Joe Biden calls Zuckerberg 'a real problem' and wants to revoke Section 230
Joe Biden is angry at Facebook — and wants to fundamentally change the internet because of it.
In an interview with the New York Timeseditorial board published Friday, presidential candidate Joe Biden went off on Facebook and said he wants to revoke section 230 of the Communications Decency Act.
"Section 230 should be revoked, immediately should be revoked, number one," Biden said. "For Zuckerberg and other platforms."
Section 230 shields internet platforms and publishers from liability for what users write on their platforms. For example, a social media company can't be sued for what a user posts, or a blogger isn't liable for what readers write in the comments section. A lesser-known component of the law is that it also allows internet companies to moderate their platforms as they see fit.
The law dates back to 1996, and some have called for its reexamination in light of how the internet has changed in the last 25 years. However, online civil liberty experts also say it is crucial for protecting freedom of speech online.
"Gutting CDA 230 won't fix any of the problems caused by centralized Big Tech platforms," Evan Greer, an internet freedoms expert and advocate with Fight for the Future, told Mashable. "It will just open the floodgates for widespread internet censorship, while stripping existing platforms of their ability to moderate content responsibly."
SEE ALSO:Thanks to Elizabeth Warren, breaking up Big Tech will be a major issue in the primariesBiden appears to have his sights set on Section 230 because of an October 2018 scuffle with Facebook. The Biden campaign wrote a letter to Facebook asking it to remove an ad, posted by an independent Political Action Committee (PAC), claiming that Biden was blackmailing a Ukrainian official to keep them from prosecuting his son, Hunter Biden. Facebook declined to remove the ad, answering that it will not monitor political ads based on whether the information they present is true or false.
"I've never been a big Zuckerberg fan. I think he's a real problem."
Biden's takeaway from this experience appears to be that Section 230 needs work, specifically as it applies to Facebook: in November, he said that the company should be exempt from its protections.
"I’ve never been a big Zuckerberg fan," Biden said. "I think he’s a real problem."
He took that sentiment a step further by advocating that the law be revoked. Mashable has reached out to the Biden campaign to see if his comments on Section 230 constitute an official campaign position, and will update this when we hear back.
So is revoking 230 such a terrible idea? With all the harm wrought by false speech on Facebook, it seems a reasonable argument that they bear legal responsibility.
However, the internet saw the consequences of kneecapping 230 firsthand with the introduction of exemptions to the law in 2018 — and it wasn't pretty.
Two provisions called FOSTA and SESTA were nominally introduced to curb online sex trafficking by making internet companies liable for hosting prostitution ads on their websites. While the intention seemed noble (although some said it was actually a conservative anti-sex work Trojan horse), its effects were immediately chilling.
Some websites, notably including Tumblr, had long been valued, safe spaces for sex workers and frank talk about sexuality. But in the wake of the changes, rather than host any explicit content that could leave them liable, websites like Tumblr banned explicit content and gutted once-thriving sex-positive communities.
Instead of messing with Section 230, Greer believes in a finer approach that curtails the power of consolidated tech giants while also protecting freedom of speech. Simplistic talking points shouldn't jeopardize that, Greer said.
"There's nothing more dangerous for democracy than when politicians who don't understand how the Internet works turn complex policy debates into political footballs."
(责任编辑:产品中心)
- Weather update for second Pak vs Ban second Test match day one
- Korea, U.S. have no plan to discuss THAAD at defense chiefs' meeting: Seoul
- Ronaldo 'happy to be back' for Man Utd
- Titmus clinches freestyle treble at Commonwealths
- 17 Places That Harness the Power of the Sun
- Freedom from Dissent
- Medvedev races into Los Cabos semi
- Biegun emphasizes US readiness to engage in talks with NK
- Beagle and his baby BFF have their picture taken monthly over 2 years
- The Techies Who Lunch
- N. Korea's COVID
- Roger Stone's Instagram account shares bizarre post hours after indictment
- New guidelines aim to stop kids' peanut allergies before they start
-
Recently I had a friend over to whom I offered to audition my DIY PC speaker system. The first thing ...[详细]
-
Stephen King really, really hates Twitter, apparently
Well this is awkward. Stephen King — a notable tweeter — really, really hates Twitter, a ...[详细] -
8 winter pranks that'll make you weep icicles
Winter is basically a long April Fools' celebration. With the arrival of ice and snow comes the "com ...[详细] -
柑皮丝茶亮相法国国际农业博览会 德庆贡柑再登国际舞台_南方+_南方plus近日,第60届法国国际农业博览会以下简称“农博会”)在巴黎举行,中国馆首次亮相该博览会,广东知名农业企业东璞农业公司以下简称“ ...[详细]
-
North Korea says it conducted important test to develop multiple warhead missile
A trail of what appears to be a North Korean missile launch is seen from Incheon. North Kore on June ...[详细] -
IAEA: N. Korea could have started nuclear reprocessing
North Korea could have started reprocessing spent nuclear fuel to harvest plutonium for nuclear weap ...[详细] -
飞机坝到货运站方向车辆禁止通行,荥经至雅安货车绕行成雅高速公路,其余车辆绕行龙观路、城后路 交通管制期间,5路公交车始发站从泛华厂移至胜利路口,2路公交车始发站从货运站移至泛华厂 雅安日报讯 市民关 ...[详细]
-
Helion raises billions promising net electricity from fusion by 2024
Washington startup Helion Energy says its seventh-gen Polaris prototype will be the world's first fu ...[详细] -
Scientists detect water sloshing on Mars. There could be a lot.
A pioneering NASA robot detected over a thousand quakes on Mars. It also may have revealed a huge re ...[详细] -
USDA: 60% of North Koreans are food insecure
North Korean farmers plants rice in the field in Pyongwon County, South Pyeongan Province, in May 19 ...[详细]
Carbon neutrality law violates basic rights: Constitutional Court
Raducanu wins marathon to reach Washington quarters
- Keurig K Mini deal — get $30 off at Target
- Osaka makes triumphant return
- New unification minister appointed to serve as point man on Pyongyang
- New guidelines aim to stop kids' peanut allergies before they start
- How 3D Game Rendering Works: Texturing
- Here's 20 sweet seconds of Ed Sheeran's brand new music
- 11 North Korean defectors returned home over past 5 years