Fox and Dominion settlement: It's actually fine there's no trial.
What does the Fox (News) say? Not enough to save American democracy. But we never should have expected that a private defamation suit could have cured this country’s ongoing election panic anyways.
Dominion Voting Systems had sued Fox for defamation after Fox hosts and guests lied about the supposed role of Dominion’s voting machines in the 2020 presidential election. (Specifically, they said that the company rigged the votes against Donald Trump and for Joe Biden.) Voting machine manipulation was one of many outlandish conspiracy theories—like those involving Italian space lasers or fake ballots coming in from China—that swirled across right wing cable television and social media as Donald Trump churned up the lies to try to overturn his loss.
AdvertisementBy the time the Dominion defamation case got to trial, Fox had a weak hand. Embarrassing depositions, emails, and other material from inside Fox showed that those at the top of the company knew the claims of a stolen election were a huge lie unsupported by any real evidence. The trial judge had already ruled, before trial, that the evidence indisputably showed that claims of Dominion voting machines being rigged were false, and that Fox was not merely reporting on such claims. The only real issue (aside from which Fox entities were liable and how much damage Dominion suffered) was whether Fox made false statements with “actual malice.” That standard, imposed by the Supreme Court to protect journalists and others reporting on public officials and public figures, requires proof that the speaker made the statements knowingthey were false or with reckless disregard as to their truth or falsity.
Ultimately, Dominion agreed to a whopping a $787.5 million settlement from Fox in its defamation suit just as opening arguments in the trial were about to begin. Those damages more than compensate for any loss of reputation suffered by Dominion. What the settlement did not come with was a requirement of an apology or any on-air recognition directed to Fox’s cocooned viewers. No statement by the conservative-turned-Trumpy network that it had been shoveling manure for Trump and others when it came to the 2020 election. The most that the public will get is this anodyne sentence in the middle of Fox’s one-paragraph statement: “We acknowledge the Court’s rulings finding certain claims about Dominion to be false.” The sentence came right before Fox, with unparalleled chutzpah, praised its own “continued commitment to the highest journalistic standards.”
Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementSome who wanted more out of this case were sorely disappointed. Journalism professor and columnist Margaret Sullivan tweeted: “Dominion should have insisted on an apology, including prominently on air. They could have gotten it from F[o]x, which was feeling desperate (in my view). It would have been in the public interest.” Before the settlement, liberal Twitter was full of similar sentiments urging Dominion not to settle so that more embarrassing truths would have come out. How great it would have been, they argued, to get Fox leader Rupert Murdoch under oath on cross examination.
While Murdoch testimony may have been better than an episode of Succession, we should abandon the idea that a single trial full of embarrassing details would change beliefs about a stolen 2020 election. Even if Fox agreed to a two-minute on-air crow eating by Sean Hannity or Tucker Carlson, it would not have moved the needle. In poll after poll, the base of the Republican Party continues to express belief in a stolen 2020 election, a message that was repeated not just by Fox but by Trump himself, on television, social media, and elsewhere. It is supported by a constellation of grifty people lying about the American election system for profit and political power. Indeed, when Fox was the first out of the box to call the 2020 election for Biden after their decision desk determined he was going to win in Arizona, Fox viewers did not suddenly accept Biden’s victory; they instead switched over to One America News Network or Newsmax to hear happier lies. It was that ratings pressure that caused Fox to amplify the false statements in the first place.
Advertisement AdvertisementThere will be more defamation suits to come, too: one from Smartmatic and another involving Atlanta election workers Wandrea Moss and her mother Ruby Freeman, who were falsely accused by Trump allies and the Gateway Pundit website of engaging in election fraud. They may help the public understand the lies a bit better, and I hope they lead to very generous awards for Moss and Freeman, who have faced harassment and threats for years.
AdvertisementDefamation is just a limited tool to deal with this social problem. Most of the statements Trump made about the election being stolen could not even be subject to a defamation suit despite their falsity because they did not injure the reputation of anyone in particular. Falsely saying the election is “rigged” is an attack on the system as a whole, not on someone who is an identifiable plaintiff. Think of stolen election claims more like creating a “vibe” than stating a falsifiable fact.
