[News analysis] Experts skeptical of Moon’s claim of de facto end
Debate has been sparked among experts over President Moon Jae-in’s recent remarks that the US and North Korea have effectively agreed to end the Korean War with the recent meeting of their leaders at Panmunjom.
On Sunday, US President Donald Trump and North Korean leader Kim Jong-un created fresh momentum for stalled denuclearization talks with symbolic gestures, such as shaking hands on the North’s side of the Demilitarized Zone separating the two Koreas and then crossing together to the South’s side.
US President Donald Trump shakes hands with North Korean leader Kim Jong-un as they meet at the demilitarized zone separating the two Koreas, in Panmunjom, South Korea, Sunday. (KCNA)
They held a meeting for about an hour at Freedom House, a building on the southern side of the truce village of Panmunjom, and agreed to resume working level-talks on a denuclearization deal.
Describing the meeting as having ushered in “the beginning of a full-fledged peace era,” President Moon said in a Cabinet meeting Tuesday, “Although they did not sign any document, their action was tantamount to the de facto declaration of an end to hostile relations.”
Some local media outlets interpreted the president’s remarks as his view that Washington and Pyongyang have now declared an end to the 1950-1953 Korean War, which was halted only with an armistice.
Senior Presidential Secretary for Civil Affairs Cho Kuk had also called the Trump-Kim meeting “a historic day that practically declared an end of the war,” on his Facebook account Sunday.
Given that the US general representing the United Nations Command and a North Korean general representing the Korean People’s Army and the Chinese People’s Volunteer Army signed an armistice 66 years ago at Panmunjom, the crossing of the Military Demarcation Line does appear to have diplomatic and political significance.
However, opposition parties and analysts have criticized Moon for overstating the significance of Sunday’s meeting, asserting that it still has not yielded any substantive progress in the North’s denuclearization.
Sohn Hak-kyu, the head of the minor opposition Bareunmirae Party, said that Moon was being overly optimistic in effectively assessing actions by Trump and Kim as a declaration of an end to the Korean War.
“In light of the complexity of the North Korean nuclear issue, the end-of-war declaration and peace on the Korean Peninsula cannot be realized merely by the fact that US President Trump has stepped onto North Korean soil,” he said Wednesday.
Moon has advocated an end-of-war declaration to build trust between Washington and Pyongyang and persuade the North to move toward giving up its nuclear weapons.
The Moon administration initially pushed for a trilateral agreement by South Korea, North Korea and the US for the declaration, but has since changed course to forge two separate bilateral agreements -- one between the two Koreas and the other between the US and North Korea -- after facing strong opposition from US hawks.
Seoul, for its part, signed a military agreement with Pyongyang in September last year to cease all hostile acts against each other, which the North Korean leader and South Korean officials touted as tantamount to a nonaggression treaty.
“A de facto agreement is good. But what we can call a declaration is a de jure agreement that requires an official statement, said Kim Jin-a, research fellow at the Korea Institute for Defense Analyses.
The president’s remarks appear to emphasize the circumstances of the Panmunjom meeting and previous statements from the US aimed at overcoming tensions and hostilities between the two countries could be seen as a de facto agreement, she said.
“It seems like officials in Cheong Wa Dae hold a constructivism perspective, thinking that if these kind of messages (Moon’s remark) continue to accumulate, people will come to perceive it as reality,” Kim said.
But the signing of an official statement between Washington and Pyongyang would face steep political hurdles in the US, Kim said.
US officials and analysts have been expressing concerns that the North may demand the withdrawal of 28,500 US troops from the South when an end to the war is declared.
For the Trump-Kim meeting to be seen as an agreement on ending the war, there should have been messages regarding a peace regime on the Korean Peninsula, said Shin Beom-chul, director of the Center for Security and Unification at the Asan Institute for Policy Studies.
“It (the president’s remarks) was excessively optimistic. There was no comment on the armistice or how they would replace the armistice with a formal peace treaty,” he said.
Analysts said that discussions on a peace regime are unlikely to move forward when denuclearization is not making progress as the South and the US want the two goals to be achieved simultaneously.
Asked whether the US and North Korea discussed an end-of-war declaration when Trump and Kim met Sunday, a high-ranking Cheong Wa Dae official told reporters Wednesday that he would share more details on what took place at the meeting at the right time.
(hnpark@heraldcorp.com)
On Sunday, US President Donald Trump and North Korean leader Kim Jong-un created fresh momentum for stalled denuclearization talks with symbolic gestures, such as shaking hands on the North’s side of the Demilitarized Zone separating the two Koreas and then crossing together to the South’s side.
They held a meeting for about an hour at Freedom House, a building on the southern side of the truce village of Panmunjom, and agreed to resume working level-talks on a denuclearization deal.
Describing the meeting as having ushered in “the beginning of a full-fledged peace era,” President Moon said in a Cabinet meeting Tuesday, “Although they did not sign any document, their action was tantamount to the de facto declaration of an end to hostile relations.”
Some local media outlets interpreted the president’s remarks as his view that Washington and Pyongyang have now declared an end to the 1950-1953 Korean War, which was halted only with an armistice.
Senior Presidential Secretary for Civil Affairs Cho Kuk had also called the Trump-Kim meeting “a historic day that practically declared an end of the war,” on his Facebook account Sunday.
Given that the US general representing the United Nations Command and a North Korean general representing the Korean People’s Army and the Chinese People’s Volunteer Army signed an armistice 66 years ago at Panmunjom, the crossing of the Military Demarcation Line does appear to have diplomatic and political significance.
