Unrest in Haiti: Why it's not actually gang violence.
This article was originally featured in Foreign Policy, the magazine of global politics and ideas.
For the past four and a half years, Haiti’s internal security has steadily deteriorated. In 2019, the United Nations concluded 15 years of peacekeeping operations in the country, which had been initiated to address growing instability in the wake of President Jean-Bertrand Aristide’s 2004 ouster. Under the U.N. mission, an estimated 10,000 international nongovernmental organizations channeled foreign aid into Haiti to help support its social services. But the U.N.’s departure forced many aid groups to withdraw, spiraling the country into social unrest once again.
The 2021 assassination of President Jovenel Moïse was the most visible harbinger—and catalyst—of impending state collapse. That foreign mercenaries managed to kill the president, as both Haitian officials and U.S. prosecutors allege, was itself a signal of Haiti’s eroded internal security. De facto Prime Minister Ariel Henry then assumed control of the government without a roadmap to new elections. Henry’s lack of legitimacy made him unpopular and further compromised the country’s stability.
Now, the Haitian state has functionally disintegrated. Henry traveled to Nairobi in late February to secure Kenya’s leadership of a new U.N.-authorized Multinational Security Support mission for Haiti. But his absence from Port-au-Prince undermined the prospects of the planned intervention by emboldening gangs that already controlled most of the capital to make further advances.
Jimmy Chérizier, who leads the G9 Family and Allies gang and is known by his nom de guerre, “Barbecue,” apparently orchestrated a mass prison break in Port-au-Prince, freeing upward of 4,000 prisoners. This faction has claimed responsibility for attacks on government institutions, including Toussaint Louverture International Airport, the apparent aim of which was to prevent Henry’s return. Chérizier declared his intent to oust Henry, threatening “civil war” and “genocide” unless the leader resigned. The Haitian National Police, whose ranks have dwindled from around 9,000 to an estimated 5,000 over the past two years, is losing ground daily.
Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementAfter an emergency Caribbean Community and Common Market meeting in Jamaica on Monday, Henry announced his resignation and vowed to step down after the installation of a CARICOM-mandated transitional council. Henry was not present at the meeting and remains in Puerto Rico, where he diverted his plane after being unable to land in Haiti or the Dominican Republic.
These rapidly escalating developments should prompt the international community to speak about Haiti’s crisis in clearer terms. The country is experiencing not just an uptick in gang violence—as the U.N. mandate for the new security mission characterizes it—but a full-blown insurgency. Pretending otherwise will doom any intervention before it has begun. In framing Haiti’s situation as a mere gang problem, global actors risk committing to an ill-prepared and ill-fated intervention that will fail to secure the country and needlessly endanger those deployed—ultimately exacerbating the humanitarian crisis.
AdvertisementThe Kenyan-led U.N. mission to Haiti was predicated on the view that the country required assistance in suppressing gang violence to restore public order. As a result, the current U.N.-backed plan, largely financed by the United States, entails Kenya leading the force with a contingent of 1,000 Kenyan police officers. Several CARICOM states, as well as Bangladesh, Chad, and Benin, have pledged to send personnel to supplement the Kenyan police, but their numbers and composition have yet to be finalized.
AdvertisementAs the core—and only deployment-ready—force, the Kenyan contingent is wholly insufficient to provide any meaningful reinforcement to the Haitian National Police. It is also inappropriate to center the U.N. mission on policing when Haiti’s situation clearly requires a military response.
AdvertisementPolice officers enforce laws under governments that hold the monopoly on violence in their respective territories. When nonstate armed groups—whether one calls them gangs or insurgents—challenge that monopoly on violence by establishing control over territory claimed by the state, they nullify the law’s reach into that space. In these cases, a military intervention is necessary to reclaim lost territory and neutralize hostile forces.
AdvertisementThe distinction between organized criminal groups and insurgency groups can be murky. Both employ violence to contest state control over territory. A growing body of strategic literature speaks to organized crime and insurgencies as variations of the singular phenomenon of organized violence. Narco-traffickers in Latin America, most recently in Ecuador, have so evidently confounded the distinction that analysts increasingly label them as “criminal insurgents.”
AdvertisementThis nuance is often eschewed by academics, policymakers, and other stakeholders who remain hesitant to liken organized crime to insurgencies for both rhetorical and pragmatic reasons. Rhetorically, they concede the overlap in the modi operandi of gangs and insurgent groups but reserve the insurgency label for armed groups with stated political goals, as opposed to criminal groups, which are considered violent income-generating enterprises.
Advertisement AdvertisementRegardless, Haiti’s most prominent and powerful gangs have issued political demands while also conducting operations against government officials, institutions, and infrastructure. These are the actions of insurgents carrying out urban warfare. Perhaps if a major gang donned fatigues and included the word “revolutionary” in its name, we would more readily acknowledge this reality.
Related From Slate
Philippe de Bard
Haiti Doesn’t Have a Single Elected Official Left. Where Does the Country Go From Here?
