Why the Fulton County indictment is different from Jack Smith’s case.
If the recent federal indictment of Donald Trump on charges related to his attempt to subvert the 2020 presidential election was a streamlined surgical strike aimed at ensuring a clean case and a speedy trial of the former president before the 2024 election, Monday night’s Georgia indictment is the equivalent of a blitz. With 19 defendants and 41 charges, the heart of the indictment is a sprawling state racketeering charge that places Trump at the center of a vast conspiracy to lie to state officials, pressure election officials to change vote totals, turn in phony slates of fake electors to Congress, influence witness testimony, and gain access to voting machinery and software, all in an effort to turn Trump from an Electoral College loser into a second-term president. And although the action in the state complaint occurred primarily in Georgia, the indictment alleges that part of the conspiracy, which included the actions of his chief of staff and lawyers, spanned much of the continent, from Arizona to Pennsylvania, Wisconsin to Washington. The case will be messy and difficult to manage, especially given Fulton County District Attorney Fani Willis’ stated intention to try all 19 defendants together.
But the biggest difference between the federal case and the state case isn’t the number of defendants or counts in the indictment. It’s about the central role that race is likely to play not in the federal case but in the state case, from the race of the prosecutor, to the focus on Black election worker Ruby Freeman, to the essential nature of the race-baiting bogus voter-fraud charges in Georgia that formed Trump’s basis for falsely claiming that he was the rightful winner.
AdvertisementRelated From Slate
Dennis Aftergut and Philip Allen Lacovara
How the Start of Trump’s Georgia Trial Might Look
Read MoreFirst, expect Trump to attack Willis in especially harsh terms. It’s not as though Trump has treated Jack Smith, the special counsel in charge of the federal probe, kindly. He has called Smith “deranged” and a “lowlife prosecutor.”
But Trump has a record of being especially hostile toward Black women, from journalists, to Vice President Kamala Harris, to New York Attorney General Letitia James, whom Trump for no reason branded a “racist” after she brought tax charges against the Trump Organization. He recently said that Tanya Chutkan, the Jamaican-born U.S. district court judge hearing the federal election interference case, is “highly partisan” and “VERY UNFAIR & BIASED.” Indeed, even before the indictment was unsealed on Monday, Trump’s campaign was attacking Willis in personal terms, calling her a “radical Democrat” and “rabid partisan.”
Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementWillis is especially a threat to Trump because he holds no power over her. Even if he becomes president again in 2024, he cannot stop her prosecution or attempt to pardon himself of state crimes. The best he could try to do is delay his prosecution until he is no longer president. In Georgia, the governor has no power to pardon either, so it is not as though Trump could appeal to someone over Willis’ head to get relief. And the RICO statute, which formed the basis for the indictment’s primary charge, carries a mandatory minimum sentence of five years.
Willis’ indictment is full of legalese, but it essentially tells the story of Trump and his allies’ attempt to subvert the outcome of the 2020 presidential election. It includes the elements one would expect, from the pressure on Vice President Mike Pence not to count electoral votes, to the infamous phone call with Georgia Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger to “find” 11,780 votes, thereby flipping Georgia’s Electoral College votes from Biden to Trump, to the fake electors schemes in Georgia and around the country.
AdvertisementBut the indictment also goes out of its way to tell the story of another Black woman, Ruby Freeman, and her daughter, fellow election worker Shaye Moss. Freeman became a central figure in Trump and his allies’ false claims about the Georgia election being stolen from him. The indictment describes some of Trump’s lies, including that Freeman was a “professional vote scammer,” that she stuffed ballot boxes, and that she fraudulently awarded at least 18,000 votes to Joe Biden during ballot counting at the State Farm Arena. The mother and daughter were eventually cleared of the false claims, and Trump’s lawyer Rudy Giuliani has essentially conceded in a civil defamation suit that the claims against the pair were false and made with knowledge of the falsity.
Advertisement AdvertisementThe complaint also alleges that Trevian Kutti, a former publicist for Trump supporter Kanye West, tried to mislead Freeman into giving false testimony about what took place at the arena. Freeman and Moss were at the center of a lie pinning the supposed theft of the 2020 election on two Black women, and they have faced threats and harassment ever since.
Popular in News & Politics
- A Supreme Court Justice Gave Us Alarming New Evidence That He’s Living in MAGA World
- We’ve Been Entertaining an Illusion About the Supreme Court. It’s Finally Been Shattered.
