Trump's words on N. Korea do not reflect US policies
This is the third in a series of interviews with international experts to seek ways toward a peaceful resolution for the North Korean nuclear crisis on the occasion of the 67th anniversary of The Korea Times, which falls on Nov. 1. ― ED.
By Kim Jae-kyoung
U.S. President Donald Trump is often criticized for his inflammatory rhetoric on North Korea.
Many argue his reckless words have complicated the situation and escalated tension on the Korean Peninsula, raising the possibility of Pyongyang making a miscalculation which could lead to a military conflict.
Balbina Hwang, a former special adviser to the U.S. State Department, said people should not put too much weight on Trump's improvised rhetoric because it does not mirror the U.S.'s official policies on North Korea.
She added it is also important to recognize Pyongyang's nuclear weapons development and missile tests are the source of rising tensions on the peninsula, not U.S. rhetoric or policies.
"Trump's tweets and other utterances should be interpreted within the context they are meant as rhetorical statements that may reflect his personal feelings at any given time, but are not necessarily reflective of official U.S. policies," she said in a recent interview.
She said U.S. policies are more carefully and judiciously crafted by a deliberative and collaborative process which includes professional diplomats, military strategists and national security experts.
"So what matters more are the official policies and actual actions implemented rather than the rhetoric," said Hwang, a visiting professor at Georgetown University's Center for Security Studies.
"Indeed, the same principle applies to the North Korean leadership. We should pay more careful attention to the North's actions and official policies rather than the fiery rhetoric."
She explained official U.S. policy continues to be that diplomacy is still the first and primary policy choice, but it will be supported by strong pressure to demonstrate to Pyongyang its continued violations of international principles will not be tolerated.
The Washington-based North Korea expert pointed out that the Kim Jong-un regime has not changed its attitude even under the leadership of President Moon Jae-in, who clearly offered a very different tone and attitude toward North Korea.
"Thus, it seems clear the responsibility for the lack of diplomatic or a negotiated path toward resolution of tensions lies with North Korea, and not with other parties, such as the U.S. or South Korea," she said.
NK's calculation
Hwang, who served as a special adviser on East Asian affairs for the George W. Bush administration, believes it is not a good idea to take military options off the table to appease Kim Jong-un.
"Ultimately, a final resolution of the nuclear issue is not likely to succeed unless the military option becomes acceptable for all parties, or at a minimum both the U.S. and South Korea," she said.
According to her analysis, the nuclear issue is not the cause of tensions on the peninsula, but a product of the underlying causes of instability _ the unresolved status of the Korean War, and the division of Korea.
In this regard, as long as South and North Korea continue to exist in fundamental opposition to the other, there cannot be peace on the Korean Peninsula.
"Thus, the only way to secure peace is to bring the Korean War to a permanent end," she said.
She emphasized that since the Armistice is a military agreement that only technically stopped the military conflict, and included the agreement that a permanent "political" solution should be reached, any negotiations with the North must focus on returning to the existing Armistice, and working on its expansion and completion.
"Attempting to start with negotiations focused on nuclear weapons, which North Korea has insisted is not possible, will only revive the cycle of the incomplete processes already attempted for the last two decades," she said.
The former research fellow for the Institute for National Security Strategy in Seoul said diplomacy and negotiations are unlikely to resolve the North Korea nuclear crisis as Pyongyang remains lukewarm to any dialogue.
Kim Jong-un has refused to engage with China, its traditional ally, in any high-level dialogue.
The young dictator has also made it consistently clear that while he has not ruled out dialogue with the U.S. in principle, its nuclear weapons programs are absolutely not on the table for discussion.
"Thus, the impasse in resuming any dialogue remains. Diplomacy and negotiations only work if all the relevant parties are willing to actually engage in the process," she said.
"Similarly, in contemplating the possibility of a peaceful resolution, this depends entirely on the willingness of all parties to commit to such an outcome."
While it seems the North also prefers a peaceful resolution, it has shown no actual willingness to pursue such a process, as it continues instead with aggressive actions.
"It is likely Pyongyang has calculated that the other parties' preference for avoiding a military solution is much too costly and they ultimately will stop short of pursuing this final option," she said.
By Kim Jae-kyoung
Balbina Hwang |
Many argue his reckless words have complicated the situation and escalated tension on the Korean Peninsula, raising the possibility of Pyongyang making a miscalculation which could lead to a military conflict.
Balbina Hwang, a former special adviser to the U.S. State Department, said people should not put too much weight on Trump's improvised rhetoric because it does not mirror the U.S.'s official policies on North Korea.
She added it is also important to recognize Pyongyang's nuclear weapons development and missile tests are the source of rising tensions on the peninsula, not U.S. rhetoric or policies.
"Trump's tweets and other utterances should be interpreted within the context they are meant as rhetorical statements that may reflect his personal feelings at any given time, but are not necessarily reflective of official U.S. policies," she said in a recent interview.
She said U.S. policies are more carefully and judiciously crafted by a deliberative and collaborative process which includes professional diplomats, military strategists and national security experts.
"So what matters more are the official policies and actual actions implemented rather than the rhetoric," said Hwang, a visiting professor at Georgetown University's Center for Security Studies.
"Indeed, the same principle applies to the North Korean leadership. We should pay more careful attention to the North's actions and official policies rather than the fiery rhetoric."
She explained official U.S. policy continues to be that diplomacy is still the first and primary policy choice, but it will be supported by strong pressure to demonstrate to Pyongyang its continued violations of international principles will not be tolerated.
The Washington-based North Korea expert pointed out that the Kim Jong-un regime has not changed its attitude even under the leadership of President Moon Jae-in, who clearly offered a very different tone and attitude toward North Korea.
