Trump nominee Brett Talley’s apparent thoughts on capital punishment: “Just shoot them.”
Since his confirmation hearings for a seat on the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Alabama, 36-year-old Brett Talley has come under criticism for his relative inexperience, his failure to disclose that his wife works as a lawyer in Trump’s White House, and the fact that he didn’t reveal that he’d apparently written a series of pseudonymous message board posts on the website TideFans.com under the username BamainBoston.
In those posts, which covered a wide range of sports and nonsports topics, BamainBoston was open about his enthusiasm for the death penalty. In 2015, for example, BamainBoston noted that it would be “awesome” if Alabama brought back the electric chair. Later in the thread, BamainBoston proposed an alternative means of execution, saying that a “bullet’s cheap.” One year earlier, responding to news that an Oklahoma inmate named Clayton Lockett had died of a heart attack on the gurney after his lethal injection was botched, BamainBoston wrote: “Just shoot them. That’s effective.”
In a post this year, BamainBoston indicated he had worked on capital punishment cases in his career. That post read as follows:
Handled a bunch of death row cases in my previous job. With one exception, every one of them admitted that they’d committed the crime but were trying to mitigate to life without parole based on some excuse—drugs, violent childhood, etc. And the one exception the guy was clearly guilty. I don’t know the details on this Arkansas case, but death row cases with an actual innocence claim are kind of like abortions based on rape, incest, or the life of the mother. They certainly happen, but the whole debate shouldn’t turn on them.Advertisement
BamainBoston’s message came in a thread titled “Arkansas May Have Just Executed an Innocent Man.” That man, Ledell Lee, was executed earlier this year. Elizabeth Vartkessian of the Marshall Project wrote that the “courts refused to allow Lee’s team to conduct DNA testing and new evidence of his likely intellectual disability was never heard.” BamainBoston opined, “I wouldn’t spend too much time weeping for Lee.”
Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementAs a district court judge, Talley could hear capital criminal cases. At least 18 former death row inmates have been exonerated by DNA evidence and released from prison, the Innocence Project reported in 2009. BamainBoston expressed skepticism that anyone had been executed wrongfully since the Supreme Court reinstated the death penalty in 1977, writing:
AdvertisementAnti-death penalty advocates have gone to great lengths to definitively identify someone from the modern era who was executed and was innocent, Roger Keith Coleman being probably the most famous failed example. But that is beside my point. Feel free to change the standard for the death penalty if you like and give people who make claims of actual innocence yet another appeal process, or have a higher standard for imposition of the death penalty itself, beyond not only a reasonable doubt but any doubt. Do whatever you want, because the vast majority of people on death row are unequivocally and admittedly guilty.
In response to follow-up questions from Sen. Dick Durbin, a member of the Senate Judiciary Committee, Talley listed his work on death penalty cases as one of his key qualifications as a potential federal judge. In his own follow-up questions, Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse noted that Talley had in his role as deputy solicitor general of Alabama “defended questionable practices concerning the death penalty, such as executing a mentally incompetent death-row inmate and allowing a judge to override a jury’s recommendation for a life sentence and impose the death penalty.” Talley’s response:
Advertisement AdvertisementI defended the practices to which you refer in my capacity as an attorney representing a client, the state of Alabama. Those representations will have no influence on my sentencing practices, other than providing familiarity and experience with the legal issues surrounding the death penalty and challenges to sentences generally.Advertisement
The Supreme Court ultimately sided with Talley’s view in the case of the mentally incompetent death row inmate. Earlier this month, the court unanimously struck down a lower court ruling blocking the execution of a man who couldn’t remember his crime—but could understand the concepts of crime and punishment—after having suffered a series of strokes.
Find anything noteworthy in BamainBoston’s message board posts? Email us at tips@slate.com.
See also:
Trump Judicial Nominee Brett Talley Appears to Have Defended “the First KKK” in Message Board Post
Trump Judicial Nominee Brett Talley Appears to Have Called Roe v. Wade “Indefensible”
Trump Nominee Brett Talley Appears to Support 20-Year-Old Woman Having Sex with 14-Year-Old Boy
(责任编辑:资讯)
-
South Korea beefs up drills amid escalating NK provocations
A Spike missile is launched during the South Korean Marine Corps' full-scale live-fire drills on the ...[详细] -
冰雪孟获城 周万龙 摄冬趣喇叭河 付雅 摄飞雪神木垒 王进 摄戏雪王岗坪地处神秘的北纬30度线上的雅安,属四川盆地到青藏高原过渡地带,境内山脉众多,5000余米的海拔垂直高差,拥有着壮丽的山川和独特的 ...[详细]
-
本报讯近日,中央广播电视总台新闻中心《新春走基层》栏目组一行走进雨城区多营镇葫芦村,采访拍摄“谱家乡的歌走自己的路”专题节目。拍摄现场,由葫芦村村民集体创作完成的村歌《葫芦颂》传唱开来,大家脸上洋溢着 ...[详细]
-
机器不停歇、工人不停工、原料不断供、内销外销不断流……进入2024年以来,雅化集团各生产基地生产经营呈现出一派热火朝天的繁忙景象。2024年是中华人民共和国成立75周年,是实现“十四五”规划目标任务的 ...[详细]
-
Newborns hit new low, but births to those unmarried reach record high: data
(Getty Images)Births to those not married accounted for nearly 5 percent of all births last year, se ...[详细] -
书法爱好者们为居民写春联本报讯春节将至,年味渐浓。2月1日上午,雅安经开区在永兴街道开展“我们的节日·春节”主题志愿服务活动,通过丰富多彩的活动,为当地群众奉上“文化大餐”的同时,也向他们送去浓浓的新 ...[详细]
-
G549线石棉境内段改建工程四标段正式通车,有效缓解了当地的交通拥堵问题本报讯2月6日,G549线石棉境内段改建工程四标段完成外业交工验收,标志着本标段正式建成通车。G549线石棉境内段改建工程四标段 ...[详细]
-
本报讯1月27日,由雅安市作家协会和雨城区民宗局、雅安市佛教协会联合举办的迎春诗会在雨城区澄清寺举行。诗会上,钟渔、刘江岳、黑辞、王进等雅安诗人和嘉宾声情并茂地朗诵了自己创作或喜爱的经典诗歌,并通过古 ...[详细]
-
'Terminator Zero' creators find fresh life in sci
In the 40 years since a low-budget action film from a relatively unknown filmmaker and crew blasted ...[详细] -
“遇到法律问题可以打什么电话咨询?”“可以打12348”一名村民前来询问,司法局工作人员为群众耐心解答。新春将至,连日来,雅安市司法局会同有关县区)和部门组织机关党员干部深入基层开展普法宣传活动,播撒 ...[详细]