AdvertisementMuch more needs to be done to counter the Big Lie vibe. Among the most important things is campaigning and voting against the politicians who embrace such lies. Early studies show that election deniers who ran for office underperformed in the 2022 midterms. When enough Republicans learn that running on a stolen election platform is a recipe for losing, they will start giving up on those claims.
Advertisement AdvertisementPopular in News & Politics
- A Supreme Court Justice Gave Us Alarming New Evidence That He’s Living in MAGA World
- Ten Years Ago, His Book About Civilizational Collapse Got Unexpectedly Popular. He’s Back With a Little Bit of Hope.
- Sure Sounds Like the Supreme Court Is About to Give Trump a Big Win!
- We’ve Been Entertaining an Illusion About the Supreme Court. It’s Finally Been Shattered.
Social media companies have no obligation to amplify election lies on their platforms. Meta and Twitter are moving in the wrong direction in many ways, but at least Meta has taken the position that it may remove Trump again if he starts lying about election integrity in 2024.
Congress and the states also need to provide a lot more money so that election officials can run free and fair elections. Without enough funds, election officials are more apt to make mistakes, and in a poisonous atmosphere, those mistakes metastasize into new conspiracy theories. And our leaders need to deal with ongoing threats of violence against election officials and poll workers, and to stop the exodus of talented election workers who just cannot take the abuse anymore.
Sure, there would have been some visceral satisfaction in seeing Fox executives squirm on the stand. But that squirming would not have been covered on Fox News itself, or likely broken the fever gripping parts of America.
The Dominion lawsuit did some good in getting us irrefutable proof that Fox executives knew they were lying about the 2020 election being stolen. More of this would be good. But it is not nearly enough to safeguard our democracy.
Tweet Share Share Comment(责任编辑:产品中心)
-
9 Planetariums to Get Lost in the Cosmos
The constellations, planets, and moons that make up the night sky feel far from human reach—because ...[详细] -
雅安日报/北纬网讯2日,世行贷款芦山地震灾后恢复重建项目中期检查工作启动会召开,听取世行贷款雅安灾后恢复重建城建基础设施项目,及世行贷款灾后恢复重建农村公路项目工作情况的汇报,对项目中期调整工作提出具 ...[详细]
-
中国山东网青岛11月10日讯(记者 刘淑红 通讯员 张刚) 中国电子检验检疫主干系统(以下简称“主干系统”)在山东的上线运行,有效助推山东进出口企业迈上了通关“高速 ...[详细]
-
近日,招商银行发布最新小微贷款数据,今年小微企业贷款累计投放已超过3000亿元,有力支持实体经济。自2012年招行小微业务起步以来,经过近4年的快速发展,截至目前小微贷款客户已达43万户,成为中国最大 ...[详细]
-
10 Places to Get to Know Paul Bunyan
Paul Bunyan, a larger-than-life lumberjack with super-human strength, was a character created by Can ...[详细] -
雅安日报/北纬网讯11月19日是第7个“世界厕所日”,荥经县幼儿园结合实际,加大宣传力度,强化常规教育,落实管理责任,扎实推进校园“厕所革命”。他们利用电子显示屏,制作厕所健康卫生知识专题宣传栏,张贴 ...[详细]
-
131个推广项目入选广东省农业技术推广奖_南方+_南方plus近日,省农业农村厅发布《关于2022年度广东省农业技术推广奖获奖项目的通报》以下简称《通报》)。根据《广东省农业技术推广奖励试行办法》《广 ...[详细]
-
雅安日报/北纬网讯11月13日,农业农村部网站公示2019年中国美丽休闲乡村名单,260个村落上榜,四川有8个村,汉源县九襄镇三强村名列其中。三强村位于九襄镇东侧,雅西高速公路九襄站出口连接线旁,距高 ...[详细]
-
Webb telescope discovers 6 rogue worlds. They didn't form the way you'd expect.
Sometimes, planets go rogue. Scientists used the powerful James Webb Space Telescope to spot six of ...[详细] -
冬日音乐会,甘薯是绝配!陆丰甘薯集市火力全开送“甜蜜”_南方+_南方plus冬天,是吃甘薯的季节,来上一块烤到流蜜的陆丰甘薯,软糯甜蜜,从舌尖一路暖到心尖。“吃了几种甘薯,我最喜欢板栗薯,软糯可口还很 ...[详细]