DOJ should probe endemic police failures on sexual assault cases.
Raped on a dinner date by a man she met on a dating app, Alicia Franklin, a Black woman, immediately went to the Memphis Police Department, desperate for her perpetrator to be brought to justice. Despite collecting evidence that would have allowed officers to quickly find Franklin’s rapist, law enforcement officials let her rape kit sit on the shelf for months. It took nearly a year before DNA testing came back with a positive match.
The same day that a forensics team completed DNA testing on Franklin’s rape kit, police found the body of Eliza Fletcher, a white woman who went missing while on a jog near the University of Memphis. In contrast to Franklin’s almost yearlong wait, police processed evidence found on Fletcher’s body within hours of her discovery. The results showed that the same man who raped Franklin had now raped and murdered Fletcher, 11 months after Franklin initially reported her rape to the police.
The tragic story of Alicia Franklin and Eliza Fletcher is not an isolated one. While a local judge dismissed Alicia’s lawsuit against the city, thousands of rape victims in Memphis last year joined together in a class action, alleging that the city is at fault for not processing 12,000 rape kits between 1985 and 2014. One of these women is Debby Dalhoff, whose rape case hasn’t been solved since she reported it to the Memphis Police Department in 1985. “They let perpetrators run free that could’ve been in jail,” she told a local journalist. “They’ve destroyed so many women.”
AdvertisementLast year, after four Memphis police officers brutally beat and murdered Tyre Nichols—an unarmed Black man—the Justice Department opened a pattern-and-practice investigation into the Memphis Police Department. Authorized by federal statute, these investigations take place when there is “reasonable cause to believe” that a government agency consistently commits civil rights violations. In justifying the investigation, the DOJ pointed to the MPD’s excessive use of force, aggressive escalation of traffic stops, and unnecessary deployment of specialized units.
Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementNowhere in this announcement, however, is any mention of the Memphis Police Department’s profound failure to investigate gender-based violence. This is not altogether surprising: The DOJ’s own explainer on pattern-and-practice investigations does not mention gender-based crime when detailing which issues may be considered during these investigations.
AdvertisementThis does not mean, of course, that the Department of Justice turns a blind eye to how law enforcement agencies treat cases involving gender-based violence. After all, its August 2016 report on the Baltimore Police Department, March 2023 report on the Louisville Metropolitan Police Department, and open investigation into the NYPD’s Special Victims Unit reflect the DOJ’s growing willingness to confront police departments that fail to adequately protect women.
Nonetheless, the lack of explicit language regarding sexual assault in its public-facing guidelines, in addition to the dozensof pattern-and-practice investigations that make no mention at all of gender-based crime, suggests that DOJ officials frequently overlook their ability to hold law enforcement officers accountable on this issue.
AdvertisementThis is especially egregious when one considers how well established it is that law enforcement agencies consistently fail to handle gender-based crime. In Austin, a DNA testing center was closed for months, leading rape kits to go unprocessed. In Chicago, between 80 percent and 90 percent of sexual assault reports made to the city’s police department in the previous decade did not result in an arrest. Out of the more than 1,000 sexual assault cases reviewed by the Minneapolis Star Tribune, police conducted a background check on the suspect only 10 percent of the time. Lawsuits filed against police departments in San Francisco and Greenwich, Connecticut, furthermore, have criticized law enforcement agencies for failing to conduct victim interviews, pursue leads, and retrieve important evidence.
Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementThe failure of law enforcement officers in this regard facilitates more gender-based violence. Because many police officers treat sexual assault crimes as low priority compared to other crimes, rapists get away more often than perpetrators of any other violent crime. In addition, more than two-thirds of police officers questioned in a 2018 report admitted they had no training on how to read rape kit results, and a CNN investigation revealed that law enforcement agencies disposed of evidence in 400 sexual assault cases before the statute of limitations had run out. In those cases where evidence is properly gathered, detectives sometimes view rape survivors skeptically based on their emotional response during questioning, leading prosecutors to drop otherwise winnable cases. When DNA is untested or cases are dropped, rapists go on to commit more rapes.
AdvertisementRelated From Slate
Mark Joseph Stern
Turns Out It’s Really Useful to Have a Former Public Defender on the Supreme Court
Read MoreThe failure of law enforcement agencies to resolve sexual assault cases, which increases the reluctance of victims to report what happened to them, occurs on a systemic scale. When law enforcement officers do not investigate and prosecute these crimes, not only is justice not served, but victims’ constitutional rights to due process and equal protection are infringed.
For this reason, the Department of Justice should mandate that pattern-and-practice investigations include an analysis of how police departments respond to gender-based violence. While these investigations are not perfect, they do make an impact. A study of 23 police departments that agreed to consent decrees found that the average number of civil rights suits filed per year against the law enforcement agency in question dropped between 23 and 36 percent after the federal investigation.
Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementPopular in News & Politics
- The Lawyer Defending Idaho’s Abortion Ban Irritated the One Justice He Needed on His Side
- We’ve Been Entertaining an Illusion About the Supreme Court. It’s Finally Been Shattered.
- You Don’t Want to Know How It’s Going Between Trump’s Lawyers and the Judge Presiding Over His Criminal Case
- Prosecutors Are Finally Revealing Their Strategy Against Trump
Moreover, oversight has proven to be an important tool in compelling police departments to change their practices. After investigative journalism revealed untested rape kits in Phoenix, the Phoenix Police Department applied for federal grants that facilitated the processing of these cases. In Pennsylvania, the Women’s Law Project conducts a yearly case review of uninvestigated sexual assault claims, helping to limit the state’s rape kit backlog. The Baltimore Police Department, for its own part, responded to the DOJ’s 2016 report by processing rape kits at a higher rate and by increasing consistency in its data documentation procedures. And within three years of a settlement with sexual assault victims, the Austin Police Department announced it had eliminated its rape kit backlog.
Advertisement AdvertisementVictims of gender-based crime deserve to have their stories heard, their cases investigated, and their offenders prosecuted. History shows that when law enforcement agencies’ mistakes are publicized and their policies are overseen by external actors, they do a much better job at dealing with gender-based violence. Along these lines, the Department of Justice must, in allits pattern-and-practice investigations, assess how law enforcement agencies treat gender-based crime. As a first step toward this, the Department of Justice should call out the Memphis Police Department for its profound failure to investigate cases of sexual assault. Doing so will increase women’s trust in law enforcement, stop the brazen behavior of perpetrators who too often escape punishment, and move us closer to a world where women like Alicia Franklin and Eliza Fletcher are safer from violence.
Tweet Share Share Comment(责任编辑:新闻中心)
- 13 Places to Find Little Legends and Compact Cryptids
- Atletico close in on Real Madrid
- European tour wins legal battle
- Spy chief denies illegal surveillance on court's impeachment ruling
- How much for Oasis tickets? Fans joke about splurging on reunion shows
- Google is bringing AI summaries to ‘Files’ so you can find your docs quicker
- Atletico close in on Real Madrid
- Apple needs to make it easier to manage subscriptions on iOS
- North Korea launches short
- 特写|在农事定向大赛遇见和美乡村
- 大湾区“芒”起来!百色芒果及壮山农鲜专场推介会将在广州启幕
- Samsung's 108
- Prince Harry joins the U.S. work force to...fight misinformation?
-
Foreign, multicultural students rise amid declining school population
(Getty Image)The number of Korean students in kindergarten, elementary, middle and high school natio ...[详细] -
Last week, Chinese smartphone maker Xiaomi hinted it would launch a phone with a 108-megapixel camer ...[详细]
-
House committee passes reauthorization act on North Korean human rights
U.S. Rep. Young Kim speaks during a meeting with South Korea's Unification Minister Kim Yung-ho in S ...[详细] -
The simple reason Apple AirPods will be ubiquitous someday
After I tried out AirPods at Apple’s big launch event last September, I said I couldn’t ...[详细] -
[Graphic News] Average book price nears 20,000 won
The cost of purchasing a book in South Korea is approaching 20,000 won ($14.80), according to recent ...[详细] -
White House: THAAD deployment 'national security matter' for S. Korea, Japan
The deployment of the US THAAD missile defense system is a "national security matter" for South Kore ...[详细] -
村K首唱!肇庆海选赛“燃”起来 | 2024广东乡村歌手大赛_南方+_南方plus♫唱村K,话村美,秀出村风采!♫7月27日-28日晚7点2024广东乡村歌手大赛肇庆赛区海选赛将在广宁县迎·LIVE ...[详细]
-
House committee passes reauthorization act on North Korean human rights
U.S. Rep. Young Kim speaks during a meeting with South Korea's Unification Minister Kim Yung-ho in S ...[详细] -
Understanding Relational vs. Non
Relational databases and non-relational databases primarily differ in the types of data they store a ...[详细] -
雅安日报讯日前,记者从荥经县地方税务局获悉,截至2011年3月28日,该局共受理了39位年所得12万元以上纳税人纳税申报,为去年申报人数的103%,为市局下达任务数的103%,圆满完成了2010年度年 ...[详细]
How much will PCB's Champions Cup mentors be paid?
Madhu Muhammadan FC clinch Naya Nazimabad Ramzan Cup
- 12 Sculptures Made From Recycled Materials
- 荥经地税 圆满完成个人所得税自行申报
- Madhu Muhammadan FC clinch Naya Nazimabad Ramzan Cup
- Atletico close in on Real Madrid
- Naver, Kakao strive to combat deepfake porn spreading online
- North Korea slams planned South Korea
- Amazon should be excited about the FAA's latest milestone for drones