- Them Supreme Court Boys Are at It Again
- In a Week Full of Hypocrites, Greg Abbott Came Close to Winning the Crown
In important ways, the Georgia complaint is about getting justice for Freeman and Moss. But more broadly, the complaint vindicates the interest of all Black voters in Georgia and across the country. When Trump made his voter fraud claims in 2016 and 2020, he constantly focused his accusations on Democratic cities with large Black populations. On Nov. 27, 2020, for example, Trump tweeted: “Biden can only enter the White House as President if he can prove that his ridiculous ‘80,000,000 votes’ were not fraudulently or illegally obtained. When you see what happened in Detroit, Atlanta, Philadelphia & Milwaukee, massive voter fraud, he’s got a big unsolvable problem!” The message was clear: Minority voters were stealing the votes of Trump’s white rural supporters. These racist tropes were also a major theme of Giuliani’s public-facing efforts to overturn the election.
Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementRace is not absent from the federal complaint, mind you. The Department of Justice charged Trump under the post–Civil War Ku Klux Klan Act for depriving voters of their right to vote. But race will be front and center in Georgia.
Willis’ constant presence in the public eye over the next year will be an important reminder that although Trump may have been unique in his complex racketeering conspiracy to subvert the election, this is hardly the first time Black voters have been targeted for disenfranchisement in Georgia and across the United States. Part of Willis’ job will be to make it that much more difficult to do so the next time around.
Update, Aug. 15, 2023: This article has been updated to clarify the clearing of claims against Ruby Freeman and Shaye Moss.
Tweet Share Share Comment(责任编辑:产品中心)
- 蒙顶山茶有了专属茶器
- N. Korean plane arrives in Vladivostok for 1st time in over 3 years: report
- iPhone 16 Pro: These 2 camera rumors will make you regret the iPhone 15 Pro
- Spacecraft looks like a 'Star Wars' ship. It just crashed into Earth.
- How to watch 'Kinds of Kindness': When is it streaming?
- 21 Unexpected Wonders in Colorado’s Vibrant Cities and Small Towns
- Weather Destinations for All Seasons
- Yoon says trainee doctors' collective actions 'cannot be tolerated'
- Number of surgeries halved as hospitals suffer from strike
- 23 Peculiar Places of 2023
- S. Korea ready to become most vocal 'speaker' over N. Korea's human rights: minister
- AI George Carlin releases comedy special that Carlin would've despised
- Best Apple watch deal: Get the Apple Watch Ultra for under $630
-
CPUs Don't Matter For 4K Gaming... Wrong!
Something we hear a lot these days, especially when it comes to CPU benchmarking, is that CPU perfor ...[详细] -
Nurses support med school quota hike
A doctor is seen walking outside the operation room of the Keimyung University Dongsan Medical Cente ...[详细] -
YouTube demonetizes public domain 'Steamboat Willie' video after copyright claim
UPDATE: Jan. 5, 2024, 5:18 p.m. EST On Friday, Disney retracted the copyright claim on YouTuber Broc ...[详细] -
The Supreme Court just legalized stalking.
This is part of Opinionpalooza, Slate’s coverage of the major decisions from the Supreme Court this ...[详细] -
Washington Mystics vs. Chicago Sky 2024 livestream: Watch live WNBA
TL;DR:Watch Washington Mystics vs. Chicago Sky in the WNBA with WNBA League Pass. Avoid blackouts an ...[详细] -
How to watch 'The Color Purple' — release date, Max subscription deals
The best Max streaming subscription deals at a glance:BEST FOR MOST PEOPLEMax (with ads) annual subs ...[详细] -
Tesla Model Y owner adds DIY solar roof to his car
A Tesla Model Y owner got fed up with the company not offering solar panels for its cars, so he buil ...[详细] -
[Graphic News] Cigarette sales fall for 1st time in 4 years in 2023
Sales of cigarettes in South Korea inched down in 2023 for the first time in four years, but demand ...[详细] -
Ruling bloc seeks tougher sentences for deepfake sex crimes
People Power Party Chair Han Dong-hoon speaks during an emergency meeting of government officials an ...[详细] -
Elon Musk wants to build a city called Starbase in Texas
SpaceX CEO Elon Musk is getting into the city-building business. On Tuesday, Musk tweeted about "cre ...[详细]
- Tesla considers adding a new ‘stuck detection' feature to Cybertruck. Here’s why.
- Switching Away From Outlook or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love Gmail
- Best Amazon Fire tablet deal: Snag the Fire HD 10 tablet for a new all
- 进度40.6%!湛江已完成春播面积193.12万亩
- [Graphic News] Average book price nears 20,000 won
- Super Bowl 2024 hits record viewership
- Apple takes the smartphone market crown for the first time