Diplomacy key to resolving North Korea crisis
This is the first in a series of interviews with international experts to seek ways toward a peaceful resolution of the North Korea nuclear crisis on the occasion of the 67th anniversary of The Korea Times, which falls on Nov. 1. ― ED.
By Kim Jae-kyoung
Diplomacy is the only way to achieve a peaceful resolution of the North Korea nuclear crisis, according to Kelsey Davenport, director for nonproliferation policy at the Arms Control Association.
She said that in order to bring North Korea back to negotiations, U.S. President Donald Trump and his administration should send a sincere, consistent message that the offer of engagement is real.
"Diplomacy is the only path forward to resolve the North Korean nuclear crisis," Davenport said in a recent interview.
"The Trump administration purports to advance a strategy of maximum pressure and engagement but U.S. actions and rhetoric expose a serious diplomacy deficit," she added.
She pointed out that mixed messages from Trump and top administration officials about U.S. intentions to engage in talks further complicate the environment.
"The Trump administration can and must signal to North Korea that it is willing to engage in talks without preconditions," she said.
"Direct talks would give the U.S. an opportunity to discuss a path forward with North Korea to reduce tension."
Davenport stressed that the U.S. Congress should also refrain from activities that heighten tension and muddy the waters regarding the prospects of diplomacy.
"That may require putting denuclearization on the back burner, voicing support for shorter-term, more manageable goals, and giving existing sanctions time to work before pushing new measures," she said.
She believes that given the tension between North Korea and the U.S., a high-level figure could engage both parties to try to reduce this and convey to Pyongyang Washington's interest in negotiations.
"That will require identifying an individual the Trump administration trusts and is willing to refrain from openly criticizing," she said.
"Ultimately North Korea wants to negotiate with the U.S., but other states can and must play a role in facilitating a peaceful resolution to the crisis."
The Washington-based North Korea expert said that while South Korea faces serious security challenges, it is incumbent upon Seoul to refrain from actions that would prompt an arms race, further destabilizing the region.
Davenport thinks that tougher sanctions and military signaling without a plan for diplomacy will only complicate the situations.
"Given the current escalated risk of miscalculation, South Korea and the U.S. need to walk a fine line between sustaining security alliances and provoking a North Korean response," she said.
She warned that Trump's vague threats, paired with military signaling, could inadvertently spark a crisis.
"The U.S. and South Korea could scale back some military activities without negatively impacting readiness," she noted.
"Putting that on the table might be attractive to Pyongyang as part of an interim negotiated freeze."
Lesson from Iran deal
Davenport, who provides research and analysis on nuclear and missile programs in North Korea and Iran, said that lessons should be learned from the process of the P5+1 talks for the Iranian nuclear weapons agreement.
The P5+1 refers to the U.N. Security Council's five permanent members — China, France, Russia, the U.K. and the U.S. — plus Germany.
One lesson to take from the nuclear deal with Iran in her view is the critical need for coordination in any multilateral approach.
"The six countries negotiating with Iran were in lock step on the strategy and goals of the process," she said.
"Multilateral talks with North Korea will require the same close coordination on goals and processes."
Another important lesson relevant for multilateral talks with North Korea is that the negotiations with Iran demonstrated that an interim agreement can be a positive way to prevent tension from escalating and demonstrate all sides are willing to implement a deal in good faith.
"In negotiations with North Korea, an interim deal designed to freeze Pyongyang's nuclear and missile progress in exchange for concessions from the other side, such as a pledge not to impose any additional sanctions or a roll back of some elements of the U.S.-South Korea joint military exercises, might be helpful in demonstrating that both sides are willing to follow through on an agreement," she added.
By Kim Jae-kyoung
Kelsey Davenport |
She said that in order to bring North Korea back to negotiations, U.S. President Donald Trump and his administration should send a sincere, consistent message that the offer of engagement is real.
"Diplomacy is the only path forward to resolve the North Korean nuclear crisis," Davenport said in a recent interview.
"The Trump administration purports to advance a strategy of maximum pressure and engagement but U.S. actions and rhetoric expose a serious diplomacy deficit," she added.
She pointed out that mixed messages from Trump and top administration officials about U.S. intentions to engage in talks further complicate the environment.
"The Trump administration can and must signal to North Korea that it is willing to engage in talks without preconditions," she said.
"Direct talks would give the U.S. an opportunity to discuss a path forward with North Korea to reduce tension."
Davenport stressed that the U.S. Congress should also refrain from activities that heighten tension and muddy the waters regarding the prospects of diplomacy.
"That may require putting denuclearization on the back burner, voicing support for shorter-term, more manageable goals, and giving existing sanctions time to work before pushing new measures," she said.
She believes that given the tension between North Korea and the U.S., a high-level figure could engage both parties to try to reduce this and convey to Pyongyang Washington's interest in negotiations.
"That will require identifying an individual the Trump administration trusts and is willing to refrain from openly criticizing," she said.
"Ultimately North Korea wants to negotiate with the U.S., but other states can and must play a role in facilitating a peaceful resolution to the crisis."