Read MoreStates also hesitate to describe gangs as insurgent groups because doing so carries practical implications. Since gangs are conceived as criminal enterprises, countermeasures fall under the umbrella of justice and law enforcement; combating gangs, the argument goes, is the purview of the police and the courts. Declaring the existence of an insurgent group, by contrast, invokes the laws of war, a military response, and the concomitant resources and strategy.
AdvertisementPopular in News & Politics
- The Lawyer Defending Idaho’s Abortion Ban Irritated the One Justice He Needed on His Side
- We’ve Been Entertaining an Illusion About the Supreme Court. It’s Finally Been Shattered.
- You Don’t Want to Know How It’s Going Between Trump’s Lawyers and the Judge Presiding Over His Criminal Case
- Prosecutors Are Finally Revealing Their Strategy Against Trump
It is undeniable that Haiti is a failed state. That means there is no Haitian-led solution to the country’s turmoil forthcoming. The Haitian government, and by extension its laws, has lost authority; armed groups have overrun Port-au-Prince and are expanding across the country. The only practical goal of an international intervention would be to reverse this situation and reassert control of the country through direct confrontation with armed groups—setting aside the fraught question of determining trustworthy local stakeholders to reconstitute a government. This is the work of soldiers, not police. Retaking territory and neutralizing enemy combatants are military actions.
Advertisement AdvertisementFor the moment, Kenya has paused its plan to deploy its police forces to Haiti until a transitional government has been established. This gives the international community an opportunity to rethink and reconfigure the requirements for the U.N.-backed security mission.
Unless CARICOM, the U.S. government, and all who have a say or stake in Haiti accept that we are facing an insurgency, not a gang problem, the prospects of resolving Haiti’s crisis remain dim. Haiti can only be brought under control by a military deployment operating under rules of engagement that recognize armed groups as combatants. Otherwise, anarchy will prevail, with attendant consequences for the people of Haiti and the security of the Caribbean Basin.
(责任编辑:新闻中心)
- Naver, Kakao strive to combat deepfake porn spreading online
- Park renews calls for peaceful unification with North Korea
- YouTuber MKBHD gives us a look at RED's Hydrogen holographic phone
- LeBron James ejected in Lakers win
- Google is bringing AI summaries to ‘Files’ so you can find your docs quicker
- The Weird, Wonderful World of Water Towers
- 参赛指南|2024年广东省第一届农事运动会
- Top Chinese official's visit signals little thaw in ties with N. Korea
- YouTuber MKBHD gives us a look at RED's Hydrogen holographic phone
- Blinken condemns Russia
- Gangwon governor proposes 'floating hotel' for North Korea delegates
- 7 entry level vibrators if you are new to the sex toy game
- 良种配良技,筑牢稳产保供“压舱石”
-
[From the Scene] How ‘world’s first oil town’ is wrestling to become ‘green'
City of Baku, Azerbaijan (Getty Imgage)BAKU, Azerbaijan -- Driving just a few miles from the venue o ...[详细] -
Koreans value Internet privacy over right to know: poll
South Koreans tend to value Internet privacy over the right to know, a poll showed Tuesday, with a m ...[详细] -
Park embarks on mission to upgrade U.S. alliance
WASHINGTON -- South Korean President Park Geun-hye started her official schedule Wednesday by paying ...[详细] -
Powerful videos show 'Dreamers' storming Senate office building
It's been a year since Donald Trump was elected President of the United States and people are still ...[详细] -
味道真系正!怀集食材邂逅顺德厨艺_南方+_南方plus借顺德区举办第46届国际龙家具展览会和第36届亚洲国际家具材料博览会之机,8月19日,怀集县联合顺德区在龙江镇S-Park体育公园举办“怀集味道· ...[详细]
-
Park renews calls for peaceful unification with North Korea
President Park Geun-hye renewed her calls Tuesday for a peaceful unification between South and North ...[详细] -
LG V30's camera will have some amazing specs
As is customary, LG is slowly leaking the details about its upcoming V30 flagship smartphone weeks a ...[详细] -
The 1980s represent a treasure trove of popular culture, fashion and, of course, gadgets. Technology ...[详细]
-
Jeffrey Arlo Brown ,July 31, 2024 The Comp ...[详细]
-
Considerate man Justin Timberlake sent fans pizza so they could #TimberlakeAndChill
"Them other boys don't know how to act," declared Justin Timberlake in his 2006 opus, "Sexy Back."A ...[详细]
DOJ accuses TikTok of collecting and sharing users' personal views, as the app fights a ban
Gangwon governor proposes 'floating hotel' for North Korea delegates
- Tesla's big software update includes something called 'Night Curfew'
- Chinese media sheds light on N. Korea's education system
- Top Chinese official's visit signals little thaw in ties with N. Korea
- US wants diplomatic solution to North Korea's nuclear crisis: CIA chief
- Tesla Robotaxis aren't coming in August, it seems
- HP is putting a supercomputer in space
- Report: Apple store employees stole and rated photos from customer phones