Here's the difference between Chelsea Manning's case and Edward Snowden's
With the stunning news that a bulk of Chelsea Manning's remaining sentence has been commuted by President Obama, there's an obvious question in the air about that other infamous leaker of government document troves, Edward Snowden.
Mainly: Why grant mercy to Chelsea Manning, but not Edward Snowden?
SEE ALSO:Obama commutes majority of Chelsea Manning's sentenceIt's easy to conflate the two, due in no small part to the fact that Snowden issued his own heart-felt call to Obama to commute Manning's sentence just last week.
Tweet may have been deleted
But people—many important ones—see a major rift between the two. In a statement to media today, White House press secretary Josh Earnest was crystal clear in what he saw as the "stark difference" between the two cases of Manning and Snowden:
On Chelsea Manning:
“Chelsea Manning is somebody who went through the military criminal justice process, was exposed to due process, was found guilty, was sentenced for her crimes, and she acknowledged wrongdoing,” [Earnest] said.
On Edward Snowden:
“Mr. Snowden fled into the arms of an adversary, and has sought refuge in a country that most recently made a concerted effort to undermine confidence in our democracy.”
Even more:
In Manning's case, the documents leaked related to the ongoing military operation in Iraq and Afghanistan, as well as diplomatic cables, and information about detainees in Guantanamo. Many of Manning's documents related to the war were about operations that already happened, and documents that revealed the number of civilian casualties to be higher than what the U.S. government was reporting at the time. In Snowden's case, the leaks detailed massive surveillance programs that were currently under use by U.S. intelligence agencies, including cracking encryption, collecting data-like text messages from cell phone carriers, and surveillance of other nations, including several allies.
Chelsea Manning leaked documents directly to WikiLeaks after being turned down by several newspapers, including the New York Times. Eventually, the Times, as well as The Guardianand German paper Der Spiegel, would go on to publish excerpts from the documents. Edward Snowden's documents were leaked to multiple outlets, including the Washington Postand The Guardianand, later, The New York Timesand Der Spiegel.
Government officials also noted that while Manning's leaks were information, Snowden's leaks showed, in detail, exactly how intelligence agencies went about collecting information, which could give enemies of the United States a better idea of how to avoid detection and circumvent U.S. efforts to undermine their plans.
Snowden, for his part, has expressed gratitude towards the U.S. Government in commuting Manning's sentence.
Tweet may have been deleted
Given the White House's take on the matter, Snowden's gratitude not withstanding, it certainly doesn't look like he's going to be on the receiving end of any help from the American government any time soon. For all the various ways the Obama administration and the forthcoming Trump administration seem to differ, given the last time he weighed in on it, it looks like the matter of Edward Snowden is one of the few things he and Obama can seem to agree on:
Tweet may have been deleted
Then again, given Trump's ever-evolving dynamic with Moscow, that one's potentially up in the air these days, too.
Featured Video For You
Edward Snowden says Russians probably hacked the NSA
(责任编辑:行业动态)
-
市民填写献血相关表格8月22日晚,雨城区正黄时代天街广场天桥旁停靠着一辆献血车,身穿红马甲的志愿者们正向路过的市民发放无偿献血宣传手册,不少市民停下脚步,参与无偿献血。这是雅安市中心血站开启夜间献血模 ...[详细]
-
Soccer at tipping point, says Ferdinand after Basaksehir, PSG players walk off
PARIS:Former defender Rio Ferdinand says football is at a "tipping point" and those in pow ...[详细] -
N. Korea broadcasts encrypted spy message on YouTube for first time
Captured image from a video clip posted on the Pyongyang Broadcast Service YouTube account.North Kor ...[详细] -
IBM's lithium battery uses seawater materials instead of heavy metals
Lithium-ion batteries are seen as a vital technology in our pursuit of sustainable energy, but there ...[详细] -
25 Years Later: A Brief Analysis of GPU Processing Efficiency
The first 3D graphics cards appeared 25 years ago and since then their power and complexity have gro ...[详细] -
Why is North Korea not sending cheering squad to Paralympics?
A North Korean cheerleader dances while her compatriots wear masks of a man, claimed by some conserv ...[详细] -
NASA fits 265,000 galaxies into a single ‘Hubble Legacy Field’ image
Astronomers have assembled the most all-encompassing image of space ever created.It puts together 16 ...[详细] -
Moon's special envoys head to US with Kim Jong
Chung Eui-yong, left, head of the National Security Office, speaks to reporters at Incheon Internati ...[详细] -
The Best AMD Ryzen Gaming Laptops (So Far)
As a culmination to our testing of Ryzen Mobile 4000-H processors and the various laptops they are f ...[详细] -
Gorsuch should start answering Supreme Court case questions.
Sen. Chuck Grassley, R-Iowa, opened Judge Neil Gorsuch’s confirmation hearing this week by telling G ...[详细]
- 12 Sculptures Made From Recycled Materials
- Google Maps AR directions won't come with a cute fox after all
- 好秧一半稻!控水温、防稻瘟、适时起秧,春耕种植看这里
- How the GOP will water down tax reform after the defeat of Trumpcare.
- Bernie Sanders’ DNC speech sounded like everyone else’s. That’s astonishing.
- U.S. airstrikes may have killed as many as 200 civilians in Mosul.
- 北江合唱团百人快闪助力“清马”