However, opposition parties and analysts have criticized Moon for overstating the significance of Sunday’s meeting, asserting that it still has not yielded any substantive progress in the North’s denuclearization.
Sohn Hak-kyu, the head of the minor opposition Bareunmirae Party, said that Moon was being overly optimistic in effectively assessing actions by Trump and Kim as a declaration of an end to the Korean War.
“In light of the complexity of the North Korean nuclear issue, the end-of-war declaration and peace on the Korean Peninsula cannot be realized merely by the fact that US President Trump has stepped onto North Korean soil,” he said Wednesday.
Moon has advocated an end-of-war declaration to build trust between Washington and Pyongyang and persuade the North to move toward giving up its nuclear weapons.
The Moon administration initially pushed for a trilateral agreement by South Korea, North Korea and the US for the declaration, but has since changed course to forge two separate bilateral agreements -- one between the two Koreas and the other between the US and North Korea -- after facing strong opposition from US hawks.
Seoul, for its part, signed a military agreement with Pyongyang in September last year to cease all hostile acts against each other, which the North Korean leader and South Korean officials touted as tantamount to a nonaggression treaty.
“A de facto agreement is good. But what we can call a declaration is a de jure agreement that requires an official statement, said Kim Jin-a, research fellow at the Korea Institute for Defense Analyses.
The president’s remarks appear to emphasize the circumstances of the Panmunjom meeting and previous statements from the US aimed at overcoming tensions and hostilities between the two countries could be seen as a de facto agreement, she said.
“It seems like officials in Cheong Wa Dae hold a constructivism perspective, thinking that if these kind of messages (Moon’s remark) continue to accumulate, people will come to perceive it as reality,” Kim said.
But the signing of an official statement between Washington and Pyongyang would face steep political hurdles in the US, Kim said.
US officials and analysts have been expressing concerns that the North may demand the withdrawal of 28,500 US troops from the South when an end to the war is declared.
For the Trump-Kim meeting to be seen as an agreement on ending the war, there should have been messages regarding a peace regime on the Korean Peninsula, said Shin Beom-chul, director of the Center for Security and Unification at the Asan Institute for Policy Studies.
“It (the president’s remarks) was excessively optimistic. There was no comment on the armistice or how they would replace the armistice with a formal peace treaty,” he said.
Analysts said that discussions on a peace regime are unlikely to move forward when denuclearization is not making progress as the South and the US want the two goals to be achieved simultaneously.
Asked whether the US and North Korea discussed an end-of-war declaration when Trump and Kim met Sunday, a high-ranking Cheong Wa Dae official told reporters Wednesday that he would share more details on what took place at the meeting at the right time.
(hnpark@heraldcorp.com)
(责任编辑:行业动态)
相关内容
- When will Trump and Harris debate? The presidential campaigns snipe over ABC News’ rules.
- Quartararo looking forward to Spanish MotoGP
- Footballers recruited for dementia study
- Ronaldo salvages point for Man Utd against Chelsea
- 抖音超600万次传播量!广东省农事运动会乡村直播大赛火出圈
- Ruling bloc seeks tougher sentences for deepfake sex crimes
- Diana using football knowledge in cricket
- F1 to renew push for six sprint races
- North Korean leader arrives home after summit
- I Deleted All My Social Accounts: Three Weeks Without Social Media
- F1 to renew push for six sprint races
- 市民:商品房质量保修有什么规定?
- Number of full
推荐文章
-
Pranks can be awesome. They are one of those few things in life that most people can unequivocally a ...[详细]
-
Spyware creator arrested for allegedly creeping on thousands for 13 years
The culprit behind the creepy spyware Fruitfly was nabbed finally -- after 13 years.A 28-year-old Oh ...[详细] -
Defense Ministry dismisses N.K.’s missile claim
South Korea’s Defense Ministry on Tuesday cast doubts on North Korea’s ability to ensure that its in ...[详细] -
Kim Kardashian West said she wants President Trump 'to win' and people are not happy
In May, Kim Kardashian West met with President Donald Trump in a successful effort to free a great-g ...[详细] -
What to expect from Apple's September event: iPhone 16, Apple Watch 10, and more
Apple's big September event is fast approaching, bringing us all the latest gadget goodies from the ...[详细] -
North Korean media staff in Vietnam [PHOTOS]
A North Korean media representative films in front of the Sofitel Legend Metropole Hanoi, the venue ...[详细] -
Seoul envoy to U.N. warns of tougher sanctions for additional N.K. provocations
A top South Korean envoy to the United Nations warned Monday that the international organization cou ...[详细] -
Gov't beefs up railway security amid North Korean threats
The government said Thursday it will install a thermographic camera on South Korea's main railway br ...[详细] -
Séamus Malekafzali ,July 23, 2024 Netanyah ...[详细]
-
市民:商品房质量保修有什么规定? 市房管局:《建设工程质量管理条例》《房屋建筑工程质量保修办法》对商品房质量保修有明确规定,只是对商品房的不同部位有不同的保修期限。购房人在买商品房时,一定要在《商品 ...[详细]
热点阅读
随机内容
Best Labor Day headphones deals: Apple, Bose, Beats, and more on sale
Woman saves 'sabretooth squirrel' from its own terrible teeth
- 护航孩子成长 解决职工后顾之忧
- Footballers recruited for dementia study
- 'Overwatch' hero Symmetra is getting a complete overhaul
- GoPro announces layoffs, end of drone business
- 'Hyundai Way': Auto giant's W121tr plan aims to seize mobility market lead
- North Korean leader to leave Hanoi on Saturday morning: source
- A college course about Frank Ocean comes to UC Berkeley this fall