Apple News' 2020 election hub shows promise despite a few missteps
On Monday, the Apple News app launched its 2020 election hub to coincide with the start of primary voting. And while there's a lot to love, there are some head-scratchers, as well.
Overall, the hub feels aimed at the average American who's kinda following the race more than your hardcore Bernie Bro or #YangGang member. And that's perfectly fine.
With live updates, important stories curated from a variety of sources, and profiles on candidates and issues central to the election, there's a simplicity to the hub that could actually connect with millions of voters who might not otherwise be paying attention. It's very reminiscent of Apple's 2018 effort, too.
Given the huge readership that Apple News claims – pegged at around 100 million as of earlier this year – there's real potential here for Apple News to become a major player in how people learn about the election and educate themselves on the issues.
That Apple will livestream Friday's Democratic primary debate is another huge win for the company's efforts to make it something of a one-stop news clearinghouse.
That's not to say the project is perfect. But in a time when social media platforms are twisting themselves into knots over what role they play in politics, there's hope that Apple may pull this off.
The Good
First, the layout is simple and easy to use with news at the top, candidate profiles in the middle, and election issues at the end. While some users may scoff at the giant icons used to differentiate the issues, I find the whole layout easy to understand and simple to navigate.
Credit: AppleThe issue pages themselves are pretty informative even if it's really hard to break down complex issues, like climate change or immigration, into shorter bites.
Also helpful is the way the issue pages break down each candidate's stance. Again, it's not perfect — these issues and positions always contain more nuance than can be given here (more on that in a minute). But if you're looking for a quick overview of a topic and a candidate's take, this is, at least, a helpful start.
As for the sources used to curate the news, Apple, thankfully, hasn't repeated Facebook's mistake by including extremist outlets like Breitbart in the mix. Instead, there's a solid mix of network, digital, and print sources with long histories of accurate and thorough news reporting.
In its press release about the launch, Apple notes the outlets it's using include "ABC News, CBS News, CNN, FiveThirtyEight, Fox News, NBC News, ProPublica, Reuters, The Los Angeles Times, The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal, The Washington Post, TIME, USA Today and others."
That the hub includes a misinformation guide from the News Literacy Project is also quite helpful when taking in this extensive list of sources.
Most of those outlets are great, legit news outlets that do outstanding reporting. Kudos to Apple, too, for including non-profit ProPublica in the mix. But, there's one inclusion that is, to put it mildly, questionable.
The Bad
We live in an incredibly politically charged time and we all carry with us some sort of inherent bias or subjectivity when it comes to the news outlets we read. And while the effort to be as objective as possible is a noble one, it's hard for a project like this to keep from undermining its own efforts.
Case in point: the inclusion of Fox News.
While it's true that there are legitimate journalists working at Fox (Chris Wallace and John Roberts have both built reputable careers across multiple outlets), the fact that the network has become a platform from which President Trump can spew disinformation and outright lies via pundits who kowtow to his whims is inescapable.
Whether it's the racism of Tucker Carlson or Laura Ingraham, or the conspiracy theories of Sean Hannity, there are plenty of reasons to question Fox News' authenticity as a citable source. This story from Vox on the many missteps the network had in one dayshould be enough reason to chuck them.
An Apple spokesperson didn't respond to a request for comment on Fox News' inclusion here.
Credit: AppleThen there's the complexity of the issues that are tackled in the hub. Again, I recognize it's hard to boil these topics down to a single page, but it's notable that, for instance, the immigration page makes only one reference to the Trump administration's family separation policy. And even that downplays the images of children in cages that were plastered across newspapers and newscasts for weeks.
Likewise, the gun policy issue page makes one passing reference to the growing number of mass shootings over the last decade. But it makes no specific mention of any mass shootings that occurred in 2019, including the racism-fueled El Paso, Texas Walmart shooting that killed 22 people or the Dayton, Ohio shootingthat killed 9 less than 24 hours later.
