Twitter is now adding a controversial 'hacked materials' warning label to tweets
“These materials may have been obtained through hacking,” reads the disclaimer affixed to a tweet linking to a story from independent news outlet, The Grayzone.
Tweet may have been deleted
The tweet was originally posted on Feb. 20. However, three days later, users began to notice the label added to The Grayzone’s tweet. (It is not yet clear when exactly the label appeared.) Furthermore, readers discovered that an extra step was added when trying to retweet posts linking to The Grayzone’s story: A pop-up appeared reiterating the warning label and asking users to “help keep Twitter a place for reliable info.”
A link is included which forwards users to Twitter’s “distribution of hacked materials” policy.
Tweet may have been deleted
The Grayzone’s storysources recently hacked and leaked documents which allegedly show that the BBC and Reuters participated in a program created by the UK government to “weaken Russia’s state influence.”
This appears to be the first instance of Twitter using this particular warning label on an English-language outlet. A search on the platform found one other instanceof a version of the “hacked materials” warning label being used. This one was stamped on an Italian outlet’s tweet regarding Pfizer's COVID-19 vaccine in January.
“These materials may have been obtained through hacking or may be manipulated,” reads the earlier warning label on the tweet, which is in Italian.
Mashable has reached out to Twitter for more information. The new warning label comes after Twitter's controversial decisionto block links to a New York Poststory in October 2020, which included material from a laptop belonging to President Joe Biden’s son, Hunter Biden. Twitter was roundly criticized across the political spectrum for the action it took when the story was published and shared on its platform.
In response, Twitter updated its policiessurrounding “hacked materials” and unblocked links to the story. This new warning label is clearly a new approach to flagging news stories which are based on hacks and leaked documents.
It should be stressed again that these warning labels are being added to tweets sharing links to news stories based on hacked materials, not tweets sharing raw leaked or stolen materials themselves.
However, some Twitter users have pointed out that the New York Timesstory on Ted Cruz’s tripto Cancun was based on leaked text messages from the senator’s wife. Yet, they point out, there is no warning label placed on tweets linking to that story even though it appears to fall under Twitter’s own “distribution of hacked materials” policy.
Twitter also uses its warning labelsfeature to inform users about misinformation spreading on its platform. While this was a helpful service amid all the liesand disinformationcampaigns surrounding the 2020 U.S. presidential election, it’s not clear if this translates to “hacked materials.”
Debunked claims are proven to be false. However, the same cannot be said outright for “hacked materials.” In fact, some of the most important journalism of just this past decade was done with documents that would fall under Twitter’s “hacked materials” policy.
Would the eye-opening “Collateral murder” video that was provided to Wikileaks in 2010 by Chelsea Manning have received a warning label? Would Twitter have warned users before retweeting the many crucial investigative pieces that came out of the NSA spying documents provided to multiple news outlets by Edward Snowden?
As Will Menaker of the podcast Chapo Trap House tweeted, these “hacked materials” warning labels may very well be construed by critics as “highlighting journalism that is especially important.”
UPDATE: Feb. 23, 2021, 8:56 p.m. EST Max Blumenthal, editor of The Grayzone, provided Mashable with a statement on the warning labels:
By applying a scare label exclusively to my article, Twitter has contributed nothing to the public's understanding of news or disinformation. Instead, it has confirmed the veracity of my reporting, as well as the threat it presents to a national security state that seems to be protecting its agenda through a desperate campaign of social media censorship.
Blumenthal noted that his article that Twitter marked with the hacked materials label references a British Army unit that uses social media to help fight wars. Twitter's head of editorial in Europe, the Middle East, and Africa Gordon MacMillan is a reservist for that unit. Twitter reviewed his Army role in 2019 and found no wrongdoing, according to Business Insider. Mashable has reached out to Twitter to ask if MacMillan was involved in the decision to add the hacked materials label to Blumenthal's post.
UPDATE: Feb. 24, 2021, 9:34 a.m. EST According to Twitter, this instance is indeed the first time the "hacked materials" warning label has been used. Twitter also says that enforcement decisions are handled by its Trust and Safety Team. MacMillan, the Twitter employee referenced by The Grayzone's editor, is not part of this team or the enforcement process.
Related Video: How to recognize and avoid fake news
TopicsCybersecuritySocial MediaTwitter
(责任编辑:关于我们)
- Prime exclusive deal: $50 off Govee floor lamp
- North Korea's media shifts stance, questions effectiveness of COVID
- 我市成为全省森林康养目的地最富集的地区
- Namibian teen model is a doppelganger for Regina George from 'Mean Girls'
- DNC 2024 speech: Barack Obama and Michelle Obama have a superpower no other Democrat has.
- What to expect when a tech bubble bursts
- Someone tell the GOP all the old white men yelling about Kavanaugh isn't cute
- McIlroy, Rahm head strong field at Colonial
- 国家级荣誉!深汕特别合作区2村获评全国乡村治理示范村
- 16 of the Most Epic Sandwiches Around the Planet
- La Liga gets its wish for season return but not without compromise
- 4chan hackers take over city billboard to broadcast hate memes
- Someone tell the GOP all the old white men yelling about Kavanaugh isn't cute
-
First officially approved Gen IV nuclear reactor in the US breaks ground
Kairos Power has broken ground at Oak Ridge on the first officially approved Generation IV reactor e ...[详细] -
South Korea remains open to another summit with North Korea: minister nominee
Unification Minister nominee Kwon Young-se / Korea Times fileThe new administration remains open to ...[详细] -
芦山县产业集中区是《芦山地震灾后恢复重建总体规划》中布局的重要产业园区,规划面积5平方公里。灾后重建中,芦山县产业集中区遵循“绿色低碳、适度超前、产业高端、产城一体”的总体思路,按照“两核一心驱动、组 ...[详细]
-
US senators remind Moon, Abe of importance of trilateral cooperation
WASHINGTON -- A group of 40 US senators sent a letter to South Korean President Moon Jae-in and Japa ...[详细] -
本报讯8月23日,中国劳动关系学院劳动关系与人力资源学院副院长张才明一行赴雅考察职工思想政治引领数智化发展工作开展情况。中国劳动关系学院为中华全国总工会和教育部联合共建,是全国总工会唯一一所普通高等院 ...[详细]
-
Kiwi Dixon wins IndyCar opener in Texas after pandemic delay
CANBERRA:New Zealand's Scott Dixon climbed out of his car and donned a white protective face mask af ...[详细] -
Clothing brands are making dedicated AirPod pockets now, if that makes sense to you
Because it's not odd-looking enough to wear earphones that look like they got abruptly chopped off, ...[详细] -
Sorry, but you're doing your pa$$w0rds all wrong
Maintaining a set of strong, unique passwords is tough work these days — and yet it's never be ...[详细] -
NCT member Taeil leaves band over sexual offense allegations
Taeil of NCT (SM Entertainment)Taeil, a member of K-pop boy band NCT, has left the team after being ...[详细] -
雅安日报讯昨(29)日,省总工会党组书记、常务副主席罗茂乡,巡视员唐科伟一行,到雨城区环境卫生管理处和市区汉文化广场棚改房工程(一期)施工现场,向冒着酷暑坚守在岗位一线的职工,送去夏日清凉。市委常委、 ...[详细]