming a meme on his own platform.The Twitter CEO made an ...[详细] -
Welp, humanity had a good run: Humpback whales organize into mysterious 'super
Huge groups of humpback whales have been seen gathering in the Southern Hemisphere, and it's leaving ...[详细] -
21 Caves That Offer Otherworldly Experiences
Millions of caves can be found worldwide, many of which are home to flora and fauna that are uniquel ...[详细] -
Police interrupt students' group chat in the most spectacular way
It's not every day the police make a sudden guest appearance in your group chat.SEE ALSO:Cops help 1 ...[详细]
NASA's new plan keeps Starliner astronauts in space until 2025
Reuniting with teachers on Twitter is so incredibly wholesome
- iPhone 16 Pro new color will reportedly be Desert Titanium
- N. Korea bristles at US over comments about possible disabling of spy satellite
- HBL PSL8: Bigger, better, stronger?
- Tsitsipas, Auger
- Pakistan Cricket at crossroads after shock defeat at Pindi
- 汉源县 营造整洁好环境
- N. Korea bristles at US over comments about possible disabling of spy satellite