Court finds ban on leafleting into NK unconstitutional, ban on praise for NK constitutional
A South Korean court on Tuesday found a law banning private entities from sending leaflets or other items by balloon into North Korea unconstitutional.
In a 7-2 decision, the Constitutional Court found the Development of Inter-Korean Relations Act, promulgated in 2020 during the liberal Moon Jae-in administration, unconstitutional. Scores of North Korean human rights groups filed the complaint with the Constitutional Court immediately after the law came into effect.
After the conservative President Yoon Suk Yeol succeeded Moon, his administration's unification minister, Kwon Young-se, submitted an opinion to the court, saying the leafletting ban "infringes on freedom of expression" and “violates the principles of proportionality between responsibility and punishment.”
Under the rule, those who violate the so-called "anti-leaflet law" are subject to at most three years of imprisonment or a fine of 30 million won ($22,160) or less.
Meanwhile, the same court on Tuesday found a law to ban the act of praising or propagating the North Korean regime under the National Security Act constitutional. The decision is the latest development in the row over what constitutes as anti-government activities, since the latest revision of the rule in 1991.
Under the current security law, a person who praises, incites or propagates the activities of North Korea or its affiliated organizations, or those who instigate a rebellion against the South Korean government, will be punished for up to seven years in prison. Those making, possessing or distributing documents, drawings or expression materials to praise North Korea are subject to penalties.
The same rule defines North Korea as an "anti-government organization" that fraudulently uses a government title.
Those who founded or joined anti-government organizations intended to praise North Korea could face at least one year of imprisonment.
The suit marks the eighth of its kind. Those who were convicted of the security law violation claimed that specific clauses in the law violates the principle of "no punishment without law," and fails to provide a principle of certainty under which the law must provide a clear framework to regulate people's conduct.
The Human Rights Commission of Korea in 2022 also blasted the same clauses for "breaching the freedom of speech and freedom of conscience with a violation of the principle of certainty and the principle of proportionality" during the court trial.
The Ministry of Justice, however, argued that the government intervention to address what has already become an existential threat due to the anti-government campaign would be rendered useless, so excessive regulation preemptively on such activities are essential.
(责任编辑:关于我们)
- New Grok response directs users to Vote.gov for election questions
- Nike and Apple ask: Are we running today? Internet responds: No.
- Sacked NK military official returns to No. 2 post of military
- Sacked NK military official returns to No. 2 post of military
- Netanyahu’s Inferno
- Understanding Relational vs. Non
- Samsung Gear VR is now so much easier to use
- 规范支付业务 保障消费者权益
- Messi's 20
- US to oppose North Korean worker dispatch to occupied Ukrainian territory: State Dept.
- Ariana Grande and Mac Miller declare their love with a leg hug
- Try not to have sleepless nights after reading this man's tale about his haunted apartment
- Colin Kaepernick says he'll donate profits from NFL's hottest
-
Who is the Dark Wizard in 'The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power' Season 2?
Just when The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Powerreveals the identity of one mysterious wizard, it ...[详细] -
WikiLeaks dump shows how CIA compromised iPhones and Macs
WikiLeaks' latest document dump allegedly shows the CIA has devoted a lot of time to going after App ...[详细] -
Kim's sister denounces UNSC meeting on NK's ICBM launch
Kim Yo-jong, North Korean leader Kim Jong-un's sister and vice department director of the ruling Wor ...[详细] -
17 percent of MERS patients medical staff: gov’t
So far, 17 percent of the Middle East respiratory syndrome patients in Korea have been found to be m ...[详细] -
A Global Tour of Bakeries With Fascinating Histories
Baked goods may be infinitely varied across the globe, but many of them carry a powerful cultural re ...[详细] -
Watch the moment an Amazon drone delivers sunscreen for the first time
Amazon has taken another small autonomous step toward drone delivery. The company completed its firs ...[详细] -
Ruling party to push for vote on PM nominee
A top ruling party official vowed Thursday that his party will push to hold a vote this week to conf ...[详细] -
Chinese ship might have to pay $120 million in Great Barrier Reef clean
The Australian government wants millions of dollars from a Chinese company after its ship, the Shen ...[详细] -
Sports minister says audits into football, badminton federations set to conclude in Sept.
Yu In-chon (right), minister of culture, sports and tourism, speaks during a plenary session for the ...[详细] -
Park to delegate full authority to medical experts over MERS
President Park Geun-hye said Monday that she will give full authority to medical experts over the ME ...[详细]
- 夜间献血模式“上线”
- Park to delegate full authority to medical experts over MERS
- Pension reform, other bills sent to Cabinet for promulgation
- Barshim, Tamberi 'love
- 蒙顶山茶有了专属茶器
- In other celebrity breakup news, Amber Heard and Elon Musk have reportedly broken up
- Defense chief orders robust posture of intelligence, cybersecurity forces