Want to try Bluesky? Look carefully at the terms of service.
If you're on Twitter, you've probably seen people flocking to Bluesky, a social platform hailed as a promising alternative to the now-ailing bird app. It looks nearly identical to Twitter, was initially funded by Twitter, and calls itself a "social network for microblogging" which, huh, is funny because that's exactly what Twitter is. Anyway! Before you go running for Bluesky's greener pastures, it’s important to know what you’re agreeing to when you sign up for the platform.
Bluesky currently owns everything you post
On Thursday Apr. 27, Twitter user Ashley Gjøvik tweeted about Bluesky's disconcertingly broad terms of service. She tweeted several screenshots of the terns, including a snippet that reads "If you post any content to the Bluesky Web Services, you hereby grant Bluesky and its licensees a worldwide, perpetual, royalty-free, non-exclusive right and license to use, reproduce, publicly display, publicly perform, modify, sublicense, and distribute the content, on or in connection with the Bluesky Web Services."
In plain English that means: we own everything you post.
Rose Wang, who works in Strategy and Operations at Bluesky according to her LinkedIn profile, replied to Gjøvik's screenshots with an explanation of how Bluesky's team intends to interpret the terms: "In order for us to operate, we need to be able to promote the app," wrote Wang.
"That means, we will take screenshots of Bluesky, which will include your users’ content. That said, we have explicitly told our community that if we are using your content in a way you disapprove of, please email us... and we’ll do our best to honor your wishes. Bluesky was created so that users own their data, devs will never be locked out of the ecosystem, and creators can always own the relationship with their users... Thus, we are doing our best as [a] team to honor our ethos... Soon, our ToS will spell out use cases to mitigate confusion."
That all sounds nice. But Terms of Service agreements amount to a binding contract, and tweets claiming a company is "doing [its] best" to use your content a certain way do not.
These terms are harsh, even compared to Facebook
Let's take a look at Facebook's terms of service, which are much more nuanced in their explanation of user rights. "You retain ownership of the intellectual property rights," the terms page reads. "Nothing in these Terms takes away the rights you have to your own content... However, to provide our services we need you to give us some legal permissions (known as a 'license') to use this content."
The Facebook terms document then outlines what is covered by the license, and notes that it only applies "specifically when you share, post, or upload content that is covered by intellectual property rights on or in connection with our Products." The document also provides a helpful example: if you post a photo, you grant Facebook certain necessary permissions, allowing Facebook's parent company Meta to duplicate it, store it, and share it with others in ways "consistent with your settings." Reassuringly, it notes that the license you grant "will end when your content is deleted from our systems."
Bluesky may just be protecting itself because it's new
In comparison to Facebook's terms, Bluesky's read like a first draft put in place to satisfy a legal team, probably so the platform could start onboarding users and, for her part, the CEO has claimed this is essentially what happened. You know what they say in tech: move fast, break things, and claim ownership of your users' content!
Wang's replies point to another sticky subject: copyright. "We must protect ourselves," she wrote. Journalists, according to Wang, have been "taking screenshots of the app and putting it into their publications," and the terms need to make it possible to "transfer rights to license content to them." In the case of moderation, Wang said, copyright once again comes into play. Bluesky must be able to legally transfer content to moderators "so that they can scan through content" and sift out objectionable material.
These terms might have downsides for Bluesky itself
But owning user content, and being able to transfer rights to that content, may mean BlueSky is not protected by the "safe harbor" provisions of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA). Under the DMCA, safe harbor protection goes away if a company has the "right and ability to control" copyright-infringing content and can potentially profit off of it. That means these terms leave Bluesky vulnerable to costly copyright infringement litigation, which would sap the fledgling app's potential.
For all its promise, Bluesky is still very much a work in progress. And while it's never fun to read the fine print, it's worth taking a quick look before handing over your content to Bluesky.
Mashable has reached out to Bluesky's CEO for comment, and will update if we hear back.
(责任编辑:新闻中心)
- Best smart home deals this week at Amazon
- N. Korea's Kim Jong
- A real 'Will & Grace' revival series is finally in the works
- Olympic figure skater performs to Beyoncé's 'Run the World (Girls)'
- iPhone 16 Pro new color will reportedly be Desert Titanium
- “精致小春姐”顾春芳:华丽白西装、镶钻水晶拖鞋,带来新兴凉果No.1
- This very formal letter is the perfect response to a dick pic
- Del Potro set for 'farewell' at Argentina Open
- Apple publishes list of cars that can wirelessly charge your iPhone 8
- Supercritical geothermal power: Limitless promise or impossible dream?
- 雅安市发布地质灾害气象风险预警
- Here's 1 emoji you definitely shouldn't tweet at J.K. Rowling
- 端午将至市民忙着包粽子
-
With a new GPU generation not so far away, and new graphics cards coming from all three major chipma ...[详细]
-
Former 'comfort women' declare recent deal with Japan null
A group of former "comfort women" declared Wednesday the nullification of the recent South Korea-Jap ...[详细] -
MoonPie Twitter has evolved to making dad jokes
The MoonPie Twitter account, known for being one of the most absurd brands on Twitter, is at it agai ...[详细] -
雅安日报讯 记者获悉,刚刚结束的四川省第一届全民健身运动会体育舞蹈国际舞)比赛上,我市参赛小选手们一举夺得标准舞团体舞冠军。吴博文、周子均拿下了标准舞比赛组的金牌;姚传升、白雪洁获得了标准舞比赛组的 ...[详细]
-
八仙帽精美的刺绣作品周学琼左)、唐伟欣右)在门口刺绣藏彝走廊东部边缘的石棉县,在横断山脉的褶皱、隆起与断裂,以及河流的急剧切割作用下,群山峡谷中藏着一个藏族秘境——蟹螺堡子。石头和泥土砌成的房屋展示着 ...[详细]
-
Why you should stop laughing at Trump over a stock market correction
Repeat after me: The Dow Jones Industrial Average is not the stock market. The stock market is not t ...[详细] -
Ahn names new party People’s Party
Independent Rep. Ahn Cheol-soo announced Friday that his new party would be named People’s Party (En ...[详细] -
'Plogging' is a Swedish fitness trend that combines running with picking up litter
Forget about Hygge, Lagom, and Ikea's attempt to start a twin duvet revolution. There's a new Scandi ...[详细] -
By the time I tapped out of Persona 5after 60 hours of a massive high school adventure that I was en ...[详细]
-
Here's 1 emoji you definitely shouldn't tweet at J.K. Rowling
J.K. Rowling often goes after people on Twitter, but usually she reserves her magical takedowns for ...[详细]
- Keurig K Mini deal — get $30 off at Target
- South fires warning shots at suspected N. Korean drone
- Canada's Parrot ready to fly at Beijing Games
- Here's 1 emoji you definitely shouldn't tweet at J.K. Rowling
- How to trademark your TikTok phrase and protect your brand
- 19个市(州)703名运动员参赛
- 'Plogging' is a Swedish fitness trend that combines running with picking up litter