The Washington-based North Korea expert said that while South Korea faces serious security challenges, it is incumbent upon Seoul to refrain from actions that would prompt an arms race, further destabilizing the region.
Davenport thinks that tougher sanctions and military signaling without a plan for diplomacy will only complicate the situations.
"Given the current escalated risk of miscalculation, South Korea and the U.S. need to walk a fine line between sustaining security alliances and provoking a North Korean response," she said.
She warned that Trump's vague threats, paired with military signaling, could inadvertently spark a crisis.
"The U.S. and South Korea could scale back some military activities without negatively impacting readiness," she noted.
"Putting that on the table might be attractive to Pyongyang as part of an interim negotiated freeze."
Lesson from Iran deal
Davenport, who provides research and analysis on nuclear and missile programs in North Korea and Iran, said that lessons should be learned from the process of the P5+1 talks for the Iranian nuclear weapons agreement.
The P5+1 refers to the U.N. Security Council's five permanent members — China, France, Russia, the U.K. and the U.S. — plus Germany.
One lesson to take from the nuclear deal with Iran in her view is the critical need for coordination in any multilateral approach.
"The six countries negotiating with Iran were in lock step on the strategy and goals of the process," she said.
"Multilateral talks with North Korea will require the same close coordination on goals and processes."
Another important lesson relevant for multilateral talks with North Korea is that the negotiations with Iran demonstrated that an interim agreement can be a positive way to prevent tension from escalating and demonstrate all sides are willing to implement a deal in good faith.
"In negotiations with North Korea, an interim deal designed to freeze Pyongyang's nuclear and missile progress in exchange for concessions from the other side, such as a pledge not to impose any additional sanctions or a roll back of some elements of the U.S.-South Korea joint military exercises, might be helpful in demonstrating that both sides are willing to follow through on an agreement," she added.
(责任编辑:关于我们)
推荐文章
-
Washington Mystics vs. Chicago Sky 2024 livestream: Watch live WNBA
TL;DR:Watch Washington Mystics vs. Chicago Sky in the WNBA with WNBA League Pass. Avoid blackouts an ...[详细] -
新闻背景:日前,北京市住建委、市公安局、市规划委会同市卫生局等部门联合印发了《关于公布我市出租房屋人均居住面积标准等有关问题的通知》,对群租进行了界定,明确了群租相关各方责任。该通知还明确规定,出租房 ...[详细]
-
17日晚,芦山县惠民路集中安置小区举行了一场热闹非凡的联欢晚会,在近两个小时的精彩节目中,安置小区的居民们用欢歌笑语诠释了灾区同胞的乐观心态和热爱生活的积极向往。虽然没有华丽的舞台和耀眼的灯光,只有一 ...[详细]
-
雅安日报讯按照“实现伟大中国梦、建设美丽繁荣和谐四川”主题教育活动要求,为进一步弘扬中华民族传统美德,全面提高公民素质和社会文明程度,切实增强全县人民感恩党、感恩祖国、感恩人民、感恩社会的意识,近日, ...[详细]
-
I Deleted All My Social Accounts: Three Weeks Without Social Media
To say that a lot of people use social media is an understatement. At last count, Facebook had more ...[详细] -
“清马”最暖补给点:清远市民请跑者喝英德红茶,5000人畅饮
“清马”最暖补给点:清远市民请跑者喝英德红茶,5000人畅饮_南方+_南方plus跑“清马”,喝英德红茶!3月17日,清远好风土·2024清远马拉松赛鸣枪开跑。在赛事途经地,清远市民自设英德红茶补给点 ...[详细] -
2013年6月19日,涉嫌故意伤害罪的犯罪嫌疑人王某,经石棉县检察院启动羁押必要性审查程序后,被依法变更强制措施为取保候审,并于当日被释放。至此该案进入审查起诉环节。6月15日,石棉县检察院受理了石棉 ...[详细]
-
8500w+播放量花式“破圈”,清马短视频赛万元大奖花落谁家?
8500w+播放量花式“破圈”,清马短视频赛万元大奖花落谁家?_南方+_南方plus与两万多人一起跑马拉松是什么体验?好奇跑马参赛包和完赛包里都有啥?清远有什么好吃的东西、好玩的地方?……这些问题,在 ...[详细] -
中山古镇:到苏炳添家乡看“村BA”,来一场说走就走的美食之旅
中山古镇:到苏炳添家乡看“村BA”,来一场说走就走的美食之旅_南方+_南方plus小到客厅、卧室、厨房,大到去商超购物、博物馆参观,甚至是在体育馆看一场演唱会……总有一盏点亮你生活的灯,来自这里。中国 ...[详细] -
雅安日报讯近日,家住市区文定街的刘玉珍婆婆拨打本报新闻热线2222226,向记者反映,每晚她会在家附近的沿江公园散步,锻炼身体,但是公园随处可见狗粪,“太臭了!有时不注意还会踩到,影响心情。”天气好转 ...[详细]
热点阅读