Google tracks you even if you turn off 'location history': report
So, you’ve turned off Location History on your phone in an effort to maintain your privacy and limit the amount of data you share with the big tech companies. Well, it turns out Google may still be tracking your movements.
An AP investigation published Monday discovered that some of Google’s many different services are still tracking users' every move on both iPhone and Android phones regardless of whether they've toggled the “Location History” setting on or off.
SEE ALSO:Google never really left China: a look at the Chinese website Google's been quietly runningWhen using a service like Google Maps, Google will ask you to permit access to your iPhone or Android phone's location data. When agreeing to this request, you allow Google Maps to record your location history, and display your location history on a timeline so you can view your daily travels.
On a Google support page for managing your Location History, the company says “You can turn off Location History at any time. With Location History off, the places you go are no longer stored." However, as the AP investigation discovered, that isn’t exactly true.
Some examples of location-data logging the AP points to include Android’s automatic weather updates that still track your general location, Google’s search engine saving an exact location for each search query to your Google account, and even Google Maps itself snapshotting your location when you open the application.
AP began its inquiry into this location-tracking issue after a graduate researcher at UC Berkeley observed a notification on her Android phone asking her to rate a recent trip to Kohl’s even though she had turned off Location History.
It seems that even with Location History put on pause, a number of Google apps still automatically store your location data without asking.
In a statement to the AP, Google explained, “There are a number of different ways that Google may use location to improve people’s experience, including: Location History, Web and App Activity, and through device-level Location Services. We provide clear descriptions of these tools, and robust controls so people can turn them on or off, and delete their histories at any time.”
To actually stop location services on your iPhone or Android device altogether, Google pointed AP to the "Web and App Activity" setting. This setting, turned on by default, controls various options for apps and services connected to your Google account.
As AP discovered upon further exploring these options, Google's prompts further explain what each setting means, but only after you toggle each one on or off. Pausing Location History on your Google account webpage provides a prompt that informs you that "some location data may be saved as part of your activity on other Google services, like Search and Maps."
On an Android phone, toggling the same setting off lets you know that "places you go with your devices will stop being added to your Location History map." On an iPhone you’ll be warned that "none of your Google apps will be able to store location data in Location History."
Additionally, when toggling the “Web and App Activity” setting on through your Google account, you're notified that the setting "saves the things you do on Google sites, apps, and services ... and associated information, like location."
Technically, Google is right in its explanation of each of these settings. Location History settings seem to only pertain to the actual logging of this location data on the phone for easy user access, the ability to view a timeline of precisely where you’ve been. Toggling this setting off does not affect Google’s ability to pinpoint your location and draw from this data what the company deems necessary to give you more accurate information.
In a statement provided to Mashable, a Google spokesperson said:
"Location History is a Google product that is entirely opt in, and users have the controls to edit, delete, or turn it off at any time. As the story notes, we make sure Location History users know that when they disable the product, we continue to use location to improve the Google experience when they do things like perform a Google search or use Google for driving directions."
Mashable was also provided with this link on Google's location data policy.
Google previously faced scrutiny for a location-tracking issue late last year. The company was found to be accessing users' location even when the GPS location tracking was off through "Cell ID codes" obtained through cellular towers.
Jonathan Mayer, a computer scientist at Princeton and a former chief technologist for the FCC’s enforcement bureau, had a researcher from his lab confirm AP’s findings. Speaking to the AP, Mayer said, “If you’re going to allow users to turn off something called ‘Location History,’ then all the places where you maintain location history should be turned off. That seems like a pretty straightforward position to have.”
It’s pretty clear with the AP’s findings that the settings options and language used to describe them are fairly confusing for the average iPhone and Android user. The question remains as to whether Google will clarify these privacy issues with updated options and information provided to consumers. However, with GDPR laws already changing many big tech companies’ policies regarding how they deal with European users’ privacy and data, Google may not have much of a choice.