The exclusion of both of those incidents does a disservice to the less informed users who will come across these pages.
The Weird
Look, there's no escaping this one. Instead of using photos of each candidate for their landing page, Apple instead chose to illustrate each candidate and the results are not so much bad as they are unsettling.
Credit: APPLEFor instance, President Trump and Michael Bloomberg get a bizarre glow-up in smoothed, shiny representations that make them both appear younger and more virile than they actually are. Joe Biden's, on the other hand, is simply unsettling. It's all a little...disconcerting.
Credit: AppleAnd while Pete Buttigieg is the youngest candidate in the field at 38 years old, his portrait makes him look like a child; like he's the kid mayor responsible for the Ice Town debacle.
The candidate pages themselves are fine and pack a lot of helpful info, including figures from FiveThirtyEight and "notable supporters" that mix political endorsements with celebrities. Case in point, Bernie Sanders' page mentions both Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez's support andCardi B's.
Just try not to focus too much on the portraits and you'll be fine.
(责任编辑:产品中心)
-
24 Museums Dedicated to Black History
TheNational Museum of African American History and Culture opened in Washington, D.C., in 2016. It q ...[详细] -
陈瑶生:育种本质是优选优配!新品种的差异化商业价值是其持续发展的根基
陈瑶生:育种本质是优选优配!新品种的差异化商业价值是其持续发展的根基_南方+_南方plus“目前大多数培育的优质猪新品种的产肉效率和商品价值不一定比得上现有品种,但一定要有差异化的市场发展空间。”20 ...[详细] -
雅安日报讯“新修订的《民事诉讼法》在很多方面都有修改,而且都关系到每一个人的切身利益,所以大家应该有所了解。”11月9日,市中级人民法院的法官们走上街头,开展新修订《民事诉讼法》的宣传。在宣传现场,法 ...[详细]
-
粤米进琼!广东供销农特产品亮相海南冬交会_南方+_南方plus12月14-17日,第26届中国海南)国际热带农产品冬季交易会下称“冬交会”)在海南举行。广东新供销天润粮油集团有限公司下称“天润粮油公司 ...[详细]
-
Amazon Android Days sale 2024: Save on unlocked phones, tablets, and more
Table of ContentsTable of ContentsUPDATE: Aug. 28, 2024, 1:50 p.m. EDT This story has been updated w ...[详细] -
明知驾驶人事发前饮酒,未取得机动车驾驶证,且其中还有未成年人,但仍将摩托车借于他人,最终诱发道路交通事故,造成一死一伤的悲剧。虽然在此后的调查取证中,无法查实事发时摩托车的实际控制人,但根据事发时摩托 ...[详细]
-
雅安在市第三次党代会报告提出“以生态文明为引领,以生态优势为依托,以绿色(低碳)经济产业和现代服务业为主导,按照产业绿色化、资源循环化、生产生活低碳化、民居与环境生态化的要求转变经济发展方式,用国际化 ...[详细]
-
雅安日报讯近日,记者从芦山县检察院了解到,该院为进一步强化监外执行罪犯监督管理工作,与司法局等相关单位联合进行监外执行检察工作,切实维护社会稳定。在监外执行检察工作中,检察院干警与县司法局工作人员一道 ...[详细]
-
雅州利剑集中攻坚执行大会战专项行动启动走进位于青衣江畔雨城区三雅路6号的雅安市中级人民法院,办公环境窗明几净,法院干警热情服务……一缕缕文明新风扑面而来。文明的厚度,决定发展的高度。2018年,获“四 ...[详细]
-
雅安日报讯9日,位于市区挺进路的某钢琴艺术学校内,两名衣着单薄、风格清新的女孩在闪光灯下变换着造型,快门声此起彼伏。通过精心筹划,由北纬网主办,北纬论坛、IN PHOTO映像馆承办的“雅女映像”第四期 ...[详细]