"Thus, it seems clear the responsibility for the lack of diplomatic or a negotiated path toward resolution of tensions lies with North Korea, and not with other parties, such as the U.S. or South Korea," she said.
NK's calculation
Hwang, who served as a special adviser on East Asian affairs for the George W. Bush administration, believes it is not a good idea to take military options off the table to appease Kim Jong-un.
"Ultimately, a final resolution of the nuclear issue is not likely to succeed unless the military option becomes acceptable for all parties, or at a minimum both the U.S. and South Korea," she said.
According to her analysis, the nuclear issue is not the cause of tensions on the peninsula, but a product of the underlying causes of instability _ the unresolved status of the Korean War, and the division of Korea.
In this regard, as long as South and North Korea continue to exist in fundamental opposition to the other, there cannot be peace on the Korean Peninsula.
"Thus, the only way to secure peace is to bring the Korean War to a permanent end," she said.
She emphasized that since the Armistice is a military agreement that only technically stopped the military conflict, and included the agreement that a permanent "political" solution should be reached, any negotiations with the North must focus on returning to the existing Armistice, and working on its expansion and completion.
"Attempting to start with negotiations focused on nuclear weapons, which North Korea has insisted is not possible, will only revive the cycle of the incomplete processes already attempted for the last two decades," she said.
The former research fellow for the Institute for National Security Strategy in Seoul said diplomacy and negotiations are unlikely to resolve the North Korea nuclear crisis as Pyongyang remains lukewarm to any dialogue.
Kim Jong-un has refused to engage with China, its traditional ally, in any high-level dialogue.
The young dictator has also made it consistently clear that while he has not ruled out dialogue with the U.S. in principle, its nuclear weapons programs are absolutely not on the table for discussion.
"Thus, the impasse in resuming any dialogue remains. Diplomacy and negotiations only work if all the relevant parties are willing to actually engage in the process," she said.
"Similarly, in contemplating the possibility of a peaceful resolution, this depends entirely on the willingness of all parties to commit to such an outcome."
While it seems the North also prefers a peaceful resolution, it has shown no actual willingness to pursue such a process, as it continues instead with aggressive actions.
"It is likely Pyongyang has calculated that the other parties' preference for avoiding a military solution is much too costly and they ultimately will stop short of pursuing this final option," she said.
(责任编辑:新闻中心)
相关内容
- [Graphic News] Average book price nears 20,000 won
- Hundreds die in Iran from bootleg alcohol being peddled online as fake coronavirus remedy.
- NASA astronauts on Artemis could talk to a spaceship computer
- S. Korea to hold memorial event in Busan for UN war veterans
- Foreign, multicultural students rise amid declining school population
- Yoon, US Senate's armed service committee chief discuss alliance, N.K. threats
- Two Koreas to embark on inter
- Coronavirus Diaries: My partner is in prison, and I can’t visit.
- Hundreds die in Iran from bootleg alcohol being peddled online as fake coronavirus remedy.
- US Open 2024 livestream: How to watch US Open tennis for free
- TikTok is Twee now
- Elmo is the first viral celebrity of 2022
- Britain to face Australia in BJK Cup semi
推荐文章
-
中国科学院老科学家科普演讲团在雅开展科普讲座今年上半年,雅安市科协以科创筑梦,强化未成年人科学教育获佳绩为主题,以立德树人为目标,科学教育为抓手,从科普教育活动、科普教育阵地、青少年科技创新行动三个方 ...[详细]
-
Verstappen calls for overhaul of sprint races
SAO PAULO:Max Verstappen on Thursday led calls for a reform of 'sprint races' next season an ...[详细] -
2023粤合农产品云上农展@你来参与!粤合好物启动征集,点击查看更多惊喜
2023粤合农产品云上农展@你来参与!粤合好物启动征集,点击查看更多惊喜_南方+_南方plus知稼穑之艰难,而崇节俭之化。9月23日,是秋分,也是中国农民丰收节。我国几千年的农业生产,孕育了悠久而厚重 ...[详细] -
Police accelerate probe into Itaewon disaster
Yoon Hee-keun, the National Police Agency Commissioner General, speaks at the press conference, Tues ...[详细] -
Foreign, multicultural students rise amid declining school population
(Getty Image)The number of Korean students in kindergarten, elementary, middle and high school natio ...[详细] -
Strongman Medicine: North Korea still claims to have no coronavirus cases.
Popular in News & Politics The One Thing Donald Trump Can’t Escape i ...[详细] -
Bernie Sanders endorses Joe Biden.
Bernie Sanders endorsed Joe Biden in a split-screen livestream video on Monday afternoon, just five ...[详细] -
CDC calls on NY, NJ, and Connecticut residents to “refrain” from nonessential travel.
Popular in News & Politics The One Thing Donald Trump Can’t Escape i ...[详细] -
Pope says England are not 'one
MANCHESTER:England stand-in captain Ollie Pope said the team's cautious but successful run-chase ...[详细] -
雅安仁康医院雅安结石病医院)经过10多年不断发展,已成为一家科室设置齐全的二级乙等综合医院。为了进一步满足广大患者有针对性的就诊需求,雅安仁康医院增设了专家门诊,并于7月1日正式开诊。专家门诊由雅安仁 ...[详细]
热点阅读
随机内容
- Tesla Robotaxis aren't coming in August, it seems
- New unemployment report shows nearly 17 million Americans have now lost their jobs.
- Snapchat profiles will feature 3D full
- Milan stay on Napoli's tail
- [Exclusive] Samsung unsure of Suga's future as brand ambassador: source
- CDC calls on NY, NJ, and Connecticut residents to “refrain” from nonessential travel.
- Could the coronavirus lead to a global cease