UPDATE: Aug. 16, 2018, 1:53 p.m. PDTThe AP reported Thursday that Google is now clarifying that the app continues to track user location even after turning off location history.
A Google spokesperson said in an email statement Thursday afternoon, "We have been updating the explanatory language about Location History to make it more consistent and clear across our platforms and help centers.”
Featured Video For You
We tested this device to see if it could actually help us find our friends — no matter how good they are at hiding
(责任编辑:产品中心)
-
A Barbie flip phone is here from HMD
This summer was Brat summer. We're approaching demure fall, which may transition into a season with ...[详细] -
骞冲畨浜哄闈掑矝鍒嗗叕鍙革細閲戣瀺娑堣垂鑰呮潈鐩婁繚鎶ゆ暀鑲插浼犳湀璧拌繘楂樻牎鎶よ埅瀛﹀瓙
銆€銆€10鏈?2鏃ワ紝鐢卞浗瀹堕噾铻嶇洃鐫g鐞嗘€诲眬闈掑矝鐩戠灞€涓诲姙鐨?ldquo;姹囪仛閲戣瀺鍔涢噺 鍏卞垱缇庡ソ鐢熸椿”2023骞撮噾铻嶆秷璐硅€呮潈鐩婁繚鎶ゆ暀鑲插浼犳 ...[详细] -
近期,由驻雅部队选出的雅安市第五届人民代表大会代表隋海鹏,因工作变动调离雅安,依照《中华人民共和国全国人民代表大会和地方各级人民代表大会代表法》的有关规定,隋海鹏的代表资格终止。截至目前,雅安市第五届 ...[详细]
-
项目施工现场 施工方提供本报讯2月4日,立春。楠水阁温泉酒店提升改造项目施工现场,挖掘机来回穿梭,忙着进行基础施工;一栋房屋的楼顶上,几名工人正在浇灌混凝土。“该项目主要进行酒店改造和新建会议中心,目 ...[详细]
-
U.S. Senators call on FTC to investigate the security of drivers' data
Carmakers are still putting diver data up for auction, and it's a practice that needs to be curbed, ...[详细] -
冰雪孟获城 周万龙 摄冬趣喇叭河 付雅 摄飞雪神木垒 王进 摄戏雪王岗坪地处神秘的北纬30度线上的雅安,属四川盆地到青藏高原过渡地带,境内山脉众多,5000余米的海拔垂直高差,拥有着壮丽的山川和独特的 ...[详细]
-
芦山县“千龙千狮闹新春·欢欢喜喜过大年”龙狮街头巡游活动精彩上演
本网讯2月10日大年初一上午,“千龙千狮闹新春·欢欢喜喜过大年”龙狮街头巡游活动在芦山县城精彩上演,开启了芦山的新年序幕。热闹的活动吸引了众多市民驻足观看,喜迎新春佳节。当天一大早,由文艺爱好者组成的 ...[详细] -
“手指不仅美观,而且能屈能伸了。”近日,雅安仁康医院外科病房里,看着曾经弯曲成90°的小指变直了,而且还恢复了伸屈功能,卢女士非常激动。今年23岁的卢女士是荥经县人。1岁的时候在火炉边玩耍,看着锅里不 ...[详细]
-
八仙帽精美的刺绣作品周学琼左)、唐伟欣右)在门口刺绣藏彝走廊东部边缘的石棉县,在横断山脉的褶皱、隆起与断裂,以及河流的急剧切割作用下,群山峡谷中藏着一个藏族秘境——蟹螺堡子。石头和泥土砌成的房屋展示着 ...[详细]
-
本报讯2月10日,大年初一。市委书记夏凤俭深入基层走访慰问春节期间坚守一线的干部职工,向大家致以节日问候、送上新春祝福,感谢他们在各自岗位上的辛勤付出。夏凤俭看望慰问文化旅游工作者夏凤俭在碧峰峡景区游 ...[详细]