Twitter tests a way to minimize the voices of trolls
Twitter has put its trolls on notice.
On Tuesday, Twitter released promising preliminary results from a test of its new proactive troll filtering tactic. It wanted to see if filtering (but not deleting) content from accounts that exhibited "trolling behavior" could make Twitter more of a platform for conversation and sharing, less an adversarial cesspool.
SEE ALSO:A new study reveals how Russian trolls manipulated our Twitter conversationsTweet may have been deleted
In March, CEO Jack Dorsey announced that Twitter would work to measure and then improve the "conversational health" of the platform. The initiative came in response to the revelations of how Russian troll farms had used the platform to inflame the American public. Dorsey's tweet storm announcing the initiative also seemed to say that Dorsey was taking an earnest look in the mirror at what the platform he created had become, and what it had done to the world. That was a welcome change of tune for the same company that had just a month prior continued to obfuscate Russian trolls' use of Twitter.
Dorsey said that he wanted Twitter to undergo something of a reckoning, in which it had to actually define what it wanted "healthy conversation" to be. At least publicly, the definition of "conversational health" is still something Twitter is working out; in April, David Gasca, Twitter’s product manager for health, said that Twitter had received 230+ responses to its March Request for Proposals on how to best define, measure, and then improve conversational health on Twitter.
Tweet may have been deleted
But it appears that the experiment is already underway. For its first improvements to "conversational health," Twitter decided to see if it could reduce the amount of "disruptive behavior" by trolls.
"Some troll-like behavior is fun, good and humorous," Gasca, and Del Harvey, VP of trust and safety, wrote in a post announcing the test. "What we’re talking about today are troll-like behaviors that distort and detract from the public conversation on Twitter, particularly in communal areas like conversations and search."
To do so, it says it found a way to identify accounts that exhibit trolling behavioral markers. These markers include not having email verified accounts, a high volume of tweets directed at people the accounts don't follow, and more.
It then delisted the content posted by these accounts from search. And, since so much trolling takes place in the responses to tweets, responses created by these accounts would only be visible by clicking the "see more responses" option.
Apparently, in its testing markets, Twitter saw a 4% drop in abuse reports from search, and 8% drop from comments. That's nothing to sneeze at!
The post announcing the test explained the key challenge: how to minimize the voices whose only aim was to inflame or bully, but who weren't actually posting content or behaving in ways that violated Twitter's terms of service. Or, as Gasca and Harvey wrote, "how can we proactively address these disruptive behaviors that do not violate our policies but negatively impact the health of the conversation?"
Filtering rather than deleting content or suspending accounts essentially shrinks the microphone of trolls looking to stir up trouble. They can still post to their heart's content — so there's no "censorship" here — but the likelihood that people will see (and engage with) their content is just a bit lower.
Then again, Twitter trolls obviously don't agree that this isn't censorship. Ok.
Tweet may have been deleted
Filtering based on behavioral markers is also a proactive tactic. This addresses a frequent criticism of social and digital media companies: that they reactto violate or inappropriate content, instead of preventing it in the first place. Specifically, some asked why so many Facebook group's ties to Russia weren't noticed earlier, since they contained obvious markers such as paying for ads about American protests in Roubles. And on YouTube, horrifying videos have made it onto the platform's kids channels, racking up thousands of views by kids before parents noticed and reported the content.
Of course, proactively preventing abuse without chilling amounts of profiling, or raising cries of censorship, is a difficult challenge. Even in this new experiment by Twitter, trolls could get wise to Twitter's behavioral flagging, and adjust their behavior to appear more organic. Mashable has asked Twitter if there are additional indicators not mentioned in the post, and whether Twitter will intentionally keep some of its markers private to avoid manipulation by sneaky, determined trolls. We'll update this post when and if we hear back.
Additionally, abuse reports can certainly reflect whether users are having a bad time on Twitter — but it takes a big, trolling push to get users to actually report an account, instead of just ignore it. It's not clear yet by what other markers Twitter might measure conversational health.
UPDATE 5/16/2018 1:00 p.m. ET:A Twitter spokesperson said that there are a large amount of signifiers that an account engages in trolling behavior. Because of the multiple signifiers, Twitter does not believe that sharing a few examples will harm its ability to identify trolls.
(责任编辑:资讯)
-
Best smart home deals this week
Our top picks:Best smart speaker dealEcho Dot (5th gen) with a free Sengled Smart Color Bulb$49.99 a ...[详细] -
自古以来,过年就是中国人的头等大事,有着专属的仪式感,以及各种独具特色的年俗。过去,有的家庭三十或大年初一,晚辈给长辈拜年下跪磕头,长辈再给压岁钱,这样的传统仪式意义非凡。传统拜年礼仪分三种:一是叩拜 ...[详细]
-
开展“厉行节约、勤俭办企”专项行动,是中建集团深入学习贯彻党的十九届六中全会和中央经济工作会议精神,完整准确全面贯彻新发展理念,切实践行国家全面节约战略,保持艰苦奋斗本色,推动 ...[详细]
-
本报讯“谢谢詹大哥,如果不是你出手相救,我可能就没命了!”“不用谢,举手之劳,相信在危急时刻,谁都会这样做!”15日下午,一名小伙来到名山区马岭镇中岭社区,将一面写着“见义勇为施援手,弘扬社会正能量” ...[详细]
-
Naver, Kakao strive to combat deepfake porn spreading online
(Getty Images Bank)The rise of explicit and nonconsensual deepfake pornography illegally being share ...[详细] -
本报讯日前,记者从雨城区法院获悉,7月19日,被执行人王某携二十万元现金到雨城区法院自觉履行执行义务,并与申请执行人杨某就剩下的二十八万元达成执行和解协议,杨某同意解除对王某的所有强制措施,方便其进行 ...[详细]
-
市北区6场直播吸引2.4万求职者 线上引才激发产才融合新动能
中国山东网-感知山东5月13日讯开展“作风能力提升年”活动以来,市北区围绕“转作风、提能力、促发展”,大力培育“严真细实快”工作 ...[详细] -
本报讯“谢谢詹大哥,如果不是你出手相救,我可能就没命了!”“不用谢,举手之劳,相信在危急时刻,谁都会这样做!”15日下午,一名小伙来到名山区马岭镇中岭社区,将一面写着“见义勇为施援手,弘扬社会正能量” ...[详细]
-
Best smart home deal: The Amazon Smart Thermostat is just $63.99
SAVE 20%: The Amazon Smart Thermostat is on sale for $63.99 at Amazon, down from the normal price of ...[详细] -
闈掑矝楂樻柊鍖哄皬闆ㄦ枃鍖栬壓鏈暀鑲叉垚鏋滃睍绮惧僵涓婃紨
銆€銆€涓浗灞变笢缃戦潚宀?2鏈?鏃ヨ(璁拌€ 鏉ㄥ箍绉? 杩戞棩锛?ldquo;灏忛洦娑︾墿鏃犲0锛屽痉鑹哄弻棣ㄦ湁瑷€”楂樻柊鍖哄皬闆ㄦ枃鍖栬壓鏈暀鑲叉垚鏋滃睍鏆ㄨ繋鏂板勾鏂囪壓 ...[详细]