The Republicans who voted for Merrick Garland in 1997 are against him now.
President Obama’s decision to nominate Merrick Garland to the Supreme Court will make things more than a little awkward for a number of Senate Republicans who have vowed they won’t even consider the nomination. Blindly denying a vote to Garland, by pretty much all accounts a respected and relatively moderate judge, could hurt those senators who are up for re-election in purple or blue states, like Pennsylvania’s Pat Toomey and New Hampshire’s Kelly Ayotte. More immediately, though, Obama’s choice will leave more than a half-dozen senators who voted to confirm Garland to his current position scrambling to justify their newfound opposition to him.
Exhibit A: Sen. Orrin Hatch, a senior member of the Judiciary Committee, the panel that would be responsible for holding confirmation hearings on Garland—that is, if Republican leadership had not already ruled those out. Hatch is one of seven Republicans still in the Senate who voted to confirm Garland back in 1997 to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit. Here is Hatch touting Garland’s qualifications on the Senate floor two decades ago:
AdvertisementAt the time, the Utah senator also called Garland “not only a fine nominee, but as good as Republicans can expect from [the Bill Clinton] administration.” In 2010, when Garland’s name was among those considered for the open Supreme Court slot that eventually went to Elena Kagan, Hatch said there was “no question” Garland could be confirmed if nominated. Flash forward to this past Friday, and Hatch was saying the same thing. “Obama could easily name Merrick Garland, who is a fine man,” he told the conservative website Newsmax on Friday while discussing the president’s impending announcement. Hatch then added: “He probably won’t do that because this appointment is about the election. So I’m pretty sure he’ll name someone the [liberal Democratic base] wants.”
Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementAnd how did Hatch react to news of Garland’s impending nomination on Wednesday morning? “The right course of action is to wait until the next year’s election to consider a nominee to fill Justice Scalia’s seat,” the Utah senator told CBS News. Ah yes, of course.
Hatch isn’t alone. Republicans John McCain, Arizona; Susan Collins, Maine; Pat Roberts, Kansas; James Inhofe, Oklahoma; Dan Coats, Indiana; and Thad Cochran, Mississippi, also voted to confirm Garland in 1997. Many of those senators haven’t weighed in yet, but the early returns don’t look promising for Garland:
Advertisement AdvertisementWhy did you vote for Garland in 1997? "I supported him," Pat Roberts said to me. Will you support him now? "It's not about the person."
— Manu Raju (@mkraju) March 16, 2016
Even many of the Republicans who voted against Garland at the time said it had nothing to do with his qualifications, but instead were driven by the Republican belief that the D.C. appeals court has too many seats. Here’s what then-and-current Judiciary Committee Chairman Chuck Grassley said at the time: “I have nothing against the nominee. Mr. Garland seems to be well qualified and would probably make a good judge—in some other court.” That other court is apparently not the Supreme. “A lifetime appointment that could dramatically impact individual freedoms and change the direction of the court for at least a generation is too important to get bogged down in politics,” Grassley said in a statement today. “The American people shouldn’t be denied a voice.”
Advertisement AdvertisementIn addition to Grassley, there are four other Republicans still serving in the Senate who voted against Garland back in 1997: Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, Jeff Sessions of Alabama, Richard Shelby of Alabama, and Mike Enzi of Wyoming. While their opposition was also about the size of the D.C. court and not the nominee himself, GOP leadership is already busy rewriting history. “This is an easy one. Both our leader and judiciary chairman voted against him when he was confirmed before and it’s a clear recognition by the White House that we mean what we say: There will be no confirmation,” a senior GOP aide told Politico. “If they thought we were going to cave, they would have put up a much different candidate.”
Read more on Obama’s nomination of Merrick Garland to the Supreme Court.
Tweet Share Share Comment(责任编辑:关于我们)
- Spaceship tech slashes energy usage of existing AC systems
- US Open dream over as Serena bows out
- Rainn Wilson called Elon Musk out after Tesla 'stole' his leaf blower idea
- North Korean media demands South Korea, US to stop joint military drills, withdraw American troops
- Top 10 Tech Pranks
- Alcaraz, Sinner survive US Open wobbles
- US reconnaissance drone spotted amid speculation North Korea preparing for military parade
- IAEA report puts pressure on Seoul's bid to restart peace initiative
- Mexico's Lopez wins LPGA Dana Open
- Scientists detect water sloshing on Mars. There could be a lot.
- 'Game of Thrones' followed Emilia Clarke to the Houston Rockets game
- A month after delivery boy's murder, Flipkart launches new SOS feature
- US Open dream over as Serena bows out
-
Noelle Mateer ,July 17, 2024 The Techies W ...[详细]
-
Pornhub reveals the most popular 'Avengers' searches
Anticipation over Avengers: Endgameis so high that Pornhub visitors are even searching for their fav ...[详细] -
Binotto and Sainz lament Ferrari's Dutch 'mess'
AMSTERDAM:Ferrari team boss Mattia Binotto and one of his drivers Carlos Sainz agreed their disastro ...[详细] -
Slack is about to get a lot less confusing with threaded messages
Slack just introduced a major update that promises to make conversations easier to follow. The workp ...[详细] -
Webb scientists haven't found a rocky world with air. But now they have a plan.
Perhaps surprisingly, the majority of stars in the galaxy are not sunclones but smaller orbs of gas ...[详细] -
North Korean leader chairs politburo meeting to discuss antivirus efforts, food shortage
In this photo released by North Korea's official Korean Central News Agency, North Korean leader Kim ...[详细] -
Argentina welcomes investment at independence celebration
The Argentine Embassy last week marked the country’s 200th anniversary of independence and its resur ...[详细] -
Clubs fined by UEFA for FFP breaches
LAUSANNE:Paris Saint-Germain, Inter Milan and Juventus are among clubs who were handed fines by UEFA ...[详细] -
Kamala Harris’ ridiculous problem with the political press.
Last Thursday, standing on the tarmac in Michigan in front of Air Force Two, Kamala Harris took some ...[详细] -
开车的师傅注意了,从4月1日起,酒后驾车将被一次性扣罚12分。按照公安部新修订的《机动车驾驶证申领和使用规定》,从4月1日起,凡100毫升血液中酒精含量大于等于20毫克的驾驶员将被认定为饮酒后驾车,将 ...[详细]
Tesla considers adding a new ‘stuck detection' feature to Cybertruck. Here’s why.
North Korea accuses US of involvement in anti
- Project 2025 Comstock Act: Trump’s new abortion comment exposed.
- North Korea accuses US of involvement in anti
- Pornhub reveals how ‘Star Wars’ fans are celebrating May the Fourth
- The cursed 'vegan lasagna' is simply not a lasagna
- 多措并举优治理 绘就幸福新图景
- Moth named after Donald Trump for uncanny resemblance
- 雅安发展需要榜样力量